Simply Delicious Pies

There are no words for how delicious these pies are! «Simply» is an understatement. Caramel apple is heavenly. And oh my gosh the cherry. The turtle cream pie is divine, but needs to be ordered ahead of time.

The name says it all. Got a 8 inch caramel apple pie today to bring to a friends house for lunch. Lady at the counter was super helpful and pleasant. Caramel is added at the last minute when you buy the pie. Wonderful crust– crunchy and tasty. Filling was yummy as was crumb topping. This is a terrific find and I hope they are around for a long time!

Delicious pies. I got the 12 in pecan crumble pecan 16 $ and 12in mushroom feta 12 $. Both were delicious. I felt the price point was a little high for the 12in pumpkin but it was delicious — great flavor and texture. The quiche makes for a nice dinner served with a salad.

Ordered the pumpkin and an apple cranberry pie for a party — only had a few slices of pumping left — delicious! Highly recommend stopping in.

Amazing pies! We have tried many of them. Custom ordered the key lime pie and chocolate peanut butter pie for my husbands birthday. Also recently enjoyed the strawberry rhubarb pie. We will definitely continue to come back again and again!

Ordered an apple pie for my husband’s birthday. It was ready to be picked up the next day. The pie was incredibly delicious and I appreciated the (very small) list of ingredients on top because you know it doesn’t have a ton of junk in it. We will definitely be going back again. I’d like to try the pot pie as well.

Do I get bonus points because it’s pi day?
Came to this unassuming little pie shop today in the early afternoon to pick up some (absolutely essential!!) pies for pi day. They were pretty much sold out. of everything. but I was very lucky to have arrived T-​5minutes before new pies were coming out of the oven! There was already a small crowd of people hanging out in the shop and waiting. Next time I’ll probably order in advance — I can’t expect to be so lucky every time.
Got an apple pie and a peach pie and they were AMAZING. They were warm and fresh, not overly sweet, and the crust was crispy, not crunchy. My friends all liked them too. And, my whole car smells like pie now. So happy.

You better make sure you order before you go there. I got there 10 minutes after they opened and they didn’t have anything ready. The pie I got was delicious, but wish I could’ve had what I wanted.

Absolutely wonderful! The staff are very friendly and so the vibe there is a positive, happy place. The pies are out of this world amazing! I ordered 3 different pies for Easter and couldn’t help but buy another one when I picked them up… each one was more amazing than the one before it! I am not a huge cream pie fan, but the coconunt almond cream was really something to behold!
There is a handy parking lot just behind their building off Van Aken (east bound) and on-​street parking right in front. It is also a great location because you can walk over after getting groceries at Heinen’s, so you don’t have to move your car and find another parking spot.

The blueberry-​cherry-​apple crumb-​top pie was to die for! I am looking forward to returning to try more varieties — including the pot pies and quiches!

YUMMY!!! The BEST pies in Cleveland area, hands down. I will be honest and say I’m a cake person, not a pie person. If I had the choice between a cake and their pie, I would chose their pies every time. The pot pies and quiches are just as delicious.
Make sure you order in advance if you want specific pies!

Wife & I got the 6 inch sweet potato pie & a 6 inch bacon apple cheddar quiche. They were both excellent the quiche was savory with a hint of sweetness from the apple, the crust on the sweet potato pie was like candy! I’m going to order a banana cream pie Friday and pick it up Saturday you have to preorder the cream pies a day in advance. Check it out I don’t think you’ll be disappointed…

Once again, 5 star pie, but 4 stars for availability. This time I arrived at 10:30, on a Saturday morning thinking that surely the shelves would be well stocked in anticipation of a busy Saturday??? Well same experience, very small selection to choose from, there were just a few large fruit pies (2 – 3), and a couple of small sweet potato and key lime pies in the refrigerated case. I opted for the key lime pie and it was delicious, sweet, tangy with a homemade graham cracker crust. At some point I’ll get to try more flavors, just wish the selection was more plentiful and consistent:-(

