Don Gath Insurance

I used Don Gath for our car insurance for a couple years. I no longer do. I have two gripes with these people. After getting married, I brought my wife in to get on my insurance plan. They were unable to access the Progressive online platform and told me they would just sign her up for a different carrier — Mercury. My current insurance agent said this was bad practice. By putting us on separate plans, they were not getting us a marriage discount. It was suggested by her that they may have done this intentionally because it ends up getting the agent higher commissions (at our expense). My second gripe is a personal one. We had called and spoke to Michelle to update the autopay on my wifes account. Well someone dropped the ball and the autopay did not go through. This caused a lapse and then a reinstatement fee. When we called to complain we got Greg. After some grumbling he finally agreed to fix it but blamed us for the mistake — even going so far as to say we were «taking food off his table.» Completely unacceptable. If you make a mistake — take responsibility!

I called Don Gath Insurance earlier this month to get a quote to replace our homeowners, personal umbrella, and auto policies. I could not be more pleased with their responsiveness and their quick action to get our new policies in place before our old policies were set to expire. I really enjoy dealing with local businesses and am so happy to have found them. Highly recommended.

I use Don Gath Insurance for both my home and my house. When I was going through the process of buying my home, it was great to have smart people that I trusted helping me through the process. The quote was lower than I expected based on some prior research and they were an important and punctual part of my team. I’d recommend them to anyone that needs insurance for their car and home!

Don and Michelle Gath were so kind to volunteer their son/brother’s (Greg) expertise… and time to help me sort through a problem with an evil body shop. Michelle, a delight, accompanied me to visit the shop and successfully created a win-​win situation (the owner came to realize her wisdom).
Don Gath Insurance Agency is a cut above the others with honesty, integrity and loyalty.