The Atlantic

This place is ok for the price. We had an updated room with new laminate floors & paint. The bathroom had new tile and was decent. The cost per night was like $ 150 and the quality of this place was about up to par with the price. Its a good value for the area but don’t expect anything high end.

Avoid the first floor at all costs. Hard wood floors mean you are up all night. Staff are miserable. Night staff as well as morning staff. Pool closes at 8 pm. Included breakfast is really bad. More like expired finger food than breakfast. Cost is way more than reasonable. Smokers paradise. Private owned — makes chain hotels look great. Oh and did I mention the staff could care less? Only positive is location.

You definitely get what you pay for here. If you want to be in the area and you don’t want to pay a lot of money this is what you get. It’s not bad though. It’s just not good either. I would stay here again the next time I’m in the area of the price is right and I guess that’s what matters the most.
The positives aside from the price is the staff seems nice, and the rooms are a decent size. There is free wifi and a complimentary breakfast which mostly consists of bagels muffins and cereal.
The negatives are that the bed feels really really crappy. Like the springs may as well not even be in the mattress. The shower head should be replaced. It’s wonky as heck. You could hear almost every car that drove past on the roadway outside. Not too bad at night but in the early morning during it gets noisy.
Basically if feels like if they put $ 1000 into each room by replacing the mattress, shower head and windows this place would be a lot nicer.

The Atlantic provides decent value in an area not known for it. No axe to grind here.
Adequate, clean room (renovated in 2015); with a flat screen TV, queen bed, baseboard heaters, a modest A/​C, powerful shower and a walk-​in closet. Honestly, the place is being brought back to life after years in decline. Small table for two and IKEA-​type furniture, bleached wood floors. Ask to have your room face the pool side.
It’s a throwback beach motel with open gallery hallways, continental breakfast buffet included and an outdoor pool with deck. The Atlantic is right on 27/​39, close to everything we wanted to be near (Hampton Bays, Bottle Hampton, Riverhead).
Of course, being nice to staff results in a pleasant stay. The place can get overrun with NYC Type A guests who take out their Hamptons frustrations (high food cost, drinking culture, local police) on the staff and furnishings. I have stayed a few weekends and had a great time by keeping expectations realistic. It’s a beach motel, not the Palace.

I recently stayed here with my boyfriend for a few days. The rooms are huge for the money but very outdated and oddly laid out. The mattress was so old when I sat down on it I continued to bounce for at least a full minute. There was cigarette burns on the both the night stands even though its strictly a non smoking hotel. There was dog crap and cigarette butts everywhere. We were on the second floor and had someone underneath us, the floors were so creaky that I felt bad walking around my own room. The TV is bolted down so you cant even turn it if you wanted to. The bathroom is so incredibly small that you can wash your hands, go to the bathroom and shower all at the same time. The heat did work even though there was a HUGE gap in the door. When I say huge I mean big enough to fit a full pencil threw when the door is closed all the way. It got so cold in the room I had to go out and buy a space heater just to stay warm. The Wi-​Fi is free which is nice but it was so slow that it wasn’t worth connecting. During our stay they were also doing construction on one of the rooms near us and instead of putting us at the other side of the hotel where the noise wouldn’t matter they put us right on top of the noise, which started promptly at 8am each morning. If you plan on hanging the do not disturb sign on the door beware of the wind ripping it off the door knob as well as not having any of the staff offer to bring you fresh towels and such. I work at a hotel and I must say I am very dissatisfied with the false pictures as well as the service.

Really wish that my boyfriend and I would have looked at the reviews for this place, other then the ones on the hotel generated search screen by Google. We had a wedding to go to and this was one of the closest most inexpensive at $ 142/​night after taxes. We let the pictures on their page sell us.
Problems with the room.
* The room had no heat! For the month of November the temperature was in the 40’s. We were hopeful in thinking it would eventually «kick in».
*The room was clean! Except for the huge white stain on the carpet which was so suspicious looking.
*The bed sheets seemed clean… If they weren’t we had no choice if we didn’t want to freeze all night. (We slept in full sweat pants and hoodies. Luckily we had these!!)
*Last but not least, getting ready to leave and the bathtub had a huge cockroach. This was before I was going to try and shower. At that point we forewent the showers packed up and left.
… Spoiler we also skipped the complementary breakfast.
I do regret not bothering to telling management at that point in time. I just wanted to get out of there. Also while checking out I was never asked how my stay was. I didn’t even get a thank you!!! I got… «Checking out? What room?» At which point I was the one who said «have a good day» and receptionist said «thanks, you too»
This just maybe the most horrible «Hotel» (if you can call it a hotel) experience we have ever had. I don’t recommend this place to anyone and I suggest anyone considering staying here don’t let the pictures fool you!!!

