Noodles & Company

This place was absolutely fantastic when it opened, the food was tasty, the staff was friendly and helpful, and atmosphere was inviting. But since then… It’s been going down hill.
The last few times I’ve stopped in were just to-​go orders for dinner on my way home from work, and I didn’t have an issue with any of it. However, my most recent visit was for a dine-​in lunch, and I’m sad to say that I can’t say the same.
I ordered the Stroganoff and my mother ordered a tomato and basil soup, both with a roll and soda. The first issue was that about half of the soda selections on the touch screen Coke machine were unavailable. I should say this was really just more of an inconvenience as there was an employee there trying to fix it.
By the time I was able to get my drink and return to the table, the food had arrived and been there for a few minutes. At first I thought that was convenient, but maybe the reason it got out so fast was because they nuked the noodles before bringing them out. The noodles were very chewy and lacking flavor, the sauce was okay and the meat was edible but I didn’t eat much of it.
My mom wasn’t very thrilled with her soup, either. After a few sips she said it «Tastes like pizza sauce.» And to be honest, it kind of looked like watered down pizza sauce, too. She went up to the counter to request a refund for the soup since she hadn’t been very hungry. For some reason they said they couldn’t give her the refund, but did begrudgingly give her a chicken noodle soup as a replacement. But even that, the broth was the only thing edible and it was just «Okay».
I’m really disappointed in this place. The respect the employees have for their customers and their food has gone way down, and it makes me sad that I might be one more bad visit away from not coming back.

Disappointing once again, service and food are disappointing. I will not be back. Too bad I cannot give no stars or ½ star. May be closer to the proper rating.

Another disappointing visit. The first time the pasta was very dry and not enough sauce. This time the noodles were way over cooked and glue-​like. I’ve eaten at Noodles in Green Bay for years and always had a consistent product. Not sure what is going on in this location.

So excited to finally have a Noodles & Co. In Sheboygan! I’ve been here multiple times and I get my food in a timely manner and it’s always EXCELLENT! I highly recommend the Pesto Cavatapi & Chicken Noodle soup. Loved the outdoor patio area in the warmer months! Keep it up Noodles!

I have only been here a few times. I had a bad experience from my meal a few weeks ago and I called about it, and the manager was very quick to offer me a free entrée and asked for my address. Two weeks passed by and I never got the card in the mail for the free entrée like the manager said he would send out to me. I called there and a girl told me they had just got sent out today, mind you this was like december 27^th. It is now January 5^th and I still haven’t received the card. I called back to say I was unhappy and I wanted to come in today if I didn’t get it in the mail. The girl on the phone was a little rude but said I could come in if I didn’t get the entrée card in the mail. Which I didn’t. So I went in. I got Alfredo monte more and it was really good! Better than when I ordered the pesto cavatappi that had one tomato and one mushroom in the whole thing. I feel like they only stepped up their game with this meal because they knew I was getting a free meal from the screw up before with the pesto cavatappi. Not too pleased.

Really good buttered noodles with shrimp and a Caesar salad. Soda machine from the future. Giant cookies. Bbq sandwich better than Dickey’s for real. Wish there was more space in dining room. I like a booth, there’s a few, the rest is tables and stools. Eat the good fooood!!!