Blue Moon Pizza

Great service, great food. Got the meatball sub. Red sauce just like NYC. Crowd was after work.

Wait was extremely long. It took 35 mins just for garlic rolls. Only explanation given was that our big pizza (Medium by the way) was the reason. However, many customers that came in after myself and my son had much larger order and received their food way before we did. The food was good but bad experience.

I’m visiting from California
I ordered a med pizza with two different pizza options so I could try something different. Had ½ meat everything and ½ BBQ chicken. Both choices were delicious. You will be happy with either choice.
The atmosphere was nice, not to loud but not quiet either.
Staff was very polite and helpful.
Great place to take the family or go on a date.

Can’t say if the food is good because the service was so horrible we finally left after waiting 15 minutes for someone to take our order or give us water, even after we politely asked the hostess to send someone over. We will never go back!

Don’t order their Sicilian pizza unless you want to overpay for disappointment. It was flat as can be and was almost $ 30. I can’t speak for their other pizza, but the Sicilian was horrible and the mixed drinks were «meh» at best. The service was great.

This is my family’s favorite place for pizza. I am not a huge fan of pizza so I usually get wings. The wings are good but they always order the Meteor. They also have take out. You call in your order and when you pull up they will bring it to your car. Talk about convenience. Love it!

Refused our $ 50 delivery order tonight for some unknown reason. The young lady said she tried to run my credit card (repeated it several times, she read back the card number back correctly, AMEX confirmed she had not attempted to charge).
Perhaps they were too busy or just didn’t like the sound of my voice. In any event, Not a great way to do business.

Great place to have a pizza and a drink
fresh slices and great selection of drinks
:)
recommended

THINGS HAVE CHANGED… I understand Blue Moon has been sold and some changes have been made.
The pizza crust was alot thinner than usual. I had the meateor pizza which was rather oily. I forgot what my friends ordered but they said the crust was different
Our waitress was rather dingy, she said she had been there about a month. We had to ask for our silverware but she had no problem bringing our check

The food can be inconsistent at times but overall it’s a good experience. The cheese fries are surprisingly awesome along with the garlic parm wings.
Rob at the bar is very cool and a great bartender. We are both from the Bay Area originally so we have our spirited 49ers and Raiders debates.

Darn good pizza and a great place to eat with a big group of friends and family. We ended up ordering three whole pies for a group of 11. Service was fast and fantastic. I think we got 2 Grandm’as and a Meateator.

The food is typically good however I ordered a pepperoni pie and its was literally a grease ball! The grease was literally dripping off of it! I was so disappointed not to mention that I’m pregnant and I was craving a great slice of pepperoni pizza. Disappointed to say the least. I guess I should’ve guessed it wasn’t going to be good when they told me it would 45 min with delivery and I live across the street in the same apartments. Anyways I opted to pick up being that I could use the exercise. I’m giving it a 3 because the other times I’ve had it were pretty decent.

We went here on a Sunday the first time and were shocked to find them closed. Okay, if you want to close on Sundays when you’re in a hot location like West Village that’s your business. I was just surprised. Anyway, the second time we went, they were open. It was a Saturday around 5:00 pm I think. The place was pretty empty (which is fine because even when there’s next to nobody there, it’s loud)
Hubby ordered a beer and the stuffed portabello mushrooms. I ordered a SLICE of pizza. Why am I capitalizing SLICE you ask? Because it’s AWESOME that you can go to a restaurant and order a slice of pizza rather than a whole pie. Okay, maybe I don’t get out enough, but anyway. I loved it. Reminded me of the old days on the Jersey boardwalk.
Hubby loved his mushroom dish, but he did say it was *heavily* garlicky, and when I tried it, wow he was right. Huge visible chunks of fresh garlic clove were obvious on the plate. If you dig garlic you’ll dig that dish!
I built my own pizza slice with the toppings of my choice and DAMN it was good! They use a super thin crust, which is the only way pizza should be made of course. I would definitely go back for that pizza. In fact, I want to go back right now!