We wish we could have given it NEGATIVE stars; they don’t even deserve the one we gave! Please heed our warning:
I was searching the internet for hotels in the Hamptons because we just needed to get away. After reading the reviews on TripAdvisor about The Atlantic I started to perk up (been very stressed lately), although you should not believe what you see on their website; save your hard earned money and DO NOT book there! The ONLY good thing is the fact that there is a 24 hour front desk so you can check out any time you want or need to (although if you do check out before your check out date you will lose your money). Other than that I cannot in good conscience recommend this MOTEL (it is not a HOTEL as they would like you to believe)!
They are pet friendly, but DON’T bring them – bad enough you’ll have to suffer! The pictures are very misleading and the «policies» change depending on whom you speak to! BIG MISTAKE… with the inexpensive price the motel begs for (and gets) all sorts of problems and trouble (large trucks idling in the parking lot at all hours of the day and night, illegal immigrants living on premises, loitering, constant noise, etc.); this activity gives a tremendous black eye to the beauty of the Hamptons and having grown up in Southampton I am abashed at what has become of my hometown.
I’d rather go camping; at least it would be worth the money you’re spending and you’d get better food (the free breakfast goes against Health Code with no single serve items as there should be in a public location serving food and makes you feel as if you are in jail – which I would rather be), a better experience, and better service! From the moment you walk in you’re regretting your decision to have come in the first place! This is HANDS DOWN the most disgusting place to stay. I wish I would have read the reviews.
The majority of the staff is not well versed in the English language (very sad for adults in America). If you have any issues better to either keep them to yourself or place a review on the various websites because no one who works there cares (including the manager who is supposed to enforce rules amongst his staff); not one of them has any personality for the hospitality business. They are a bunch of imbeciles (I guess brains, common sense and logic are not requirements to get a job there), extremely rude and arrogant (regardless of age or sex), and even go so far as to speak to each other in another language in front of the guests! There is no organization and even that I could get over if there was some sense of at least one brain being shared amongst them. They act as if they’re doing YOU a favor by putting you in another room when they can’t find your reservation; WE are doing them the favor by staying at this DUMP in the first place!
Don’t bother making requests; they are not adhered to regardless of whether you make them in advance or at the time you are checking in and forget about lodging (no pun intended) complaints – nothing will be done. BARE MINIMUM is what constitutes service at this place which is TOTALLY unacceptable, especially for the hospitality business! The owners of this motel could stand some hotel management classes and the entire staff should be retrained in customer service.
The one person we did find that was concerned for the customer’s welfare deserves better than to work for such a low class place, but you only saw her if you checked in (or had issues) late at night (between 11 p.m. & 7 a.m.), though we haven’t seen her for at least a month (???). I hope she finds a better opportunity soon because she was also the only educated person there!
The property (inside and out) is completely unkempt, the room was small and smelled musty upon entering, there was mold, and it appears as if there have never been any updates! The furniture is from the 60s, there are stains of varying sorts on the sheets and carpets, the smell of smoke (even though this is supposedly a «Non Smoking» property) and animal urine is everywhere, and there are bedbugs. Housekeeping is no better than the rest of the staff; few to no towels or wash cloths (and what there were had holes and could be seen through) and half used bottles of complimentary shampoo, the bed is not made (only straightened with no fitted sheet – top sheets are used as both). The Bentley looks worse… with extra large numbers on the outside (can we say tacky) and the Capri is just as bad even though it is MORE expensive believe it or not!!! NONE OF THE THREE ARE RECOMMENDED… look elsewhere!
You get what you pay for though and I wouldn’t consider it a value! Also, BE SURE to check your bill before leaving and when you get you get your credit card statement verify it before you pay; they commit credit card fraud (I was a victim)! Bad experience overall. This hotel values money over hospitality. Never again; we’ve learned our lesson!

The owners/​managers must have read all the negative reviews, because our stay last weekend was a pleasure. Room was clean, bed comfortable, shower was fine. Breakfast was the usual kind for this type of motel. The staff – Albert and Jeff – very nice. And the price was not over-​the-​top! So we recommend it. Only beef was the location of the sign for the hotel really is not where the driveway is, and we kept missing it! However, overall, we recommend it.

