Goodfellas Pizzeria & Wings

Food was lousy !!! We will NEVER go back. pasta was over cooked, sauce was awful, nothing Italian about this place. The Abidance was like something in someone garage. Pass this one up!

Been here a couple times in the last few months .last night being our most recent.
He was shocked at the size of the pizza and the size of slices! Really good pizza too. Super friendly waitress.
Good house wine too

Not impressed.
My sausage pepper sandwich was mediocre and it didn’t help that I could tell the Italian sausage was so old and frozen that it left an after taste.
My wife’s Philly cheese was also mediocre. She stated the bread was just too much for the sandwich. The rest tasted edible-​ish.
Our calamari was undercooked and we didn’t receive enough marinara to finish them off. On top of that; the calamari was mostly breading and not calamari.
The French fries were the best part of this meal.
You get what you pay for. $ 25 wasted on mediocre. Should have known.
Staff was so very nice and accommodating though.

3 strikes your out. Gave them a fair shot. Let down everytime, Just got the lunch special. Pizza was burnt everytime. The ovens need to be cleaned. The floors were so dirty I latterly stuck to the floor. Never again.

First time eating here as I’m new to the area. I’ll start with the positive and that the flavor of the pizza itself was great. Great cheese nice sauce. Ham was good. But that dough!!!
Man idk what is going on but I’ve read other reviews that the dough isn’t that great and my trip wasn’t any different. Seemed very mushy. Almost like it could have been left in the oven for another 5+ min.
On a side note we ordered breaded wings (medium which I usually don’t) and they were not bad at all especially for the price. Will I return… maybe just would ask for them to leave the pizza in the oven longer.

Man the meanest mom n pop pizza joint ever just like back up north… Love it and they deliver!

We used to go here when we first moved to the area in the early 2000’s. It was good then and judging from the pizza we got last night it’s even better. One of the first signs of a good pizza is the weight. When you pick up the box and the pizza feels heavy there’s a good chance you’ve got a pizza with ample amounts of cheese and toppings. Needless to say Goodfella’s pizza felt noticeably heavier than the pizzas I’ve been getting recently. The crust was thin, but not too thin and the toppings were very tasty. We got sausage, green peppers and onions on our pie. I can’t vouch for their other offerings but the pizza is as good as you’re going to get in this area. It’s a bit out of our way but that won’t keep us from going back.

If you want over priced over cooked pasta with sauce that tastes like its watered down from a can youre in the right place. I ordered the fetticini Alfredo. The pasta was so overcooked it was mushy. The sauce was watered down and did not save the dish. They could not have screwed up that pasta anymore if they tried. Trying to come up with things that taste worst than this is hard. MacDonalds, taco bell, hungry howies… any of those are more satisfying then the pasta i had at goodfellas… most disappointing food i have ever bought.

The pizza is fine. It won’t blow your socks off but it ain’t like eating cardboard box. It was good to see something throwing dough in the back, and the service was joyful considering how slow it seemed.
Normally I’d give it 3 stars but for some reason people are giving it 1 star for the most self-​entitled, cry baby, dramatic reasons that I’ve seen on Unilocal in a while. Just flipping through the reviews shows just how childish the people are that the workers deal with.
All in all it was good.

The pizza dough was very dry and crumbly rather than soft and crispy. The garlic cheese focaccia bread was bland. Over priced for the quality.

Ate lunch today and wish I hadn’t! Ordered the Carved chicken sandwich ~they brought me the Italian by mistake and then brought me a chicken wrap. I’ve had better quality food at Wendys!
The lettuce was old, frayed with black edges! The tomato was mushy and I asked the waitress if they used ‘carved turkey’ as stated on the menu, she said yes. It was deli turkey!
Save your time and money~go somewhere else! The place was empty at lunchtime, that should have been a sign not to eat here!

This review is based solely upon appetizers and a few drinks. They may, for all I know, have the most amazing pizza that makes me hear sounds and jump around like a unicorn, but I doubt I’d find out.
Stopped here after Taster’s looking for a shot and came to find out they didn’t have a full bar menu. So I settled for a Goose Island (gotta love the honker) and ordered some Jalapeño poppers and some garlic knots. The poppers were good but came out super hot and I had to wait for them to cool down. The garlic knots were meh. They weren’t bad, per se, they just weren’t anything to really write home about. For a Saturday night, the ambiance was also, bleh. Nothing much to keep me there after my beer was finished.
As I’m in my Tampa Bay exploration phase, I doubt I’m going to waste an exploration slot going back here.

Order pizza for delivery. Pizza was way under cooked. Still doughie. Pizza was also delivered 30 minutes late and was cold. Disappointed.

Love this place! My wife and I recently moved to the area from Chicago and this is the best pizza we’ve had so far. Reheat your leftover slices in the oven and it’s almost better the second time around!

The dough appears to be hand made and is pretty good which leaves me questioning why you guys used canned and frozen toppings. I ordered a veggie pizza with a couple of extra toppings and I could tell every single topping was canned or frozen. That’s pretty crappy. If you are going to go through the trouble to produce an authentic crust, do yourselves a favor and use fresh ingredients for your toppings. There are way too many pizza places in the area competing for business. Do something to stand out!

If I could give zero stars, then I would. I’d rather eat any chain pizza than eat here, and I hate chains. It’s within walking distance from my work & it’s not even an option.

Not really a review but a comment I hope someone at the shop reads., 7pm Saturday night and for the last 20 minutes NOBODY is picking up the phone. BAD BUSINESS!!!
We order frequently… such a shame!

I’ve only gotten take out here once so I’m going to give this place the benefit of the doubt. I also wasn’t the one to pick up the pizza so I can’t comment on the restaurant itself. I was hoping this place would be great as it is close by, but after having the margherita pizza, I wasn’t very impressed. It seemed like they were skimpy on the toppings, especially the cheese. The crust was just ok and sauce was alright, but really nothing to write home about. I’ve heard good things about other local pizza joints so I plan to try those before going back here.

I’ve had nothing but good experiences here. Came back over the weekend. Ordered a large pepperoni and some naked wings– half sweet chili glaze and half honey barbecue. Still love the wings, they are delicious! I wanted to order some to go so I could eat them at home later lol. Pizza is consistently yummy. Lots of gooey, cheesy goodness and the dough is good. We received awesome service again.
The restaurant is a decent size. There’s a bar area to the right of the entrance with some tv’s. No super large flat screens though so not sure if viewing of sports events would be good here? Décor is along the lines of their name. Lots of pictures of mafia types from the movies and a nice mural by the bar of some gangsters. I don’t know my gangster movies so sorry, couldn’t tell you who they were. Restaurant is clean, but was really dark when we were there. Not sure why unless it’s always dark like that during the day?

I’ve eaten Goodfellas a few times, and this last time was not a great experience.
A group of 11 of us unexpectedly found ourselves at Goodfellas when our first choice was closed. The waitress was rude, and mentioned multiple times to our group that had we called ahead she could have provided more adequate seating, when all she did, and all she could have done was pull together a few tables for us to sit. The waitress was also rude to the person ordering for us, we simply ordered three large pizzas, and an order of cheese bread and cheese sticks. We didn’t all have separate orders, and everything was billed on one check. The waitress made a rude comment about how there was a difference between the cheese bread, and the cheese sticks.
The food was decent, as it always is, but if you’re forced to eat Goodfellas, get your food to go, and leave the rude staff to themselves. I wasn’t the one who paid the bill for our group, and I’m not sure what tip, if any was left, but our waitress certainly didn’t deserve anything above 5%.