Best pizza in Sayville. The food is great but the delivery is hit or miss. I live 5 minutes away and have received cold pies an hour later. Their regular pies with or without toppings are fantastic though if you pick them up.
Missy M.
Classificação do local: 5 Sayville, NY
Never had a bad slice from here. Always go with the cheese because it doesn’t need anything to make it delicious. Garlic knots need a bit work but overall fantastic.
Flash F.
Classificação do local: 4 Holbrook, NY
If you are on Montauk Highway and the South Shore probably the best slice for five or six miles either way. Locals show their love on Friday night and the selection of specialty slices are adequate. Old school owners who know the neighborhood, only issues more napkins and powders.
S. S.
Classificação do local: 5 West Islip, NY
The most tasty pizza around! I love the Sausage and Onion pies. Sometimes at pizzerias they skimp out on adding lots of toppings, but not at Sals! Every pie is loaded with any of the many toppings to choose from. Also the calzone’s are huge! It can’t even fit on a large plate without the sides hanging off the edge. Jam packed with melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese and any topping of your choice(I prefer sausage). The garlic knots are mediocore but besides that, everything here is always amazing!
Richard W.
Classificação do local: 5 Sayville, NY
By far, the best Pizza on Long Island! Great staff, ingredients, equals GREATPIZZA!!! Enjoy!
Phil P.
Classificação do local: 1 Patchogue, NY
Pizza is always always raw under the sauce. It’s absolutely tasteless. Hope you like to get up over and over cause there to lazy to put napkins on the tables or any spices. You have to wait in line in only one place they have spices for slices. There always dirty and clogged up from lack of cleaning. The tables are always dirty. Your lucky if you don’t get sick from any of the chicken pizza’s left on the counter for 10 hours everyday. This is the bottom of the barrel for pizza.
Alicia M.
Classificação do local: 5 Woodbury, NY
Great pizza! I’m not the biggest pizza fan but at sal’s pizza it’s really good! Big shout out to Kathy who does delivery! She’s very sweet, upbeat and just a very cool girl and she’s always smiling.
Samantha M.
Classificação do local: 4 Central Islip, NY
Their specialty slices are HUGE. At first when I was told the total of my order I thought that it was extremely expensive, however, after seeing my 2 slices come out of the oven I realized it was almost 4 slices worth of pizza anywhere else! $ 1 for fountain drink refills is a terrible thing though.
Matthew M.
Classificação do local: 5 Miller Place, NY
Wow again sals shows up on time and exactly what I ordered. I needed a regular pie and a specially slice they took the time to make the specialty Slice Into pie. Bravo sals. Keep it goin
J H.
Classificação do local: 4 West Islip, NY
great sauce and service
Sean D.
Classificação do local: 5 Sayville, NY
Sals is one of if not the best pizza places on Long Island! Staff is very friendly the pizza is delicious three chicken rolls are awesome too!
Mike S.
Classificação do local: 3 Setauket- East Setauket, NY
Mediocre slices. Paid $ 9.00 for a «Caesar Salad» which was a takeout container filled with salad, a handful of croutons and what was most likely store bought dressing in a cup.
Heather G.
Classificação do local: 5 Islip Terrace, NY
Great slice of pizza and I’m a pizza snob! Perfect amount of cheese to tomato ratio. Thin crust too. Yum.
Michael D.
Classificação do local: 5 Copiague, NY
Ive posted a review before but to give an update, Great NY pizza. Quality cheese and the crust is really good… Best in town.
Vincent V.
Classificação do local: 5 Islip Terrace, NY
Great Service, they handled the Lunch rush great. Had some kind of loaded chicken slice that was excellent. Would go here again when working in the area! Be aware $ 10 minimum for Credit Cards which is fairly standard anyway in most pizza places.
Kasey C.
Classificação do local: 5 Patchogue, NY
Great affordable catering options. We were at a loss on what to have for a housewarming and the packages made it easy. The food was great although the sausage and peppers was a bit too salty for me. Would definitely order another catering order from them.
Lisa M.
Classificação do local: 5 Huntersville, NC
Thanks Sal’s for catering our affair last week the food was amazing everything tasted soooo good and your catering package worked out perfect for what we needed.
Roland H.
Classificação do local: 4 Yucaipa, CA
I have had pizza all over the US and Canada, this little place was surprisingly good. The dough and sauce had a good flavor, the ingredients were fresh, and the crispy bottom soft middle was a very nice touch. Don’t let the front outsode scare you off, it’s clean inside, prices are decent, staff are friendly, very quick cooking concept for lunch(I had 2 hot slices in 1 minute — no heat lamps here) and they were happy to add items to my slices.
Bobby J.
Classificação do local: 5 Sayville, NY
GOOD Olé SAL’S PIZZA :) BEST Pizza in Town! great location only a few seconds away from the house! Great pizza EVERYTIME Never fails to satisfy my pizza cravings ! and the inside is fantastic i usually order take-out BUT a few times i have sat inside and there is PLENTY Of room for people to eat and just a great atmosphere overall. REALLYRECOMMEND If you are taking a trip to Sayville! Will NOT disappoint! GOSAL’S YOUROCK!
Blaire R.
Classificação do local: 5 Loudoun County, VA
Just updating my review to remind you all that I still love Sal’s — best pizza on the planet, hands down. The guys behind the counter are really nice and the owner, who is ALWAYS there, is so sweet. Huge, clean dining room. They also serve wine :) All different kinds of pizzas with plenty of toppings for really reasonable prices. My husband was obsessed with the chicken bacon ranch. We sat down to eat three times and had take out twice while we were home for the holidays. It was only for 10 days. And no, I’m not ashamed. Do you think they would overnight me a large pepperoni pie if I asked really nicely?