Sugar On Top

Closed Mondays!!! need to update Unilocal so others don’t waste time like I did on a mon morning hoping to surprise coworkers with unique donuts!

Had to check this place out after seeing all the pretty donut photos on Instagram and the donuts did not disappoint, especially the must-​have Maple Bacon donut!
Plain donuts $ 1.00
Plain donuts w/​toppings $ 1.50
More prices available if you want ½ dozen or dozen
Select your choice of cake donut (I had a choice of Red velvet or Vanilla on a Sunday). Then pick your choice of glaze (maple, peanut butter, chocolate, strawberry cream, etc.) and toppings (coconut shreds, bacon bits, m&m, peanuts, etc.). Toppings are unlimited at no extra charge.
The donuts were smaller than I imagined, guess I’m used to the regular size dunkin donuts. Theses are about 3inches in diameter, which is good, because you won’t be over eating. The donuts are very rich, especially after glaze and topping, which they give a generous amount. 1 donut person is the perfect amount.
Highly recommend the maple bacon, which is their best seller. The donut was dunked in bacon bits after a maple glaze. And by dunked, I mean basically drenched in bacon bits! Great balance of sweet and savory. Great price especially for unlimited toppings! Definitely stop by for a sweet treat!
Tips: Come early, they close when they sell out. Bring water with you or buy at the store for $ 1.

There aren’t many mom and pop donut shops anymore. This is one of the few places I’ve found, especially outside of NYC with such a good homemade donut. Make sure to try the maple bacon donut. Totally worth the trip to this small town spot.

I’ve now been here 3 times and it’s still fantastic. Ironically, my first visit was exactly one year ago today, and our 3^rd and final visit (we’re moving, boohoo) was today. Today was even better than our first time. I wanted to make sure the husband had a chance to try it here before we left. I’d also like to point out that we live 90 mins away. If we lived closer, we’d go weekly, at least.
We made sure we’d make it when they were open and arrived about 11am– they close early, normally. Well, I asked if they needed to be refrigerated, because we were going to explore a little today. I just wanted to make sure they’d be okay in the car. The owner, who has to be the nicest woman I’ve met, told me she didn’t want them to melt in the hot car, and that they were open until 4pm today and for us to come back later. We had a whole discussion about how many donuts we were going to want when we returned (6) and about what time we’d be back. She warned that sometimes they close early if they run out of donuts, but they might be okay at 3pm when I was expecting to return.
Well, traffic sucked and we wound up being later than 3. When we showed up, the owner wasn’t there, but the sweet employee recognized me and said that they only had 4 donuts left– BUT, the the owner talked about us and they would be willing to offer us their display for the day, assortment of 12, for the price of the the 6 we were originally going to order. She was even so kind as to switch out one for a maple bacon since it wasn’t in the display — it’s the BEST!
This is the kind of customer service that makes this wonderful concept of a donut shop so amazing. I’m so grateful that I found this place a year ago today and urge you if you’re ever in the area– and if even you’re kind of close– drive there and try them out. It’s fantastic!

A must stop when you are in Strasburg! Even if you’re not a huge donut person like me you will still love it! My husband and I both got 2 each all different combinations and each one was independently wonderful. Just pick the flavor you love or go with their suggestions. We had: 1) Vanilla with bavarian cream, 2) red velvet with cream cheese and coconut sprinkles, 3) vanilla with maple icing and bacon sprinkles, and 4) lemon meringue. But we didn’t stop there these are for tomorrow. Lots of drink options to go with it! Coffee, milk, OJ and all your other Coke products. YUMMY!

This place is a donut lovers dream come true.
We stopped in on Saturday after a quick Unilocal search for donuts in the area. There is a chalkboard with a long list of all the different toppings, frostings, and flavor combinations they offer. They have cake donuts ready to be transformed into whatever you pick. We ended up getting a dozen donuts including maple bacon, oreo cheesecake, cannoli, red velvet, pumpkin, and blueberry pie.
The women working there were super friendly and helpful. They showed us an already prepared order of assorted donuts to give us an idea of what we could get. I was immediately sold after seeing the maple bacon. It was the perfect combination of sweet and savory!

A must stop for anyone! I’m not a huge donut fan but these aren’t your typical donuts. Light, fluffy and full of flavor!
We stopped here while doing a scooter tour and the moment you walk in the smells alone send you into heaven. So many choices and toppings, I had to take minute to soak it all in!
My boyfriend are the maple bacon one and I had the cannoli donut. There are no words to express the tastiness of each bite, not overly sweet. The donut really helps cut through what you might think are overly sweet flavors but the owner here hit it right on the head!
Highly recommend any one looking for a tasty treat and a near place to stop in!

Stopped by with the family on vacation. So glad we stopped. All of us got something different and they were all delicious. They all Come with crazy toppings and you can pick any topping you want and they make it right in front of you. For 5 donuts it cost us $ 6. We’re coming back tomorrow.

Must stop by for a treat, amazing endless choices of doughnuts that they make right in front of you. Must try the maple bacon doughnut!

First time and will definitely be returning! I had the maple bacon just because it seemed different and it was better than I could have imagined. My friend had the peanut butter frosted with chocolate chip… we split to try both. We agreed they were the perfect size, not too big and the donuts was light and not too doughy. Both flavors felt perfectly balanced. Can’t wait to visit again, I will have to increase my workouts!

We stopped in here on the recommendation of Sam from Pizza City and are glad we did! These aren’t your average doughnuts. These are gourmet doughnuts and you customize the frosting, glazes and toppings from a large variety of options. They have a light, cake-​like texture. Be sure to stop in if you are in the mood for a unique treat!