The Sweet Tooth Fairy

Or not?
What happened?
Maybe they realized they could transfer this little gem to a lower rent district and still prosper. Sure hope so! Excellent product no doubt.
Baffling as to why they closed, I shall investigate.

They are moving to Chandler … I’m extremely sad but they are now offering twice a week delivery to the Scottsdale Quarters area due to the amount of disappointed regulars … I still love them and they still deserve 5 stars

Seriously amazing cupcakes!!!
Just the right amount of sweetness with out being too over the top sugary!
Unfortunately for me, The Sweet Tooth Fairy is one block from my office… totally helping me keep this baby weight on.
I’ve had cookies, cupcakes and cake bites from TSTF and ALL of them have hit the spot. My favorite is the toasted coconut cupcakes, its one serious cupcake!
The shop itself is very pretty and classic, I love all the marble and glass cases.

All I wanted when I came to The Sweet Tooth Fairy was a simple Carrot Cupcake as a finishing touch for my wife on our anniversary. Just a simple get in, get out operation. Little did I know that I would be confronted with so many different and tantalizing choices. The glass counter where the cupcakes are housed isn’t really all that large. Yet, somehow, they manage to fit an incredible selection of all different tastes and styles in that amazing little space.
At first, I was a little sad, because I didn’t see any carrot cupcakes. I was bouncing all around the case seeing fantastic visions of things called «Toasted Coconut», «Red Velvet», «Gluten Free Key Lime», «Peanut Butter Chocolate», and probably the most tempting of all, «Thin Mint». (The «Thin Mint», along with the «Somoa» are special cupcakes for the month of March, 2013.)
It only took me a moment to shake off the haze and finally find the Carrot Cupcake I so desperately desired. It was on the bottom shelf, looking amazing! When I went to order it, the young lady behind the counter confronted me with a conundrum. She asked how many I wanted. In reality, I only wanted one… but, I’m only human. I couldn’t really justify only bringing one cupcake home to a house of two women. So, I opted for a four pack.
I took a second look at the display case, and I found this adorable chocolate cupcake topped with blue frosting and a sour gummy rainbow on top of it for my daughter. It was as adorable looking as it sounds. For me, I REALLY wanted to get the Thin Mint cupcake. I asked the young lady if I would contract diabetes if I were to eat it. She laughed, but never really gave me a straight answer, so I didn’t get it. I opted for the Toasted Coconut instead.
There was one final spot left in the box. Like I said before, there were so many tempting options from which to choose, and I hate multiple choice tests. I always talk myself out of the right answer. However, I don’t know that there really COULD be a wrong answer with regards to delicious cupcakes. So, I settled (if you can call it that) on the Red Velvet cupcake.
For four cupcakes, I ended up paying just under $ 11.
When I brought them home, my wife and daughter were tickled pink! We were each very excited to take a bite of these delicious works of art. The flavors were each fantastic. There was a perfect ratio of icing to cake. The texture of each complimented one another perfectly. The cakes were soft and moist, while the icing was firm, yet still very fresh. That means it didn’t make an incredible mess when my four year old tore into it.
We don’t typically buy pastries. But, on the off chance that we get that urge in the near future, I feel like we’ve found a solid spot in North Scottsdale!

Was up in the area on a Sat afternoon with my daughter, and we just left the shop next door (Jimmy Johns yum!) and I was craving something sweet, I asked my daughter if she wanted to check out The Sweet Tooth Fairy and she said yep.
Once we walked into the shop I was amazed on how cute it is! Oh my gosh, it’s just too cute, like an old time candy store, loved it!
I had to make a choice so I picked a salted carmel chocolate toffee cupcake, oh it was delish! The cake was moist, the frosted, I couldn’t get enough of it, wanted to get a tub of it! And it was under 2.50, that’s a great bang for my buck!
Now I need to go back and try all the other cupcakes, can’t wait!

My sister and I decided to check this place out after hearing good things. The shop is really well located (next to Jimmy Johns and Five Guys) and can be seen right off Scottsdale Road. We walked in and were greeted with delicious smells, cute décor and a friendly staff member. Upon arrival, we were told all about Sweet Tooth Fairy and even the story of how they came up with the name of their vanilla cupcake. The cupcakes look pretty and delicious, so we decide to get 6. We ordered caramel apple, oreo, strawberry, smores, pb&j and cookie dough. The cookie dough was by far our favorite, tasted like a cookie and a cupcake! We also enjoyed the rest of the cupcakes, just not as good as the cookie dough. The only one we didn’t like was the smores… the cake just tasted off.
There were a lot of other goodies here that we didn’t try but would love to come back! Their cakes look amazing as well as their cookies, brownies, cake pops and loaves. I believe they also have a milkshake.
Overall, I liked it and would return if I was in the area and had a sweet tooth!

Driving down Scottsdale Rd., the husband and I found this gem tucked in between Five Guys and a Chipotle. Going in «for just a peek», we came out with two cupcakes and salivating profusely. The inside is spacious and airy with enough white and pink to seem whimsical. There are three display cases, each one having tempting delights. One is solely dedicated to Cake Bites — little bites of cake dipped in chocolate. Another case has Cupcakes and the last has an assortment of cookies, brownies, and bars. I am on a coconut kick and my eyes were immediately drawn to the three different types of coconut cupcakes they had — a Toasted Coconut, a Coconut Cream Pie, and a Pina-​colada. Needless to say, I was torn. After asking the friendly gal behind the counter, I decided on the Pina-​colada and the husband was generous enough to get the Coconut Cream Pie. Sorry Toasted Coconut — you’ll be eaten on the next trip.
Sure, the husband complained that the frosting on top looked skimpy, but one bite and he forgot all about portion size. The cake is soft, moist, and super flavorful. For the Pina-​colada, you taste the pineapple and the coconut in different dimensions. It’s sweet, maybe a little too sweet, but so good you lick the plate and suck on the fork hoping to get that last bit of moist cake. The Coconut Cream Pie has both frosting on top and a filling inside. The inside filling was okay, nothing spectacular. Pina-​colada definately won this round.
***
Four days later and we had to go back (since the sister-​in-​law was in town). This time we bought a half dozen for $ 13.50. We ordered 2 Pina-​coladas, a Toasted Coconut, a Salted Carmel, an Oreo Cookie, and a double fudge. The Toasted Coconut was good, but I’d dare say the Pina-​colada is better. I really enjoyed the Salted Carmel, but Husband thought maybe they should have done vanilla cake instead of chocolate (blasphemy!). Sister-​in-​law liked the Oreo but she’ll eat anything Oreo flavored. The double fudge wasn’t anything different than any other bakery — it was good, but I probably wouldn’t order again.
Overall, we would definitely go back — especially since every month they have new flavors. (Can we say pumpkin or eggnog cupcakes?) We won’t abandon Urban Cookies and their Ollie Cakes, but this will be our little secret.

My daughter went absolutely gaga over this place. So I made a trip… and it is a pretty nice little shop. I wasn’t completely blown away. They sell mostly cupcakes… and they are really good.
My two favorites are the Crème Brulee… ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! And the Raspberry Cheesecake… which has a real cheesecake base.
I tried one of the chocolate cupcakes, but didn’t find it anything special (it was good mind you), just not my fav.
I was surprised to see this is actually a growing «chain» of bakeries.
The other «clever» thing here is how this place is nestled directly between Jimmy Johns and Five Guys! Coincidence… I think not!