Papa Saverio’s Pizzeria

I don’t know why this place doesn’t get better reviews. I’ve only had their thin crust and pan crust, but both are excellent! They’re a little pricey (considering all the competition) but their pizzas have great flavor and really fill you up.

Well, I should have read these reviews prior to ordering. What a letdown. Ordered a speciality thin crust (extra crispy) Gardunar and their «specialty sausage. The pizza crust was like cardboard, the toppings were decent at best, just an all around bad experience. Will have to try other locations and check quality. Will not order from again.

Worst Papa Saverio’s location I have been too. I used to work near the location off of Meacham which is the one I preferred. I have now gone to this location for lunch 3 or 4 times for a quick slice. They have the oddest hours, never seem to have pizza ready as there is always a wait, and today I encountered a very rude employee. I politely asked for a slice and they informed me they were out and I stated well it is still an hour left until you stop serving slices, and that I didn’t mind waiting and she abruptly interrupted me and stated they were completely out and would not be making more. I hate writing this review because I hate going to larger chains like Pizza Hut, Domino’s, or especially Papa Johns. But I now see how this terrible food and service is a pattern and I won’t be returning.

GROSS!
GASTROENTERITIS & GUT WRENCHING FLATULENCE
I ordered a Pepper and Egg sandwich and it was smothered and nearly drowned to death in red-​sauce making the bun wet and soggy.
The salads dripping with water come with «packets» of CHEAP generic dressing.
Last but not least, let’s talk about their ‘COLD’ Calamari. I find it rather odd that the two of us who shared an order started to bloat and cramp up and by morning time, we were on a mad dash to the toilets sounding like the grand finale at 4^th of July. Throughout the day, my stomach rumbled like a Harley driving to Sturgis.
I’m sorry, I can not recommend this place. EVER.

Horrible. Hour and a half waiting still no pizza and I live exactly a mile away. Never again. Also charged me ten dollars extra. This is the worst service I’ve ever had.

This place is just bad. Ordered the cheese breadsticks and garlic bread. They took around 30min to get it out. The owner (or manager) kept saying that it was being made from «scratch».
It wasn’t fresh, if anything it felt like a few days old bread. The sticks were rock hard with no cheese on them. The garlic bread felt stale with almost no trace of garlic. Expensive, bad service and cheap food.

Buffalo wings inferno was fried wings with tabasco sauce. Chicago deep dish was more dough than pizza. Very sloppy. Have plenty of napkins or better yet a straw!

There slogan works well for this location. Only thing that kept me to 4 stars was the delivery, sometimes late, sometimes not hot. Overall good experiences though.

Something happened to this place… new owners, bad help… not sure, but there has been a drastic change in quality over the last few months. We’ve been ordering pizza here fairly regularly over the past 3 or 4 years and always thought the pizza to be not over the top great but a very good pizza at a fair price. Recently, something changed there as the ingredients suddenly were different… boring sauce, spicy and cheap tasting sausage and cheese that seemed for lack of a better description… old. The last time I was there, they didn’t even cut the pizza the same way. They made it easy for us to find another couple of places other to try.

I’ve given this Papa’s several chances. (4)
I’ve ordered for delivery on off-​peak hours, and every single time I’ve gotten my food at least an hour and 15 to an hour and 20 minutes after I ordered. (Keep in mind– I’ve only ordered a small pizza, and a side of poppers.) not only did my food arrive late, it was cold. Every time. I’ve called and politely let them know how I was dissatisfied, hoping that they’d make this right. No one seemed to care. I would not recommend this location, and will absolutely not order from them again. Worst. Service. Ever.

Their delivery is slow and when they deliver the wrong pizza is in the wrong marked box. They like to argue with the customer !!! I will never order from Papa Saverio Pizzeria !!!

Same menu items as every other pizzeria. However every other pizzeria I have ate from is thousands of times better that what I have gotten the three times I have ordered from Papa Severios.

Amazing Calzone tonight with the family! This place will become a staple in our house when we want a carb day!

There’s nothing better than pizza delivery on a Saturday when it’s cold outside and laundry to do inside. There are many places to choose from in my area but my top pick is Papa Saverio’s. One important incentive: coupons attached to the pizza box that I always save and use on my next order. Will it be Free Delivery or Free 2-​Liter Soda today?
I don’t trust online ordering. Too many variables to mess things up with my order, my payment, my delivery… So when I call in, I am always greeted by a friendly voice who gives me peace of mind.
Today, I ordered one of their Speciality Pizzas: a 12″ (you can go bigger) Beef & Giardiniera. It’s roasted Italian Beef with Hot (you can choose Sweet or Both) Giardiniera peppers and Mozzarella cheese with a Can of Coke and Jalapeño Poppers with Cheddar cheese (they offer cream cheese too). A lot of food for one person but I have enough for leftovers; so, I decided to save money and redeem their Free Delivery coupon.
People who complain about slow delivery apparently are ignorant to having their pizza made fresh, cooked and delivered with other orders. If you’re going to order during peak lunch and dinner times, your complaints sound ridiculous to the rest of us who know better. I placed my order at 2:12pm and it arrived at my door at 2:38pm. Slow delivery, say what?!
The Marinara sauce that accompanies the Poppers is delicous. The pizza is excellent!

The Negatives… Delivery is very slow. Prices are extremely high!
The Positives. The food is good. Menu choices are excellent for a delivery place.
Another negative is that they do not seem to be part of the Papa Saverio’s online network. You can’t order online.

Ordered a Thin Crust Pizza from Papa Saverio’s Monday night.
Yummy!
They have lots of coupons!
Fast Delivery!
Hot, Crispy and Cheesy!
Left over still yummy!

Their pizza IS good and I’d have given this place a 3 or 4 star rating if the service were better. I have, on several occasions, needed to order pizza for group lunches and I could not get anyone on the phone well after their opening time. Not easily put-​off the trail of good pizza, one time I actually just went to the store after calling and getting no answer, figuring maybe they were just too busy to answer the phone. When I got there, the lights were on and someone was working inside. He made eye contact with me and then walked into the back of the store. This was 15 minutes after their posted opening time. I stood there for a minute or two and then just left.
Again, really good pizza, I just wish it were a little easier to obtain at lunch.

We have been ordering Papa Saverios Pizza, pretty much every Friday before all Cross Country and Track meets. Performances using this pre-​meet meal have been exceptional.
The only «problem» is delivery, they always say 45 minutes or longer, but they come in about 25 minutes; sometimes the delivery guy needs to look for us.

I agree the pizza is great, the service is always friendly. Delivery time depends on when you are calling, obviously the weekend is when it takes about an hour, but they have never taken longer than that. Their breaded appetizers are the best! Love the breaded mushrooms & cauliflower.

Pizza is excellent — good crust, good cheese, tasty sauce. Delivery takes about an hour, in my experience.