This is my 100% honest review… I mean BLUNT.
I placed a delivery at 8:20pm, I ordered the garlic rolls, and mild /​lemon pepper mixed wings. girl picked up the phone was really nice, no complaints, she got my order right, just think she slipped in an extra charge or two or three or maybe i’m cheap BUT she was very kind and did her job well.
I received a phone call from the delivery guy (didn’t get his name) at 9:07pm saying he was outside. Now to me this did not seem to be a long wait because I placed my order as soon as I got home and took a long shower, when I got out, got dress about 5 minutes later I got the call from the delivery guy, Now blue moon is like walking distances to my house, about a 15 minute walk and 5 minute car ride, if that… so I guess OK delivery timing. Anyhow…
The delivery guy seem pretty cool and so on to the food…
Well as you can see from the picture the freaking bread is burnt I don’t want no D$@& burnt @$$ bread, from the pics online the wings appeared to be larger in size, I guess my sight is going bad because these are small wings, OK flavor, The mild has a nice kick to it, lemon pepper was cool food was cold, not luke warm cold but like its been siting in the car for a minute while the delivery dude was doing other deliveries, IDK wild guess, but the food was cold. Still took a bite and it didn’t wow me, I mean I might feel another way once I heat the food up, UGH! Not shocking that I got one cup of ranch, most places do that unless you request more, which is why I always keep ranch, so no big deal there, won’t really need more anyways. There was enough garlic to put on my burnt bread. Overall for $ 23.00 plus the $ 1.00 tip I left… Not a fan. Once again I MIGHT feel another way once I heat the food up. I might give the pizza a try during the weekday when they just open and no one is there, a long long long long time from now, and that’s if I don’t find another pizza joint by then, but that will be it if I ever order again! I ordered from other places around this area and the food temp has never been an issue. So for a first timer, i’ll have to give it a thumbs down… To many negatives!
Update: So I heated the food up, and it was seasoned well… Was hoping heating up the rolls would take away the burnt taste… No luck people!!! No luck! Sad Face. And that’s the update!

Enjoyed a new experience @ Blue Moon Pizza in Vinings with great friends! Thanks Tom & Ann for a great evening and dinner. And we can’t forget about our server Ray, thanks a bunch! #bluemoonpizza #westvillageplace #pizza #familyandfriends

The pizza was great and the service was good. We went as a family date night with our son and we really loved it. We sat outside since the weather was nice, loved the outside environment. We ordered the garlic rolls as an appetizer, it was so yummy! We had half white pizza and half margherita pizza. Next time I’ll remember to order no onions on the white pizza. Other than that it’s was very good. They even had someone blowing up balloons for the kids. It was a great experience! We’ll be back!

Meh. This place has amazing food, but recently within the last few months, service has taken a nose dive. The last 2 times I’ve been there have been some of the worst experiences ever.
1^st wasn’t too bad in the beginning, normal meal. But we ordered a salad to go. And waited 30mins for it. About 15−20mins in, we called the manager over, and he apologized, and said that the kitchen had burnt the bread and chicken in the salad. Sorry dude, but we’re sitting inside, looking at your ovens, and that chicken and flatbread never went in. 10mins after the manager came over, we finally got the salad. A fucking salad. And he bald faced lied to us.
2^nd was even worse. Spoke to someone to get a table, said he’d be right back. Disappeared while the line backed up behind us. The place was almost completely empty inside, and while we were all standing there, there were about 4 waitstaff standing around staring at us. The ignorant slug of a manager walked out of the restrooms, took a look at the line, and made a beeline to the kitchen. Got seated after about 10mins, and then it took another 15 to even get someone to come over to us. At this point, I just wanted to see how long it would take, and what would happen. Once we got the girl, all was well, but cmon.
You can tell that the management has changed, and this new guy completely missed the bus on customer service. He avoids customers, and when he HAS to speak to them, lies to get them out of his store. I’ll try again in a few months, just to see. But i’m really annoyed, because I love their food and the patio, but I refuse to have this level of service shoved at me repeatedly. I don’t care how much you made today, mister manager. Service me properly.

Food Was Great But The Service Could Have Been Better But I Will Try Them Again Next Time

Service sucked worst than a broken HOOVER
Waiter took 15 minutes to let
Us know what was available at bar…
If not for my wife’s pretty face I would be expelling a
Worst review… Said myself
Always

The chicken wings here are awesome. Lemon pepper and you can’t go wrong. Trying the pizza today. The kids get some extra doe to play with and they cook it