Best pizza on the cape. Traditional Greek style with all fresh toppings. They now have a grill and fryolator for more options! Spaghetti sauce is excellent! Meatballs home made. They toast their grinders too.
Sara P.
Classificação do local: 4 Nantucket, MA
My family and I usually get Tolys on Sunday nights and let me tell you– I am never disappointed. There’s very few pizza places I’ll order just a «plain cheese pizza» since at most joints you need the flavor of meat or veggies for it all to come together but not here. I crave their cheese pizza and knowing how close they are to me assures me I’ll never have to wait long. Delicious. I look forward to trying out more menu items. I would rate it five stars but I’ve only ever had the cheese pizza so I can’t speak for the rest of the menu.
Kate L.
Classificação do local: 4 West Yarmouth, MA
Have been ordering take out here for years(20+) and have never been disappointed. The original owners sold the place a few years ago and the new owners kept the menu and recipes. Pizza is great and lots of cheese, extra cheese isn’t necessary. Italian subs are great as well.
Bill F.
Classificação do local: 1 Great Barrington, MA
Had pizza and wings delivered. Flavor was there but wings were soft and wet with oil. Pizza was a wreck.
Tyler P.
Classificação do local: 3 Maywood, NJ
I go here a lot for dinner while I’m up in the Cape. It’s pretty good, but the pizza tastes bad after you’ve had it for a few weeks. I went here a few days ago, and I got the spaghetti with butter. It was good, but it was a little watery. The employees are very nice.
Jamie K.
Classificação do local: 4 Naples, FL
Excellent thin crust pizza with hearty toppings. Sauce and dough are very flavorful. Comparable to most other pizza places on the cape, but better than a lot of them. Fast and well made pizza.
Chuck L.
Classificação do local: 2 Lunenburg, MA
Have been going here for the past few years because it’s close to the resort. The food is consistently«just OK». Taste & quality is average. Don’t go here expecting the best anything. It will lead to disappointment. Go here because you are starving and too lazy to drive further for a good meal.
John-Carlo B.
Classificação do local: 4 Mount Vernon, NY
Best Pizza in Cape Cod. They have great pizza but their spaghetti has tomato sauce that is good but a little bland. I recommend the pizza rather than the spaghetti. Service was great and the employees are very nice
Kate T.
Classificação do local: 4 Berkeley, CA
New to the area, grabbed a pizza last night after work and was not disappointed. Staff was friendly, food was great and reasonably priced. If you’re looking for a good Greek Style pizza with that amazing golden crispy crust this is the spot. I’ll definitely be back!
Tom P.
Classificação do local: 2 Boyds, MD
Went here based on the positive Unilocal recommendations. Was a bit underwhelmed by the quality of the pizza. My son got a pepperoni and I got the sausage and mushroom. The pizzas were cooked perfectly and the service was speedy. However, the sauce was average, the toppings were pre-packaged, and the mushrooms were from a can. Zero décor and ambiance make this a carry-out or delivery only place.
George B.
Classificação do local: 5 West Yarmouth, MA
Friendly service & very good pizza. We got thin crust w three toppings and it was delicious. The price was comparable to others in the area. I will def return to this restuarant.
Jennifer G.
Classificação do local: 4 Centerville, MA
My boyfriend and I stopped in for pizzas on a whim after we realized the breakfast joint closed for the season. It took a long time for the 2 pizzas to be ready despite us being one of their two tables of customers. While there appeared to be three employees, only one was working. The owner(?) apologized for the long wait. We both thought the pizzas were tasty. Minor complaints of wishing the spinach was fresh(tasted like canned) and the eggplant was crispier.
Tierney O.
Classificação do local: 1 West Dennis, MA
Disgusting — while I was waiting for my food, watched the owner smoking in an office room right next to the kitchen then came out and checked my pizza. Then back to smoking, 2 minutes later back to my food. No gloves, no hand washing. Was too horrified to even complain and threw the food out. Will never go back, ever
Ashley G.
Classificação do local: 4 South Yarmouth, MA
I ordered an onion pizza from here and it was really good. The pizza was super cheesy and the sauce was really good. I have to say that my favorite part of the pizza was the crust. I can usually take or leave crust but I really liked theirs. Cheese was baked onto the crust giving it a great flavor. When I reheated left overs the next day the crust baked even more and the flavor reminded me of Cheez-it crackers, which was a nice surprise. Delivery was also really fast. I will be ordering from here again.
Ryan H.
Classificação do local: 3 Cohoes, NY
Had a craving for something other than seafood. Go figure. So I called Toly’s for the first time ever. They make-a a greasy pizza pie-a. The type of thing that will really hit the spot if you’re in the mood for it. Not the best pizza ever, but not the worst by far. A fine place for takeout, not eat-in. It’s the kind of place that has one of those weird old little computer betting screens at one of the tables, and a random old arcade game. They get extra points for some unexpected toppings like eggplant and spinach.
Cristina C.
Classificação do local: 5 Boston, MA
It’s near my familys Cape house, walkable. The only place we order pizza from. Soooo good. I personally just love Greek style pizza, so it’s a win-win for me. None of that Papa Ginos in our house. Oh gawd, I want it. In my mouth. Oh it’s SO good for breakfast too IF we have enough leftovers or no one eats it on a drunk binge at 3am, grr we’re fighting.
Tamara M.
Classificação do local: 4 Norcross, GA
I’ve been eating Toly’s pizza for over 20 years. It’s consistently yummy Greek style pizza. The crust is the best. It’s a family owned, family run joint where just about everyone is a regular after a visit or two. I remember when Toly himself(the owner’s oldest son) was six or seven and used to play the Ms. Pacman game(still there) in the afternoons. I couldn’t wait til they were back from vacation(jan 31st). I wasn’t disappointed with my olive and linguica pizza… just right to munch while watching the Superbowl at my Dad’s.