Pegasus Pizza

I’ve been coming to Pegasus since I was 5 years old. This is by far the best Greek style pizza in he Seattle area. They have a great atmosphere and awesome pizza. I stopped by on Saturday to make sure my memory was correct and it was just as good as ever. It definitely looks a lot different since they remodeled a few years back but the pie is just the same.
Pizza: 9.5
Atmosphere: 9.5

Not the warmest of greetings. We weren’t sure if we seated ourselves or not. No appetizers but the waitress was nice and explained different ways that things COULD be appetizers which i can appreciate. Happy hour was a BUST (1 $ off beer/​$ 2 off wine on a saturday at 5:00). I Didnt see anything else I wanted So we left before ordering.

Best pizza hand crafted food. Everything is so fresh and smells amazing. A great eviroment and the customer service is great. Always ask for Nick he is the guy to ask questions about the food. And everyone else there know what else is good. For a person who cant have cheese their pizza is so fresh I can have their food with no problems.

Love love love this place. I’ve been coming here for years. The food is good, salads amazing and great service. Not to mention the view of Alki Beach. The servers are always friendly. I would recommend this to anyone that wants a good low key Italian meal.

The service is good, nice view from anywhere in the restaurant, and good food. I ALWAYS ALWAYS get the house tom’s special and the greek salad. Both are really good, i’ve tried the italian salad, and i thought that was a bit plain, the tom’s house pizza is sooo good, i would reccommend it to anyone that goes. The only bad thing about them is. i think they over do it for the olives, i have to take them out of my salad and pizza. Other than that, i come here everytime there’s a groupon offer, i even introduced it to my boyfriend and it’s his favorite pizza place now!
I wanna try something new, maybe a pasta or something… don’t know what’s good but will take suggestions

AMAZING food and AMAZING service. I come here very often and I normally orders the Toms special pizza and Greek salad and it’s awesome every time. The feta cheese bread is also delicious, I love the sunflower seeds on top.
The owner came out and start greeting everyone and making sure everything was ok with their food.
I will definitely will continue to come here!
(Also is the best location to see the water.)

I ordered salad and a quintessential Italian pizza, the margherita. The food brought me back to a time when I lived in Columbus, what I call my purgatory years. This is a fine example of midwestern pizza and salad. It’s not Italian, not New York, and not even Chicago (which is pie, not pizza, but that’s for another time…). The ingredients are local, in the sense that they come from the local Safeway or Costco (if you’re lucky). The grated cheese is fresh, from the bag. The olives are fresh, from the can. They are very proud of the oil in their vinaigrette: they give you a LOT of it and don’t obscure it with nary a drop of balsamic. The tomato is meaty yet tasteless, just as I remember them. The crust is completely unlike anything you’ll find in Italy: thick, slightly grainy, and with no discernible char (you can take that literally or short for character). The pizza’s cheese was white, both in color and flavor. It formed a an effective barrier, protecting the eater from a tomato sauce that must have been freshly made from the aforementioned flavorless tomatoes. Note that they do add their own touch, straying from classic midwestern pizza, in that the basil on my pizza was reasonably fresh and **abundant**. This act of rebellion should not go unrecognized.
Note that they doubled their score due to good service and reasonable cleanliness.

The Fettuccine Alfredo pasta is the best I’ve eaten. The cream was so rich and tasty they do not have the vegetarian option on the menu, so you have to ask them for it. The garlic bread was very soft and crisp as well.
The pasta comes with a side of salad or soup– there is no vegetarian option for the soup. So, we got the salad.
I highly recommend this place– ask for a table outside to get a beautiful view of the Alki beach. Service was great as well.

The Greek pizza. This is it. It’s amazing. It’s salty, but tempered by the spinach. The other pizzas are also delicious. This is a nice, simple pizza place — it’s not trying to being Neapolitan pizza or anything. It’s just straight up pizza, medium-​thick crust, cheesy, laden with toppings. If that sounds good to you after a day at the beach, Pegasus can’t be beat!

Alki Beach has a gang problem at Pegasus. These are some gangsta ass toppings that will shoot up your taste budz. Cheese makes you scream Jeeesus. Owner Sarahhh (sorry not sure if it’s spelled with no «h» or 3 h’s) was super nice gave us appetizers since it was my parents 39^th anniversary.
Pegasus has the view the food and the service. I actually ordered from them for my engagement and all guests were impressed.
Coming to Pegasus, I realized you are what you eat. I ordered the Hercules so it matches my muskullzzz.
Bring your friends… tell them Lynch sent you.

Just floating around town on this chilly overcast August day in Seattle. Surprise, surprise. Heard they had an unusual warm sunny weather for 65 days. Knew that would change when I got here. LOL We’re at Alki Beach. Great pricey homes, as always where water is involved. A lot o eating places are open for dinner only. So this was the most appealing today. Can also find Subways, burgers and fish and chips
Ordered lunch special 2 slices with 2 toppings and a side salad for $ 10.75. Of course we wanted Spinach salad so that was a $ 5 upgrade
Salad was fresh and excellent. Pizza was very good. Not thin crust, but very good. Topping were generous. Would definitely recommend. Also service was quick and friendly.

This is one of my favorite places to get pizza. I like there hercules pizza, there large pizza’s are huge! It actually ended up feeding 3 people with leftovers! I’ve tried the pasta but i wasn’t a big fan of it. Service was good, and the restaurant had a nice seats outside on the patio where you can see the water. I would definitely recommend coming down here if you are ever down on Alki, it is definitely worth a try!

