Tony’s Brick Oven

Best pizza on the east coast
And the food is the best. great prices
Warm and friendly place to have lunch or dinner
love this place !!!

This place is the most amazing local family-​owned pizzeria here in Staten Island. They certainly make some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I usually get the large pizza with pepperoni, Italian sausage and mushrooms. The staff are all friendly and accommodating, and Tony always comes up front to make sure everything’s okay. It never ceases to amaze me that Tony knows literally every one of his customers’ names, which just speaks to his character.

The best pizza spot on Bay Street… This pizza is amazing and those garlic knots melt your mouth. The owner is always there making sure everything runs smooth. Always go back

Speciality pizza fell short of what was expected! Seemed to have been preheated then toppings placed on top !! Go to Denino’s instead !!

I definitely liked this restaurant. As I am not familiar with Staten Island I was looking for something to eat and stumbled upon this place on Unilocal.Its not very big or very fancy but it is definitely authentic. I ended up going with the chicken parmigian sandwich. The chicken was really good and so was the sauce, this would definitely be a good choice. I also shared the fried raviolis which is hands down some of the best raviolis that I have ever had. I loved that dish and I definitely plan to return again just to have that. Service was friendly and the food came out quickly. Overall a good choice if your in the mood for Italian and your in Staten Island!

Only have ordered pick up. Tried delivery twice, both times the said over 45 minutes.
1^st got a half margarita and half vodka. Both yummy but the vodka was a tad salty, still good though. Also had a rice ball which was yummy.
2^nd time we got half white and half clam. Both actually very good. Also got an order of calamari that was ehh, I will skip that next time. A bit fishy. Marinara that came with it was really good! A little spicy for a «mild» sauce but I like spicy.
Good prices.

Came here on a Saturday evening, looking for some good pizza. We were not disappointed. We had a margarita pizza, half margarita half cheese pizza brick oven pie. We had mushrooms and onions on the margarita pie. There is a parking lot which is a great advantage. The place itself is very casual and plain. The waitress was good she served us our first slice of pizza from the pie we ordered. The one thing I did not like we ordered a pie with half margarita and half cheese pie to accommodate the children who did not want margarita, we got charged for the much more expensive margarita pie. The soda is served in bottles as well. I would love to have some more of their pizza, would definitely come back. It tasted great and made fresh. The place also serves wine. Von breisen park is a few minutes away by car as well. The location of the pizza is right off the bus s51 stop which is another advantage.

Visited SI for the first time. This came highly recommend. Order the lunch special. Would definitely come back again. Excellent crust.

Gross soggy pizza. Ordered a pie and will never order again.
Disgrace for ny pizza. How do you give this place almost 5stars.
Cheese was nasty as well
21 $ with tip for a small pie.
Wouldn’t feed this to my dog

Nasty workers. Not customer friendly. I called to order over the phone and the worker kept trying to rush me off the phone after 2 seconds. Definitely will never suggest this place to anyone.

Recently moved to this area. Im glad i found this place cuz its really good. Clean and has lots on their menu. I like the salad pizza it tastes like bruschetta but its pizza. This place has a good area of parking space! I suggest you go eat there instead of delivery cuz it always tastes best to eat by slices!

They make the best chicken parm in the world. No other restaurant has ever been able to beat Tony’s brick oven. My family orders from here almost every other week for the past 15 years and don’t plan on stopping.

Food is always AMAZING and the staff is just as wonderful. Especially love Angelo & his boys. Been going here for years, never been disappointed.

Came here for lunch with my guys. Not the cleanest or nicest place. The staff could be friendlier for sure. I was surprised on how good the pizza was though. Definitely would get there pie again.

One of the best pizzas in NY!
Just the plain cheese slice alone is soooooooo good! (One of the best I’ve ever had).
The eggplant parmigiana is delicious too!

Always the best dinners here, I try to eat dinner at Tony’s once a month. Service and the food is great. Thank you again.

Danielle is the best waitress ever!
Very helpful and professional.
And super hot!
Food was great!

We LOVE Grandpa Pizza!!!
Between my husband and my 10yr and 2 yr old and myself, we down a whole pie in a blink of an eye so I had to go pick up some more.
I don’t live in the area so I can’t go there often. But every time I go back, there is always same guy (probably the owner and maybe his son) greets you. And never forgets to say «Thank you.»
We don’t have really good pizza in our town so our family will miss Tony’s Brick Oven Pizza.

Definitely a FAVORITE!
Food was DELICIOUS!
It was soooo good, we here twice while visiting NYC.

We spent the day in Manhattan and were looking for a quick pizza to carry back to the room when we stumbled upon Tony’s Brick Oven.
We ordered two pizzas to go and they were ready right when he said they would be. The pizzas were great! They were brick oven fired quality pizzas. Everyone in our group had nothing but good things to say.
Service was great. We did have a minor communication problem. He could not understand my southern accent and I couldn’t understand his Italian accent. You have to love a New York Italian guy telling me I have a heavy accent. It was pretty funny. Food was great. If you are in the Bay Street area of Staten Island, this little pizza place should be on your radar.