Coffaro’s Pizza

Used to come here a lot to watch show premiers. I would buy their fries when I did this because they’re cheap and it would be polite. Their fries are disgusting though. Flavorless, dry, they just throw ketchup packets on top. One day I came in to watch Archer and bought their nasty fries as a polite gesture. I asked the girls working if they could turn on the TV sound. They responded in a snarky manner, saying that both the TV and bowling music couldn’t be on at once. I knew this to be a lie as I have watched shows with big bowling parties playing at the same time. When I mentioned this, they gave a very sarcastic apology. They brought out my fries, then began talking about me, so I left. I didn’t return for a while until my boyfriend and I went to try out their pizza. We paid $ 13 for a large, which was the smallest large pizza I had ever seen. Not only that, but we waited nearly an hour for it. The guy working delivered it to our table by tossing it down, giving a mumbled apology for the wait. The pizza was not worth that much money. Between the wait, the size and the poor taste, it was a waste of money. I will never return here. The workers are almost all very rude and treat you like a nuisance. The place is not clean, not kept up, and the food is never worth what is paid. They should be ashamed of themselves.

I wish I could say it was better… it’s the best pizza in Slippery Rock… but that isn’t saying much. When you are from this area… what can you do? Wish they had salads… they do have salads… but they are pretty pathetic. Careful what you wish for! I wish for GOOD SALADS!

Definitely the best pizza in slippery rock! My friends and I get it almost every weekend, its always fresh and delicious.

Coffaro’s pizza is the embodiment of hometown pizza. Their dough is made fresh daily as well as their sauce. This is the best pizza in town by far. Delivery is typically quite fast.

Love this place!

Food is delicious… but the delivery girl at the Grove City Coffaros needs an attitude adjustment. I’ve been a loyal customer for years and don’t even know that I want to go back after experiencing her.

I got obese because of this place… Literally lost over 75lbs after leaving SrU, I miss u cofferos

Yum! Been in town in business for a week and have eaten there twice. It’s not the best pizza you’ll ever have, but it’s pretty darn good. It’s located inside of the town’s bowling alley (like a snack shop) but has much more than pizza. The folks that work there have been really nice both times we’ve been there. Service is fast and the food is cheap ($ 5.50 for 2 slices and a bottled soda). Overall, a great place to stop in for lunch!

Great delivery service from the one in Grove City to my hotel room. I had the Chef Salad and it was a very large salad with smoked ham, hard salami, pepperoni, green peppers, white onions, tomatoes, olives, and blended shredded cheeses. It was very fresh and tasty! Delivery has to be $ 10 or more, so since the salad was $ 7.50, I also ordered a Lemon Tea which hit the $ 10 mark. Best part was, I could stay in my hotel room and work on my classwork in my pjs and get a great salad brought to my door!

Ordered a small pizza and it tasted and looked like it was a frozen pizza thrown in the microwave. Not a fan, but the phone and delivery people were friendly.