Goodfellas Pizza

So many great things to say about this place. I’ve ordered delivery here as of late, on a consistent basis, and it is some of the fastest delivering there is. Last 2 times I ordered, the order arrived well under 30 min (Almost all other delivery in Scranton takes 1 – 1.5 hours at night). And the food… I was shocked that a known «pizza place» had such a wide variety. I’m a picky eater, and quality is very important to me (I don’t care how long it takes). I’ve ordered about everything off the menu over the last few weeks (hoagies, calzones, burgers, gyros, and pizza obviously) and I was thrown back on how great everything was. This is my new «go to» hoagie place from here on out… A must try!

Absolutely terrible service. Took 3 hours for delivery ah which point I didn’t even want the order and then another week long hassle to get my money back. Horrible people to deal with as well.

This place has really changed. Their service is a little slow at times, but they’ve always refunded my food if it was wrong. The bar is good for sports nights, eat with your family, or a night out. Can’t say that I hate Goodfellas at all.

By far some of the worst food in the area. But extremely convenient if you need some drinks late at night.

A novel idea; a bar-​slash-​pizza place. Dollar slices gets you a pretty good, Dominoes-​type slice of pizza. Much smaller than your average slice (but then again I’m from NY), but surprisingly good for not-​New York. Their Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza was excellent, though the toppings and crust kept falling apart.
I admit I came here on probably one of their busiest days, Parade Day, a full day bender-​I mean party day for senior students. Visiting my cousin who lived down the street, I came here four times in 24 hours, one of those times I was sober!
We ordered pizza and bought beer to go the first time. The beer is crazy overpriced, almost 3 dollars per bottle!
The second time I stumbled here for lunch and ordered the spicy garlic wings. They were very spicyl, and very garlic, and very messy, and very delicious. I had to wait a long time for them, though.
The third time we went into the bar for a bit, and left after watching someone pee behind the photo booth… You stay classy, Scranton.
The fourth time we went back for more pizza and got a bunch of pies (‘trays’ for you New Englanders), including the chicken bacon ranch, which also took a long time, but was worth it.
I would give two stars after the disgusting view of a drunk college student pissing on the floor… But I have to give one back for the workers on the pizzaria side. I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone working so hard for so long before. Bravo, but not cheers, because ew.

Good bar food for cheap. A coin-​op pool table and a golden tee. Real good beer specials… like 3 buck crafts. I thought the pizza and salad was good. Check Unilocal for deals. Would definetly go back.

Really Great Pizza, and loved the fact that they were open and delivered late. They were super fast for the delivery and I got a sweet deal from Unilocal.I flew in from out of town and not many places were open when I arrived at my hotel. Goodfellas was the SPOT to call on for my hunger. Glad they were around!

The only good thing about this place is they are open late. They are pricy their food is gross and they use American cheese on their uncooked pizza. Gross their burgers are always overlooked no matter how you order and everything taste like it was frozen and defrosted in a microwave. Three strikes and they are OUT in my book. Save your money and go to a better local place. Your better off cooking your own food then going here

Good Fellas is a great place to watch the game (s) and have a beer but definitely eat somewhere else beforehand.

Accept it is drunk food and you are good to go! Pizza has been sketchy in the past but the other food has been better than competitors and is faster to you front door.

I used to come here for many years when i lived in Scranton to watch the games and have some good bar food. I returned after 2 years only to be extremely disappointed. Pizza was raw, wings were «old» tasting if that makes sense, calzone was blah. Combine that with bar maids that don’t pay any attention to you and you have yourself a recipe for disappointment. The best thing about this bar? TV’s everywhere for watching football.

Prices are ok & the food is not bad… if you actually get it.
Order one — 2 specials both included soda — one soda was not delivered and the «hot sub» was more of a baked stromboli/​pocket
Order 2: from what I remember this order went ok
Order 3: WAITED 2 HOURS for delivery. All food was delivered but it’s inedible. One co-​worker had to leave with out even getting her lunch!
3 lunches of the coarse of a few weeks. few major mistakes. I doubt we will order here again

I was at a gathering and the food included a few trays of Goodfellas pizza. It was middle-​of-​the road pizza — although the Chicken Wing was nice. Sauce had a slightly burnt flavor to it, not sure if that was intentional. Either way, it’s ok after several cold ones.

Absolutely terrible customer service. They get your orders wrong a lot. Customer service skills are non-​existent. They actually argue with you when they get the order wrong. Completely unorganized, lack of management. No resolutions when they screw up and incorrectly charge you.

Meh for late night food, the only place besides Domino’s. For some reason they can never get a complete order correct, always forget something within your order. When you call back to mention that something is missing they seem too confused to resolve the situation. I recommend going somewhere else, or eat whats in your fridge at 2am.

Cheap beer for bums and greasy slop for college kids. Trashy, wannabe tough-​guy vibe. Everyone that works here is 2 seconds away from a venereal disease or jail, except for the Mexicans, who are personable and just want to do their job. Avoid at all costs. The parking lot makes no sense. There are two access points to the lot, one is a one-​way entrance, the other is always blocked by their delivery vehicles, forcing you to risk breaking the law by exiting their lot.

Goodfellas is decent for a late night order. Plus when you pick up your food you can grab a nice alcoholic beverage to wash it down.