This is one of my all time favorite places to get pizza in Seattle… well West Seattle. The crust is amazing and they use cornmeal so the texture and crunch is amazing.
I get the tom’s special (I love shredded pepperoni) and a greek salad. That is more than enough for two people… even if you get a small pie.
Be sure to go here if you visit!

Right off the street parallel to the shoreline! Lively atmosphere with action-​packed streets during the summer months. A great place to socialize with friends and family or to meet people during the summer.
I got the lasagna, and that was a huuuge portion, which makes up for the rather expensive pricing. With a beer pitcher split 4-​ways, my bill only came out to be around 25 bucks with tip. I would come here again, but next time I’d come on an empty stomach. Not sure what the pizza serving sizes are like, but I’m willing to find out!

If you are looking for a great place on Alki Beach– Pegasus Pizza is a wonderful spot. The pizza is high quality– it is not your cheap processed Dominos pizza– it is a heavy pizza with fresh ingredients and quality. The pizza is more expensive then others– but again but I would much rather pay for something that is higher quality then placing more processed junk in my body.
Drinks are made strong and at a competitive price, staff is friendly and there is a high energy at the location. Great place to visit especially on summer days in Seattle.

This place might really be great for some and just ok for others.
We ordered Toms Special Pizza and a Greek salad.
The pizza crust kind of reminded me of Pizza Hut, but with way better toppings. The best part about this pizza was the generous amount of shaved pepperoni on top. That was pretty original and gave the pizza a really nice crunchiness as well. I’ve never had pepperoni like that.
The Greek salad was a typical Greek salad, but they we’re very generous with their feta, which I personally liked.
In General the meal was good, the service was kind of substandard. We all definitely felt like they wanted to scoot us out to reuse the table again. Can’t help but to remember that the pizza crust was so much like Pizza huts. This place is a decent general pizza parlor, but it’s still missing something to make it special.
It’s you’re into views… this is a good spot to view the water from.

Went here on a Sunday afternoon. It wasn’t busy. Got quick seats and great service. The pizza was great. We had chicken and bacon with Alfredo sauce and fresh tomatoes. It tasted great. Worth it. Will be back.

My coworkers and I have been here a few times now and I really can’t say anything too negative because the food is pretty solid. The pizza is good, the salads are more than just chopped lettuce, and the sandwich I had today was very good.
I was kinda surprised when we arrived (sunny day in early March) that the restaurant was so quiet… not sure what I was expecting… but I’ll tell you one thing, I realized right away I wasn’t at a «The Fall of Troy» concert.

I think if I give Pegasus a second chance it may earn 4 stars. That is… When my pizza aversion has passed. (Domino’s, Food-​borne Illness, ER.)
That said, I didn’t dine on pizza, of course not! But my three men who ordered «the Domino’s» sure did. Carnage galore! Hard to ignore…
I ordered the rosemary chicken ravioli. No marinara or bread for this girl.
It was pretty good, small polio for the price– definitely not a dish to share. The pasta was good, cooked properly and seasoned with a pesto olive oil coating, delicate with good flavor. I do regret to say: no rosemary taste! It was good, but I did not sense rosemary. And the pesto was not buttery with pine nuts and fresh basil like papa used to make. It was weak-​er, delicate. And there must be a vampire back in that kitchen– no garlic aroma or taste and the chicken meat was on the dry side.
If pizza didn’t almost take my life almost a month ago, most of the pizza choices looked very tasty. I can say that the pizza is packed with toppings. Pizza on a silver platter? No, really, they are actually served on a «silver» platter. Maybe they aren’t vampires?
One more note for the pizza that I did not consume– I think that 3 could share a medium and at a fair price.
Service wasn’t outstanding, but not crappy. We had to waitresses willing to offer us help during our stay. The poor things were very busy, too.
Of course, the location is fantastic. ‘Nuff said. Parking… Another story.
I noticed they have a happy hour mon-​thu. Sorry, don’t remember the times.
I will give Pegasus pizza another chance. I think wine and veggie pizza may up them a star.
************UPDATE************03/21/15
Dined here again on a weekend and experienced the Hawaiian pizza. +1 star!
The crust was seasoned perfectly to pair with the sweet and savory toppings. The aroma was pleasantly seductive.
I wasn’t very hungry, but the pizza was so tasty that I indulged.
The service was better this time around, too.
I’ll be back :)

Fantastic local Alki Beach eatery that I’ve been dining at since the beginning when Tom opened it up.
This is the place for summer time dining when your in West Seattle because you get the view of Alki and quality food. This menu has something for everyone but some of my highlights are Tom’s Pizza, but ask for it with shaved pepperoni, it makes the pizza. White Spaghetti with chicken & mushrooms is THE BOMB and I cannot lie! This pasta dish if the perfect me. It’s served with salad and garlic bread, but asked for the feta bread is so yummy! Now if you must get one item it’s the THE GREEK SALAD, a treat of culinary bliss. I’ve never had a better salad than this and I eat a lot of salads. The perfect blend of feta cheese, Greek olives, onions, sunflower seeds and lettuce tossed together with secret sauce. Plus this salad is huge, enough for a party of 2 or 3 to split so you may want a half version of this delight if dining alone.
Ambiance in the restaurant is casual and warm with excellent wait staff handling all your dining needs. Rain or shine you’ll enjoy coming to Alki for some pizza pie.