This is one of those you-​get-​what-​you-​paid-​for places. And don’t get me wrong, they’re not cheap, but they are considerably moderate-​priced for the area.
We booked late in the season, and the Atlantic was the only hotel with availability. For fear of losing that, we booked it without looking at reviews.
Upon check in, we were given a spacious pool-​facing room, to accommodate for our 4 person occupancy. The second bed was even in it’s own semi-​room with a privacy curtain. Everything looked great for the first five minute. Then we started noticing the little things, like the broken light knobs, the missing hangers, the worn out towels, and oh, right, the broken shower knob. We couldn’t turn on the hot water.
They were very nice and immediately gave us a different, identical room. Identical as in also run down and lots of broken knobs, no hangers, only 1 suitcase rack, etc. etc. The bathroom was in dire need of renovation, as everything was cracking and falling apart. The water ran colored at first, as if no one had run water through the pipe in quite some time.
The second room, being the only one available to accommodate 4 people, also happened to be right next to some construction-​type work, where we heard drills or hammers of some sort for a few hours when we first checked in.
Overall, this is probably the best deal you can get in the area, but be aware of what you are getting when you book it; read the reviews!

Avoid this place it is not secure. I checked out of this place and someone come in my room and smoked in it. My card was unauthorized a smoking fee (which I don’t smoke) and I had to dispute with my bank. The manager Jack, hung up in my face, and ultimately could not provide proof of smoking damage. This hotel values money over hospitality. I’ve stayed at this hotel plenty of times. I’ve spent THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS and have never had a problem such as this. I have been accused of illegal activities and unspeakable things I am APPALLED. There are other alternatives in the area that are more reasonable with price and value hospitality. They have illegal immigrants living on premises as well this place gives a black eye to the beautiful Hamptons.

We originally had the Bentley hotel, but when we came in late there was no one there, so they gave us this place instead (which looked a lot better, so yay!). They said they just remodeled it, and it is definitely bigger than my studio apt! I really liked the room, though the walls were a bit rusty (pics attached) and there were a pile of ants on the floor.
Other than that, the room is spacious, it’s a great deal and location, and the bagels in the AM were super fresh and delicious!!! Yummmmy!

Grossly over-​priced!
First of all we were quoted 399 $/​night but after taxes the bill ended up being 473 $/​night. The place itself is an old partly refurbished motel on the highway far away from the city center. I would not complain if it was 80 $ per night, but what they charge here is an outrage. Take your money somewhere else where you get at least a bit value for it.

This is the worst place I have ever stayed at. My husband, 2 kids and I decided last minute to spend the weekend at the Hamptons. After trying places I’ve stayed at before this was the only choice available– and now I know why! The website is completely misleading. The place is old and crummy. Bathrooms are disgusting and completely run down. If I had known I would have chosen to stay home.

Great find. The staff was always friendly and as accomodating as they could be. They are moderately priced on weekdays. Weekends cost more. Clean rooms but carpets were pretty stained up. Very comfortable beds and good beddingband pillows. We styed in their two bedroom «suite» its basically two rooms and one queen bed and the other has one full. I would think two double beds in the other room would make more sense. Nothing more special than the other rooms so I wouldn’t call it a suite. Great thing is no one is really here during the week so we were the only ones at the pool.

This is the most god awful motel with the WORST customer service. My friends and I expected to stay in a room with two beds, but upon arrival we quickly discovered that there was only one bed and the other «bed» was a broke pull out couch that we could not sleep in. We thought we were being accomodated and given a complimentary room for the next two nights (we had to switch rooms two times), however, Dia, the manager charged us without notification for the additional room that was supposed to be complimentary.
Now I am wasting my time in a long drawn out dispute about the charges. Please save your time and money and do NOT stay at this terrible motel.

After becoming exasperated looking to get a room in the Hamptons for under $ 200 for one night, the Atlantic rescued me! My husband and I were given a special rate because of participating in a local event, so the prices were very fair – almost half of every other Hamptons hotel/​motel. The staff were very friendly and helpful, giving us recommendations for car services, and were efficient and prompt. The rooms are lovely – freshly painted, modern décor, well lighted with ample space, sofas, tables, a large bed with many pillows and a comfy mattress, lots of dresser space and closets. The grounds are very cute – a swimming pool with room for beach volleyball, several gazebos, and a tree with swings. There is a spa on the grounds for an additional price, but coffee and refreshments in the lobby are free. Free wi-​fi and lots of parking. The one downside is that it is in not beachside, so you’ll have to drive, and there are very few places to walk to eat. Overall highly recommended!