Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta

I’ve had the pizza here a few times, and the chicken parm pizza tastes great. I’m going the extra mile and posting a review here because I forgot to mention I had a coupon from one of their delivery menus and they took it anyway.

Pizzarelli’s is good for a quick bite on your way to or from the Metro North station or to or from the town of Scarsdale.
Classic New York slice.

Ordered a coupon special — a great deal– 2 hot delicious large pizza & a fresh crisp salad & 2 liter soda– came on time, delivered by «Mikey», very nice young man– and fed 6 people– who happily gobbled all but 2 pieces of pizza! Highly recommend this place — will absolutely be ordering again.

This place is great. I live on Garth road and often walk here with my wife and son. The food is great – and that’s saying something for a pizza place at a train station where all they have to do is open the doors to get customers.
The people who run this restaurant really care about their food and go the extra mile to make sure everything is right.
If I didn’t live down the road I would travel to eat their food – it’s that good.

Excellent pizza and I am very picky about pizza-​what a wonderful slice-​great mix of cheese and sauce and an incredible flavor-​very friendly staff-​what a new gem!

Easily the best delivery place in Scarsdale/​Hartsdale/​the world. Food shows up fast with a smile, and everything always tastes great. Highly recommend trying the rolls, which are a good sized meal and chuck full o’ whatever you wanted in them. Also really love the chicken bacon ranch wrap, but really, you can’t go wrong!

Amazing pizza and outstanding service. Had a slice of the plain pizza and it was awesone. Will definitely go back to try pizza with different toppings. So many appetizing things on the menu. This place is A+ in my book!!!

I pretty much don’t review stuff on Unilocal.Period. I’m just too lazy. But this is an exception.
So I was back in town for a bit, and really feeling some New York pizza after spending so long away from the area. Was feeling something new, so I hopped on Unilocal and found this place. Ordered a standard meat-​loaded pizza for pickup, blah blah, nothing special. But here’s where they got me as a customer for life:
I showed up a bit early to make sure I pickup my pizza right out of the oven, but I was looking around while waiting and somehow ended up eyeing up a Sicilian slice behind the counter. Seeing this, the woman running the show offered it to me. For free. Yes, seriously. Free.
I declined, as I had a whole pizza coming, but that’s something I’ve never seen before. A pizza place randomly offering a slice on the house just to try? ¹⁰⁄₁₀. This is something special, folks.
The pizza was great, too. No complaints about the food, just straight up good pizza. Any time I’m back in Scarsdale in the future, I know where I’m getting my pizza.

This little shop has some of the best food I’ve ever tasted in my life. Their buffalo chicken tenders are highly recommended as is the Marsala and the pizza is out of this world. I travel 30 minutes just to eat here! The customer service is incredible and they are so helpful at customizing each meal to my exact specifications. Five stars. If I could eat there everyday I would.

An authentic NY slice has been my favorite food since I’m a young kid and whenever I’ve moved away from the city I’ve immediately started my search for the best pizza in the area. Now that I’m living in the Scarsdale area and don’t make it into the city much, I’ve tried pretty much every pizza shop around here. Pizzarelli’s by far has the most authentic New York slice in the area.
I haven’t tried any of their other food but I definitely can vouch for the pizza!

Do a barell roll off the train and get into this pizzeria to get fucked up off all the specialty slices.
The service? These experienced professionals must be straight from the mother land, trained in the ancient art of pizza making. This pizza will headbutt your taste buds in the dick and take you on a ride straight down to flavor town faster than king da ka.
When I’m old, fat and missing my teeth, I’ll make my care taker blend this pizza up in a blender and dump it straight down my gizzard.
The establishment? Small clean and has the aroma of sexy succulent pizza. Thinking about having my wedding here but I can’t find a hoe worthy enough of this place.

I ordered twice to make sure it wasn’t a fluke, but this place seems to be the best pizza in the northern Yonkers/​Scarsdale area. The first was delivery, which was quick and no issues. The second was pick up, and they have some coupons in the store. Garlic knots were not good, they were either baked poorly or if fried they used no oil. Whatever, skip em, the pizza was very good. Will order again.

Pleasantly surprised at this teeny pizzeria at the Scarsdale Metro North Station. We sampled 3 different slices: Buffalo Chicken– excellent spice and not too greasy. Meat Lovers: Sausages, ground beef and pepperoni– what else can you say? Spinach: For the person who wants to pretend that there’s a healthy way to eat pizza. There were some ridiculously inexpensive specials, like a $ 5.00 chicken parmasean hero sandwich. Worth checking out!

I was really disappointed when I ordered pizza and chicken cutlet bacon wrap from here. I asked for the pizza well done, it wasn’t. And as for the bacon wrap– it was made with bacon bits– so that went right in the garbage.

SUPER FAST DELIVERY!
Pizza, Salad, and Subs are all terrific. Huge menu, lots of options! Delivery has always been faster then the estimated time and food has always been of high quality.

There are roughly 10 spots within a mile of Pizzarelli’s to get pizza. For better or worse, I’ve tried all of them.
The cheese slice/​pie at Pizzarelli’s can go toe-​to-​toe with any of them. They serve up a classic NY slice/​pie with the perfect sauce/​cheese ratio. The crust isn’t too doughy and is perfectly crisp. It doesn’t hurt that the guys there are super friendly too.
I look forward to working my way through the rest of the menu.