Tony’s at Brentwood

Pretty good pizza not exactly NY however nice to the palate. I will return and try something else. It was a bit salty for pizza that is the reason it wasn’t five stars the wings were good just alittle too much garlic but other than that the perfect wing. Service was good and fast a nice first experience.

Went here last night and the food was amazing! So glad we stopped in, it’s casual dining with wonderful service. We will definitely be back. Best pizza in town, and awesome tiramisu!

Pizza was good but the indoor seating was kind of scattered and the beer selection was poor. Not a place I would go out of my way to return to again. If I had a choice I would do an order to go. Prices were reasonable and they did have some good specials especially at lunch.

Excellent service excellent New York style pizza excellent Stromboli’s excellent prices and I had a glass of wine to top it off… no complaints here! I will definitely return!

Pizza’s are amazing n the garlic knots are so good. The staff is friendly n very helpful.

Excellent, fresh Italian food that was ridiculously inexpensive. Portions were huge. I hag eggplant parm that was loaded with mozzarella and fresh herbs. Also came with a side bowl of pasta… huge portion. My friend had baked ziti prepared with meat sauce, ricotta and mozzarella cheeses. He also ordered a side of meatballs and was served FOUR of them. Both dinners came with a large dinner salad and garlic bread. They also carried Peroni beer. The servers were so pleasant and friendly. Looking forward to returning here. Their pizza looked amazing.

Not a big fan of Italian food but the restaurant had great service! Also the food was delicious & well worth the price for the fair amount of portion. Highly recommend it!!!

I’ve had a hard time finding a decent non commercial restaurant since I moved to henry from cobb county. It’s like I have to go to Cobb for every thing. I’m sure anyone from metro ATL can tell you cobb is totally different than Henry. I’ll have to relocate soon, I miss cobb county. I decided to try this pizza place out according to the reviews and the previous garlic parmesan wing pics. Man, it’s like they just sprinkled garlic on my wings. I literally tossed my wings in the trash. The calzone (pepperoni, sausage and spinach) was very bland. Hey, at least I tried. Smh

Amazing amazing amazing philly cheesesteak pizza. I think I’ve found my pizza heaven at Tony’s. Wait time is well worth it. I’m turning my friends on to this awesome spot.

One of my favorite places around. Great salads, delicious meatball parm subs, the penne ala Tony is fantastic, and their pizza is fresh and delightful. I highly recommend this place. It’s a small location, but you can feel the love that goes into their food.

I’m not sure how I’ve lived here for years and didn’t know this place existed — I only just managed to catch a glimpse of it on my way home avoiding 75 traffic.
Well, I’m super glad I finally noticed it, because we decided to stop in tonight and it was DELICIOUS! I finally have a place that hits my pizza fix that is not all the way in Atlanta. We ordered an XL pepperoni (yay, leftovers!) The crust was my favorite part; it was crispy on the bottom, slightly chewy, and held up to the generous amount of cheese piled on it.
My boyfriend got a phillycheese, too, because if a philly is on a menu. he will get it. Im happy to say it was also yummy — stuffed with plenty of thinly sliced meat and melty cheese. The fries that came with it seemed like your typical frozen fries but they were hot, crisp, and perfectly salted.
Overall a great experience, and our waitress was super nice, too. Thanks Tony’s. :)

Glad I gave them a try. The BEST lemon pepper wings on this side of town! I used to drive all the way to memorial! Perfect Friday «Cheat Night». Although I had a taste today… I will probably stop by tomorrow!

LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Tony’s. I CRAVE Tony’s anything. Real New York, New Jersey pizza! I drive 1 hr to get there! Worth it! Great service– family owned biz from Jersey I believe.
I always order extra and freeze it! He frowns on that but I can’t just run down there anytime I want!
HIGHLY recommend you come and manga manga manga!!!
Off the beaten trail. Worth finding!
:O) Once you eat there finding it gets easy… you WILL be back!
LOVE the crispy dark bottom of my pizza… in a real oven. Not like these fake Suzy Home Maker oven pizzas elsewhere!

