The Sweet Tooth Fairy

I’ve had this place bookmarked and finally decided to stop by. I was surprised when walking in to see posters on the wall promoting that The Sweet Tooth Fairy had won an episode of «Cupcake Wars» that airs on Food Network. After carefully looking over all the cupcakes and cakebites (yes it’s all ran together like that) I was sad that I didn’t see any of the flavors promoted on the poster that they won on the show with. I asked the girl working and she said they are so poplar that they sell out each day and I would just have to come back again an try my luck. I figured these must be good and came back that very week to see if I could get my hands on one of these popular cupcakes, no luck. I came back a third time the next week and again, no luck. I asked the girl working (different girl than the first and second visit) if I could special order some and she said that they only make the cupcake flavors that won on the show during certain times of the year. She said in April they have all 4 flavors from the show, but just certain months of the year they have maybe one of them offered if at all. HUH? I appreciated her honesty, but wish I could have just had an honest answer to begin with because that first employee made me believe that I could get these flavors any day and claimed they sold out and were so popular. Makes me feel like she just was trying to get me to come back looking for those particular flavors in hopes that I’d buy more regardless of the flavor available, which I did. I bought 4 cupcakes during each visit. So, after sampling 12 different flavors of the cupcakes offered here, I can at least give an honest opinion about the cupcakes I tried. Customer service was hit and miss during each visit and I had no problem redeeming the Unilocal check in offer for a free cupcake.
The cupcakes look cute and that’s about as far as it goes. The cupcakes I had were mostly very oily. I had a hard time peeling the liner off because the cupcake wanted to fall apart and stick it was so greasy. The ones that did peel away easily didn’t taste too bad, I did enjoy 3 of the 12 cupcakes that I tried. I wish the cupcakes tasted like the description because they sure looked good yet lacked flavor. The cupcakes are $ 3 each and not very big. The frosting was OK on some and then there were times when it tasted like straight up Crisco. The «FairyFetti» is one that kids would probably really like however it is really sweet.
You are probably wondering after what you just read why I’m not giving 1 star. I’ll tell you right now, it’s the Cakebites. Holy hell they are delicious! They take cake (common type recipe used for making cake pops) and icing and mix it together and form the deliciousness they call a Cakebite. Oh yes and it’s finished off by being dipped in chocolate. They are $ 1 a piece, but at least get a half dozen for $ 5 this way you can try some of the different flavors offered. Each one I tried tasted just like they were described flavor-​wise. Seriously they should have won a competition for these things not the cupcakes! I’ll be back from time to time for some Cakebites, but not too sure about anything else.

Cute shop! Friendly staff! Clean! And the desserts are amazing! We had a sweet tooth and were planning of going out to find ice cream and ended up here instead. We ordered the cinnamon roll, an oatmeal cookie and the Swedish chocolate fish. We brought the cinnamon roll home, threw it in the microwave for 30 seconds and we both agree it is the best cinnamon roll we have ever had! Not to mention the prices are really cheap! We will definitely be back!

Sweets they offer will do the job if you have a sweet tooth, however good customer service is not something that exists here umongst these trolls that call themselves employees. I’ve been here twice and they are so rude I wasn’t even awknowledged upon walking in when no other customers were there but me. The women that work here look so miserable and you would think they would be happier since they won an episode of cupcake wars. Maybe they think because they won they are the best and don’t have to continue being the best.

This place has too much frosting on their sugar bomb creations. I know their name is the Sweet Tooth Fairy but their treats are too sweet. After you eat there you better call Wilfred Brimley cause you got Diabetes.

This place is the best! Everything I have had has been Fabulous. I love the Reese Peanut Butter Cupcakes! so good! The service is great keep up the great treats!

This place is delicious!!! I found out about this gem from the Posh Pinky nail salon during a manicure/​pedicure. I begged my husband to go check it out. We got 13 cake bites for $ 10 plus a free strawberry shortcake cupcake with a coupon. Everything was amazingly delicious. Thank goodness I don’t live nearby, or my waistline would keep expanding!

The place looked clean, and their pastries looked cute. However, they get one star because While my husband and I stood in front of the pastries talking about what we were going to get, and waited for someone to ask us what we would like, no one came to us. There was a woman talking on the phone, didn’t even acknowledge our presence, one guy came out of the kitchen twice really fast to get some things, didn’t even say hello or looked at us. So, after a few minutes of just standing there, we decided to walk out. I guess we will never know what their pastries taste like. Total lack of professionalism.

First thing I noticed and appreciated about this adorable little sweet shop is the friendly customer service. I walked in and began inspecting their shelves of tantalizing treats and my husband, brother in law and I were each offered a cake bite of our choice as a sample. We got the cookies and cream, mint chocolate and salted caramel cake bites. They all were absolutely delicious, salted caramel may have been my favorite of the three with mint chocolate in a very close second. But here is why you absolutely must check out this shop: TOASTED COCONUT CUPCAKE. This is coming from me, one who isn’t exactly a cupcake person, and normaly toasted coconut would be the last flavor I’d pick, so I didn’t even buy the cupcake my brother in law did. And like the generous kind hearted individual he is, he loved the cupcake so much he felt it’s deliciousness had to be shared. The few bites I got out of that glorious desert blew my mind and if I knew I could get them in my home state I would go as far as to say I was converted. I highly recommend this cupcake and would love so much to try the other beautiful cupcakes and treats. Tried the chocolate mint lollipop as well, very yummy.

Pretty good cupcakes. A cute little place to have in St. George! I don’t really like the vanilla frosting so go for the other flavors! Unless you like that strong almond flavor. Overall a good place if you need a sweet treat on the go!

Good products. And are even reasonably priced. It’s a nice treat to get every now and then. The cake bites are the best thing they have. Stop by if you’re near by.

