Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy

I like their Taffy, what can I say. Some flavors weren’t as strong as others, coffee was a little disappointing, chocolate was average and tasted as should, but the star for me was root beer! I recommend buying more than necessary (perhaps as the flavor selected boxes) as you can bring back and had out as «souvenirs”/goodies to family and friends. [Came back home with not enough and looking up online orders… shipping price kinda ruins it]

This place is perfect! Get a bag and pick your own combos. The molasses peppermint, licorice, and fluffernutter are the best!

Best taffy anywhere! I always go a little overboard when picking out my own taffy but I’m glad later since I tear through it at home. Love the road-​side stand, makes me feel like in a bygone era of the American beach vacation
«Made on Cape Cod by Cape Coders»

The famous «Mermaid Brand» and boy is it good! I’ve had this taffy two times before my first visit to the shop. Steve A. always brings it back for me when he’s traveling home and his mom even ships it to us when we’re feeling homesick. You can go wrong with this taffy. With 30 flavors, there’s definitely something for everyone. You can even taste the taffy as you shop, filling up a bag or box with your choice. My favorite is the fluffernutter but they’ve got everything from fruity to chocolate and even kettle corn flavors!
For $ 9.49 a pound and your choice of the flavors, it’s the best gift for yourself, family or a friend. The chewy flavorful taffy brings me back to ocean vacations and summer time adventures. This is a must stop spot!

love love love, its so good, best around and it just looks like an old place i loved going there when i was a kid, its out doors, they have awesome flavors and you can pick your own and make your own box which i like a lot so great! just love it! :D

This is the real deal! Every beach town has taffy, but they actually make it here. It’s fresh, and you can pick your own flavors. Believe me there are a lot of flavors to choose from! Yum!

The best salt water taffy EVER. From any state. Hands down. No joke. Plus, it’s an outdoor stand!

I’m not a fan of Salt Water Taffy but if I was I would have to say this would be the holy grail of it. The place has been around apparently forever and they definitely know what they are doing. They have so much taffy flavors it made my head spin. My GF who happens to be a Masshole knows her taffy and she said this is as fresh as Salt Water Taffy can get, I did try a few basic flavors and was pretty impressed. Also the stand is awesome, a huge white stand with just a ton of different color taffy’s on display you can’t miss it as your driving. It pretty much just attracts you to it, you have no choice but to pull over and check it out.

Grew up on the Cape, and this place is a must do when I return each time. 30-​ish flavors, good prices, hands down the best on the Cape… staff military friendly and respectful. Don’t leave without trying their peanut butter taffy.

Great Salt Water Taffy been going here since I was a kid and nothings changed still a fine product although have found that the Hot Chocolate Sparrow in Orleans & Gone Chocolate in Osterville now rate supreme status… Think softer but tasty. + 1 on the ability to choose your own flavors a great touch… A family trip here is a great Cape thing to do.

I LOVE this taffy place so much! It is a bit pricey but after trying other local taffy, it is totally worth the price! I love the fluffernutter and beach plum.

Best taffy on the cape!
PS cape cat across the street is a bit of a weirdo place lol

Best Taffy on the Cape! All homemade with a wide variety to choose from. The fact that we made it a point to stop here every day for a fix is a testament to their quality. And the best part is that you get to pick out all of your own flavors instead of all the pre-​packaged taffy you would get anywhere else out there.

I came here for my taffy this past week and was really happy with everything. Service was excellent with an abundance of taffy to pick from. I had to buy taffy for about five different people, so I filled up bags and boxes and was able to label them and then weigh as I went along. The flavors are awesome and they taste just as good.
I find the location incredibly charming, just a roadside stand that you walk up to. You can even see taffy pulling machines behind all the candy. You should definitely make it a point to stop here for your taffy while on the Cape. You will not be disappointed.

They have some classic taffy flavors here. Try the molasses.

My favorite saltwater taffy… better than what I tried in Atlantic City. A very wide range of flavors that impart a natural and authentic taste that often changes and develops as you chew.
The taffies here are chewy and sticky – so whether you might like it here depends on whether you like that texture.
One star off for the very expensive pricing!

Wide variety of taffy and you can watch them make the taffy

Great salt water taffy and a great selection of flavors.

This is the taffy all other taffy strives to be like! They have a great selection of flavors, I recommend the fluffernutter, and you can mix and match your own box.

The taffy here is the tastiest I have ever had — and for over 15 years my family has all been trying to find a worthy competitor for this taffy shack.
This place is always our second stop on our summer vacations to The Cape — our first stop is Seafood Sam’s right next door.
This place always seems to be staffed by female college students home for the summer and in high spirits. They’ve always been super friendly and eager to offer input.
As far as individual taffy selection goes, it’s all up to you, but be sure to check out their flavor of the week. And don’t forget to use your free sample on one of the more exotic flavors.