Pizzeria Della Nonna

I have visited several times a week and the Greek salad is amazing… to bad the guy (possibly the owner) behind the counter is so rude. Not a warm, welcoming feeling at all. Made me wait 20 minutes to pay my bill one time. Never again, I will never go back and can not believable he is still in business.

Wow, absolutely fantastic, everything!
The food was absolutely fantastic fresh great sauce chicken Parmesan was incredible!
This is really a nice little place with fantastic food and great service!

Very good place for pizza. When in Sarasota this is our go to for pizza. The specialty pizzas are best. We have never eaten at the restaurant– only take out. But they are quick and courteous.

If you have not tried the lenguni and white clams yet, you have to. Not on the menu but what a treat to eat. They are fresh and plentyful. The best within 100 miles for sure.

OMG!!! This pizza is awesome! We ordered 2 small pizzas based on topping preferences! Both were fresh hot tasty and loaded with cheese! Love the thin crust crispy and perfect! The place is a bit small in the dining area — but there were not busy! Can’t wait to try some of their other items they offer like calzones, pasta & flatbreads!

Best pizza and antipasto in Sarasota — heck, all of Florida! BAM.
This is our go-​to place for great, fresh Italian food. We always get the antipasto that is loaded with fresh lettuce, delicious olives and meats wrapped in cheese and served with the chefs homemade Italian dressing that is incredible! The pizza is thin crust, hot, cheesy and melts in your mouth.

The thing I love most about this place is the pizza. The crust, also known as the perimeter of the pizza, is nice and thin. Most pizza places have a bulky perimeter of crust. I have yet to try anything else because I have only gone twice now, but so far this place is pretty good. I definitely recommend this for somebody who is in the mood for pizza. The prices look good-​for $ 11.95 you too can own a large 16 inch cheese pizza.
The guy sounds like he is Italian, so that is a plus. The atmosphere is actually pretty quaint and cozy. Another thing I liked is that he has the condiments nailed to the wall. This may seem like no big deal at first, but it frees the table space up for more om nom yumminess. The interior is not large, so if you plan on going there with a lot of people you have to call ahead of time so he can arrange the space for you. God speed and pizza on.

Ordered to go and changed our mind upon arriving to eat our pizza there. Cook was very unfriendly and made it seem like we were putting him out to allow us to put our pizza box on a table. When asking about a toothpick, he responded with only a finger pointing to them and a stern face. Our server was friendly even though he awkwardly stood in back the whole time watching us and the other guests.
Pizza was just ok. Could have definitely used more marinara. It was very hot and cheesy though which partially made up for the sauce.
I would recommend takeout to avoid the rude cook and extra sauce if getting pizza.

I’ve been going here for several years. You won’t get trendy décor… yes, it’s a little old school but clean (very important to me!). You won’t get an elaborate menu, either. What you will get is classic, good pizza and Italian food. We like the antipasto salad and a small pizza (maybe it’s a medium… they only have 2 sizes)…perfect for two. It’s comfort food :) Try it, you’ll like it!

Had the chicken Parmesan grinder, I wouldn’t recommend. Chicken was luke warm, I swear it he reheated it by slapping a piece of cheese on it melting in the pizza oven. I suppose though that I should have not gotten chicken parm at a place known for pizza. Pizza looked good. Guy working the counter was kind of rude.

My favorite pizza place in Sarasota! Just the right amount of sauce and nice crisp crust, especially when reheated. Love the gyro meat although I wish they were more generous with it as I always have to order double meat. Haven’t tried anything else on the menu.