I couldn’t be more pleased with this cool little pie bakery in Shaker. When you first walk in, you get a hit of the delicious yummy aroma of freshly baked pie. I went with my pie obsessed boyfriend to pick out something for my aunt. I wanted to get the blueberry peach, but when we saw all the other flavors there, we really couldn’t leave with just one pie. We left with both the blueberry-​peach and the cherry-​peach.
One was for my aunt, but the second one was for us. We broke into the pie as soon as we got into the car. That blueberry flavor was rich and warm, but didn’t overwhelm the peach. It was subtle, but added a great sweetness that I can’t get enough of. But the best part of any pie is the crust. This one was flaky and buttery. The crumble topping was Dutch style (like they do on a Dutch Apple pie) and cinnamon-​y and sweet. The parts where the sugar melted tasted gooey and caramel like. Oh, it was so good! We finished the whole pie in one day and ate some of that cherry pie too at my aunt’s house.
I will definitely be back for more! The owner recommended the chicken pot pie, so I will be here bright and early for a scrumptious taste!

We love the pies at Simply Delicious, and the women who run the shop are fantastic! We are always greeted with a smile, and they seem genuinely happy to serve.
Order ahead for best results, as the popularity of the shop leads to empty shelves at the end of the day!

These pies are VERY GOOD! I was impressed. They taste fresh and are full of flavor I bought apple pie and sweet potato.
The staff was friendly and informative. They’ve only been open about a year but you’d never know it. Pleasant customer service, delicious pies… it doesn’t get any better than that!

I read about Simply Delicious Pies in a Unilocal newsletter. When I saw all of the five star ratings, along with the fact that it was located right down the street from my apartment, I knew I had to go immediately.
We picked up three pies for the week to share with family — the caramel apple, the pumpkin with pecan crumb, and the chocolate pecan. The crust on each pie was perfection. Each pie was good, although the caramal apple was a bit sweet for my personal taste. However, the chocolate pecan pie was insanely good. It is verrrryyyyy rich, so just a tiny sliver is enough, but it definitely hits the spot.
The service here was wonderful and friendly, and I’m going to have to come back to try their quiche. And more pie. This shop is definitely worth the visit — it will definitely be my new go-​to pie spot!

I’m not a baker, I’m not a pie expert, but I am foodie, and here’s what I can say: These are damn good pies. I love them, my wife loves them, my kids love them. A little too much, frankly.
We might be addicted.
It’s been our experience that certain pies can sell out quickly, so calling ahead to reserve is never a bad idea.

Simply Delicious Pies is truly a delightful little Lee Road gem!
I stopped in here with a friend yesterday just to take a look at what they offered. The first thing that hits you when you walk in the door is the smell. It is that magical sweet and fruity aroma that hits you like a nostalgia train, taking you back to weekends at grandma’s. Even though I just had lunch, I was starting to become hungry all over again!
After a few moments of indecisiveness in the face of all the tasty sounding options, ended up leaving with a darling 6″ pumpkin pie. It was perfect! It had a smooth texture in the filling. It was not too sweet, which I appreciated, and had a lovely balance of the earthy pumpkin flavor and the spices (a balance which a lot of pies surprisingly seem to lack!). The crust was lightly sweet and buttery.
My friend got a 6″ mushroom quiche which had a delicious cheesy filling and a buttery, savory crust.
There weren’t a whole lot of pies out in her display case by the time we got there at about 1:00, but still a pretty good variety. However, you could choose to order a pie in advance in 6″, 8″, or 10″. I’ve got my eyes on the carmel apple for next time!

I Love Simply Delicious Pies! They are wonderful. I ordered 2 pies to take to work for a party — the Chocolate Malt & the Apple Pie. The Apple Pie made 1 of my colleagues tear up after eating it. She said it was the best apple pie she’d ever had. The chocolate malt pie was so great. I’ve never wanted to go back and have more pie like I did with the chocolate malt pie.
My recommendation for buying pies is to order them in advance from their website, that ensures they will be ready in time. The cream pies they need advance order for, so definitely order those in advance and 10 inch pies need advance order.
The ladies who own this place are so kind. They will take care of you no matter what your request is.