We’ve been getting our pizza here for the past few months. Not one bad experience! Finally good pizza in our area. We usually get 2 mediums which is plenty for our family of 4. My favorite is «the works»! The kids are picky so it’s always extra cheese for them. Great place!

Yesterday I had a taste for pizza I think everyone has one of those days, so I got on Unilocal researched pizza restaurants and there it was «Pizza Day». This restaurant is a little treasure, they have a very nice staff of workers (very attentive) it seems that everyone was smiling even the cook making this atmosphere very inviting.
RATINGS
*** Friendliness of the staff (5 stars)
They were polite and efficient
*** Cleanliness of restaurant (4 stars)
*** Food Quality (5 stars)
The pizza was awesome and the garlic Parmesan wings were finger licking good!

This was the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time! If you love New York style pizza then you must come and try this place. It’s not huge inside or fancy by any means but it’s all about the pizza. The waitress was really nice and friendly. I only wish I lived closer, I would be coming there quite a bit.

Yes, it hit the spot! Great Baked Ziti & good fresh pizza, all for a very very reasonable price.
Highlights: Pizza is made fresh, cooked crispy and ample quantity, Location was easy to find, Staff was friendly and enough sitting area.
Can improve: Garlic knots were not cooked all the the way and were very raw in the middle, need to staff better as during busy times the service suffers, store the cleaning supplies and water bucket out of site from the customers and dinning area.
Benchmark: For Atlanta area, Antico Pizza is still best in my book.
Dined in July 2015

A great little Unilocal find. We were stuck in traffic on 675 headed back to Atl so we took a «creative detour,» then decided to eat to kill time. Found this place thanks to Unilocal and had a nice pizza in a small place with a pleasant atmosphere. Doubt we’ll pass this way again, as Robt Frost said, but if we did, I’d go back!

Tony’s at Brentwood fresh pizza made to order, except the lunch specials slices, great salads, and many other dishes.
The place is small 34 seats, 6 large tables (4 place), 4 small tables (2 place) and several art prints on wall.
The pizza dough is made fresh and hand tossed, marinara sauce, and garlic knots. The biggest complaints are inconsistent service and food that is precooked (but that happens in 80% of restaurants). If you order a whole pizza it is made to order and ALWAYS fresh. Another complaint is the lasagna contains eggs and that’s not a deal breaker for me; however, its big enough to share.
The meatballs are home made style and made daily which are used on the pizzas as well as a topping. All the toppings are fresh which hold moisture and makes the pizza a little softer on the bottom.
Unilocal reviews are high on average 4 stars due to some of the reasons I cites. Tony the owner is here most of the time and his family in the kitchen. Tony is Italian and a 20+ year US Army veteran. He has worked in pizzerias in New York for many years. He takes a lot of pride in the food he serves and will make things right: just ask.
Based on everything I have seen and tasted in this restaurant I rate it 5 stars.
Signed,
A well traveled man. 5* stars.

We stopped in for dinner after a night of cruising, stalking T.I.‘s house. (lol)
Tony’s is located in a strip mall and it definitely has that feel to it. They had the best reviews but most claimed it to be the best NY style pizza around… the pizza was fine but not great and it lacked the «NY style» in my opinion. If I hadn’t seen the guy pounding and stretching the dough myself, I would have thought the crust was pre-​made. It was almost perfectly round and had that chain pizza look about it.
I ordered a calzone, it too was good, super cheesy and made with fresh mushrooms. My sister in law ordered a chicken alfredo which came with a salad, she liked it just fine. To top off my meal I had the tiramisu, it was good, lacked espresso flavor but good nonetheless.
After eating here, I realized that folks around here don’t have much to choose from so this is probably the best they can get and/​or all these five star reviews are fake since most are from faceless profiles with very few reviews.