Dangerous!!! To the calorie conscious beware.
I have avoided cupcakes the better part of my life, until now. There is something sinfully seductive about sweet-​tooth treats.

Yummy cupcake.
Very nice and cute shop. all cupcake were decorated very artistic and inviting to eat a bite.
The price like any cupcake shop I been into.
I do recommend and wish the owners the best as small business need to thrive.
I will stop by at times for sweet treat

All I have to say is you need to try the raspberry lemonade cupcake, it was fantastic!
Cute little shop with a lot of adorable and yummy cupcakes and cake bites, had quite the little selection.

This is my very favorite place in town! It blows any other cupcakes out of the water. They are consistently delicious, the service is always quick and friendly. They are very delicious.

I’m gonna have to say, for dinky St. George… this bakery wins. It beats 25 and Main and any other half assed cupcake places. The cupcakes were almost Chicago sized and the flavors were all decent (except Sweet potato… wtf!?)
There are handmade candy canes, overpriced but delicious chocolate covered oreos, ice cream sandwiches (which would be better if it could come in another flavor than just vanilla) and of course cupcakes galore. Also the only place in St. George I’ve seen with cake balls and they did them very well!
Its no place I will yearn for when out of Utah… but it ain’t bad.

update… i had some dude who was peeved at my short review and ask me to give a fair review.
alright heres your fair review:
sweet tooth fairy is overpriced, oversweetened, and i felt sick after eating there because it was so sweet. i havent been back. to me there was nothing that made this place any better than going to the grocery store except they had everything look pretty in their glass displays. $ 3 for a cupcake is a rip off, and at $ 1 a pop, the cake bites are a waste of time. i might as well eat the dollar bills in my wallet. It would probably taste better anyway. i ordered and tried my friends desserts, and everything just tasted like sugar. You would probably be better off and save money by buying a bag of powdered sugar and eating it with a spoon. You can even watch TV while you do it.

First of all, I must say I do NOT have a sweet tooth and do not eat sweets on a regular basis. We were on vacation so we decided to stop in and grab something for dessert.
I’ve had «gourmet» cupcakes before and these taste all the same. However, the cupcake bites were fricken delicious.
Double choc, lime cake, lemon cake, red velvet were all delicious. My only complaint is that they should be a bit larger. Definitely great but I wish they were larger.

This was a for sure stop for me during my recent visit to St. George.
I was disappointed when I walked in because hardly anything was left in the display cases.
I wanted to try the cupcake flavor of the month «Honey Lemon» — Nope, nothing left, I wanted to try the french macaroons — Nope, nothing left.
So I settled for what they had: Cupcake Flavors — Snickerdoodle, Cookies & Cream, Fairyfetti, Vanilla, Red Velvet, & German Chocolate. All were OK, I think the Snickerdoole cupcake was the best. Then I gave into the cakebites temptation and tried Lemon and Fairyfetti flavors. I really enjoyed the lemon while my daughter enjoyed the fairyfetti better.
The best items I think we tried were the Iced oatmeal and chocolate chip oatmeal cookies. They were both equally chewy and delicious!!!
The interior was cute and they had various cupcake inspired items for sale. I once visited the location in Provo, Utah so I was excited to find that one opened closer to Vegas. I think The Sweet Tooth Fairy is a cute and clean place with a variety of yummy stuff for sale-​I just wish they would always have a full display case but I know that’s close to impossible as people keep coming in and buying stuff.
If I am in the St. George again I wouldn’t hesitate to visit again…

OMG first time I had a Cupcake Shake and it was amazing. One of thee best shakes I ever had. I tasted all these sample piece of cupcakes all of them were so good I couldn’t decide. I ended up with a strawberry shortcake cupcake shake, the chunks with ice cream were the best thing I’ve ever tasted.
My family got some extra cupcakes, and some cake bites to go. OMG if you’ve never had a cake bite find a place that has them. They’re like amazing mini cupcake cookies. Like 10 times better than crack girl scout cookies. I don’t know I just had such a sweet tooth this day!

Visited January 10^th, 2011
I had the pleasure of stumbling onto this magical little place on my first ever visit to St. George, Utah. I couldn’t help but be lured off of the I-​15, when out of the corner of my eye, I spied a cute sign… The Sweet Tooth Fairy. So, I immediately pulled off at the next exit & made my way down Red Cliffs drive, right into the Pineview Plaza. It is actually located next to a frozen yogurt place & they kind of share a common entry way & then you have the choice to enter either one.
As I made my way into their cute shop, clean & well decorated. I was greeted by the pleasant smell of baked goods & the wonderful sight of gorgeous cupcakes!
As I was drooling over the display case, a very friendly young lady came out from the back to help me. Everything looked so good, but I finally decided on the Strawberry Shortcake cupcake.
As I was eagerly awaiting to pay for my scrumptious little treat, I was asked if I would like this cupcake for free. Ummm… YEAH! The only catch was, is that I had to fill out a card with my email address, in case I wanted to receive any info & offers, not to mention a FREE cupcake on my next birthday! Oh man, could it possibly get any better?! It did!
So, she packed my cupcake away in a cute little Chinese take out box & I was on my way. I may or may not have been skipping out of there all giddy & whatnot ;) The cupcake was really good & moist! It was topped off with a juicy strawberry half dipped in chocolate! The frosting was not too sweet or sugary, with that grainy texture, like some typical cupcake frostings.
Overall, I will definitely give them my business anytime I am in St. George or at any of their 5 locations throughout Utah. They are definitely better than most of the cupcake places here in Las Vegas.
I just wish I had taken pics :(Sorry fellow Unilocalers, maybe next time.
Additional locations:
Provo
Draper
Salt Lake
Layton
Midvale