Right off the bat I was a little disappointed when I wanted to get a turkey sub and they told me they don’t have that sub anymore… and there’s literally only 7 subs total on the menu(now 6 apparently). I just didn’t get why they’d remove that particular sub and not the others? Anyways, we got a pizza and their«buffalo» wings, which were subpar. The pizza was pretty good, but being from Buffalo, NY I have high standards for buffalo wings and it didn’t meet them too well. All in all it was pretty good and the delivery was fast but then again we were lazy and it was literally a block away so I can’t really comment too much on that. We got a discount on the wings for getting the pizza and that was nice!
Brad P.
Classificação do local: 3 Saint Petersburg, FL
Great service but average pizza wouldn’t order from here again. Very expensive 25 $ for a large 2 topping pizza!
David W.
Classificação do local: 5 Jacksonville, FL
Fantastic slices. great little spot close to downtown and right in a walkable residential n’hood! My wife is speechless, literally.. for a change!
Debi C.
Classificação do local: 5 St. Petersburg, FL
We’ve been in St Pete for 9 months and are so happy to have found Old Norteast Pizza. My NY friends will say there is no way it’s true«NY pizza» but I’m telling you it really is! OK, maybe my taste buds have been corrupted but this really is a little bit of home for this NYC transplant. Cash Only! Delivery or Grab and Go only(Just like lots of pizza places in NYC)
Paula B.
Classificação do local: 5 Ponce, Puerto Rico
Craving a really authentic NY pizza? This place is incredible! Only had the pizza but it was exactly what I was dying for!
Siri G.
Classificação do local: 4 Orlando, FL
Good pizza, nice and crispy, and friendly workers. What’s nots to like? You can order slices which are large and loaded with toppings, something I enjoy. Also good selection of toppings. Tried a couple other things, but I think the regular slices are the highlight. Have to remove a star for cash only. Yes I know they are a small local business but I prefer the ease of credit transactions.
Franklin A.
Classificação do local: 5 Saint Petersburg, FL
Best local pizza around, you can just taste how fresh it is, and that it is actually hand tossed
Michael R.
Classificação do local: 4 St. Petersburg, FL
This is my go to spot for delivery. Nothing super special but good pizza at a good price. Better than any of the chain delivery alternatives.
Michael R.
Classificação do local: 5 New Port Richey, FL
Amazing Pizza. Fresh grated cheese, fresh homemade sauce and plenty of toppings. I order every week, never been disappointed. The manager is a friendly person who is very passionate about the quality of the product he offers.
Rigby N.
Classificação do local: 3 Tampa, FL
The pizza is very good but they lose two stars for being difficult every step of the way. They don’t have a menu online like every other place does, you have to download their app to see the menu. But you can’t order through the app so you have to look at the app then call them. They only accept cash just to add to the hassle. And no matter how clear and simple I make the directions to my apartment, the delivery guys don’t even try. They just call and make me come outside… if I’m ordering food, it’s because I didn’t want to have to get up and go downstairs.
Amanda R.
Classificação do local: 5 Saint Petersburg, FL
We went in looking for quarters, and came out 3 hours later with an AMAZING handcrafted goat cheese, basil, garlic, tomato pizza that was to die for. This is the real NY/NJ deal, as far as pizzas go! Thanks for persuading us «subliminally» at the first quarter request, it was«heaven on earth» as my roommate said.
Mark S.
Classificação do local: 4 Hartford, CT
This pizza reminded me of New York(specifically of Italian Village on 80th and 1st though not sure if it’s still there). Very greasy and heavy on the cheese. You may need a knife and fork to navigate through their good-sized slices. I liked it, though it’s a very specific style of pizza. Bonus points for the 1980s video game availability for only a quarter.
Jen R.
Classificação do local: 4 Saint Petersburg, FL
If you like greasy, BIG, fold-in-half kind of New York style pizza, this is it. PROS: –You can buy by the slice –Quick –Free delivery to Old Northeast Tavern next door CONS: –Cash only(though there is an ATM) –Really no seating area(basically carry-out or delivery)
Valerie R.
Classificação do local: 3 Saint Petersburg, FL
Decent pizza, one of our family(a celiac) could not join us because they do not offer a gluten-free option. We will look elsewhere for the next pizza night
Tony M.
Classificação do local: 4 Niceville, FL
Thanks to the reviews on this site we found this place! What a nice suprise. It’s New Jersey style, not NY, which means the flavor is a little different but size is the same. We walked into it thinking we would grab a table and chow down. Nope, no tables but since the pub next door is same owner we sat there, put a few good local brews down and enjoyed the meal. Just a short walk from the ritzy and artsy scene.
Stephanie V.
Classificação do local: 5 St. Petersburg, FL
If you like New York style, have to fold-in-half-and-let-the-grease-run-off OH-frickin-YEAH pizza — Then this is your place. The thing I love is that they are consistent with sauce and crust so I know what I am getting every time. Pro-tips: 1. They ONLYTAKECASH! — Don’t fret, there’s an ATM inside 2. They WILL deliver to Old Northeast Tavern if you are enjoying a brew. 3. They deliver — Cash only though so get those greens out. 4. You CAN order by the slice.
Anna C.
Classificação do local: 5 Tampa, FL
Great pizza! Matt is the best. Fun guy to chat with. Highly recommend. Reasonably priced and good.
Cindy S.
Classificação do local: 5 St. Petersburg, FL
I grew up in NYC. Thank you Old NE Pizza for making a cheese pizza so close to what I grew up with! They’re Big slices you have to fold, with just the right amt of cheese and sauce. The heros are great too, with homemade meatballs and crispy crust bread. So lucky to have this gem eight in my neighborhood! Cash only, but that’s fine with me.
John L.
Classificação do local: 2 St. Petersburg, FL
I don’t know where you people have eaten pizza to say this place is so good, but it was definitely below average. Ordered extra cheese and I had more sauce than cheese. The sauce had a spaghetti-os consistency and taste to it and the crust made me chew so much, my jaw hurt afterwards. Definitely will not be back. My search for a great pizza place in St. Pete continues. PS — I was even kind of drunk when I ate it, so what does that tell you?
Ash D.
Classificação do local: 4 St Petersburg, FL
This is one of my favorite places to order from. I’m your typical Italian New Yorker, so amazing pizza is what I grew up on. They have a fantastic range of toppings, I’ve never gotten a cold pie, and I’ve been completely satisfied with the quality and service nearly every time. There is one reason they received a 4 star rating from me instead of 5, and that’s the credit card thing. The bar takes cards, I never carry cash, and it’s very inconvenient because I basically have to plan in advance whether I’m going to order here or not. They would definitely see much more business from me in the future were they were able to process credit. and I order at least one pie a week in general.