Prime Selection

First time I’ve tried meat from anywhere other than a grocery store; great taste & quality. Despite mixed reviews, my boyfriend purchased the pork and chicken and I didn’t even save him any. The salesman that approached me didn’t make me uncomfortable and more importantly knew his product when I questioned him. One good attitude and employee is all it takes. Thanks!

Does it seem a little odd at first that someone is selling meat at your door? Sure. Is there maybe some sticker shock at first as well? Yes, until you realize just how much meat you’re getting. They also let you choose what you’ll actually eat. So far the meat we’ve had has definitely been high quality. Keep in mind, the meat won’t cook itself so part of it is up to you. But for us we’ve found nothing to complain about. Steak, chicken, seafood-​all top notch with great service.

UPDATE: today i cooked some chicken again and i think im in love with the bbq chicken flavor not the chicken itself. as i cookee i saw alot of fat being released and yestrday i cookee tritip. its very low quality very tough to chew and it has alot of fat-​_​– i totally regreat buying. I will not buy again. Dont be fooled .i think even food 4less offers better quality meat!
Today my husband came in the house while i was working out and i saw this 2men bringing boxes. i continued to workoit because it was non of my biss .then about 15mins to myworkout he comes to the room and askes me to come take a look. main consern was that im in a diet and i watch my carb and sugar and fat intake alot. and the guy convinced me how healthy they are. they looked great in the packages. .i cook chicken all the time and i notist it was well trimmed which i think its great. he wqs saying to try their chicken with rice in the oven for 25mins at 450 degrees. thats exactly what i did with the bbq season chicken. when i took it out. OMg it was deliciouss!!:)) the chicken was nice and juicyy. i really did loved the flavor. next time i take someout to cook i will post pictures. since i was military he gave me a deal half prime and half chicken for the chicken price and no tax and instead of paying in full he would charge my card on the 1^st and 15^th of the month for 2months which i thought was very convenient since i didnt have the money infull at the moment. the only thing thats sucks is that they said it was in bulk and it would last me a few months. i think thats a lie. in total i got 56pieces for 270some bucks .i tend to eat chicken everyday 56pieces for 2persons thats only 28days worth not monthss. thats 4 $ a piece. at the comissary i could get the same usda certified and organic or grass fed only alot cheaper. i did see alot of bad reviews but omg the chicken inmy personal opinion qas delicious and fast n easy to cool but i just hope the tritip are as good as the chiken. will see

I wish I could give them 0 stars. Prime Selection meat tastes like CRAP and is expensive as hell! Sadly my husband bought this horrible crap. We made it for dinner one night and it was so disgusting. We called to tell them it was gross and we didn’t like it. They said we had 3 days from purchase to return it and all of it has to be returned. How the hell are you suposed to know if you like it or not?! These people are peddling horse shit and they are the biggest crooks. If you see these people at your door… don’t waste your time answering and certainly don’t waste your money. We are now out $ 250 for meat that I would only use as dog food.

My husband and I just made our first order of meats and they were delivered today by Rich and Louie. They were exceptional with their customer service! Rich asked us about what food we are and did not pressure us to buy anything we didn’t like or wouldn’t use! Louie packed all the meat in our freezer and even labeled them for us! Great guys and great service! We are no longer buying meat at the grocery store! Thanks guys

It is 2016, so why is this company going door to door selling meat? It is bothersome and dangerous. I informed the staff not to do this in our neighborhood or at all and the implied I was mentally retarded (I have an advanced degree)

What a catch! I was looking for a good local spot to buy my relatives beef and fresh seafood for a big Christmas party we were hosting at the casa! My family loves to eat good quality beef so I needed a good quality place! I recently stopped eating beef and only eat fish but I still choose to go here for their fresh wild caught selections! I love their seafood because no one can compare to them. No one! They are also extremely friendly. I always look forward to seeing Chris when I go because he knows just what I like! My family members and I are very satisfied with Prime Selections! We will continue to order from them for generations to come! Thanks u guys!

I absolutely LOVE their meats. I grew up on a farm and my parents grew beef this is the best quality around I would know! They even gave me an extra box just for my birthday! Eric is the most friendly person I’ve ever met, and he doesn’t force or try to get you to buy anymore than you need. Val the lady who works in the office is so funny and sweet and she’ll always make sure you’re taken care of if you have anything bad to say about them then clearly you have the wrong company or have experienced a bad sales person. Hands down love them! The meats are priced amazingly and you can do payments. If you wanna be cheap be cheap if you want amazing quality, awesome service and guaranteed fresh meat then this is the place to get it. Even better perk I get to sit on my butt and wait for them to bring it! :)

Purchased beef from truck in neigborhood. Hard sell but I thought I would try some… Finally cooked two NY strips today. Pretty unimpressive on the tasting. Although they are supposed to be choice and aged, I found them very tough and lacking flavor. They were well packaged cryo vacuum packed, but really dropped the ball on flavor. They were no better than any select grade beef at the supermarket and cost was at a premium to the supermarket. I took a look at their teres major in the light and they are to be very dark or old. They look like beef that has been handled properly at slaughter at packing house. Looked like typical dark cutters due to lactic acid stress. I will call Prime Selection and have them honor their advertised 100% return guarantee. I was very disappointed. For the same price I can get high choice at Costco that tastes great. For a little more, I can frequently find prime cuts.
Dave D

My favorite company to buy my meat! Great customer service. Awesome salesman! The secretary even rocks! Thank you Prime for the home delivery service.

We were pressured into trying this selection of steak, seafood and ground sirloin. We have thrown out the sirloin after cooking it for a hamburger. The NY steak was too tough. The lobster tails were minuscule so I boiled 4 of them and had enough meat to make 2 salads.
Very disappointing all the way around. I did not like the hard sell and I did not like the young unknown man asking to use my bathroom. If I could return the rest I would in a heartbeat.

Got a knock on my door from a prime selection guy, said he would give me a great deal on steaks seafood chicken and pork. Hey Meatman, where have you been all my life! i’m loving that everything was portioned with a 12 month guaranty. I made the best pork chops last night that were juicy and flavorful :) if you want a good steak try these guys out

I ran into Sammy and he showed me a case of steak. I bought it and he even stacked it in my freezer for me! I like that it’s all individually wrapped. I always end up throwing meat away from the store because I can’t go through it fast enough. He threw in some salmon as well and they make a great date tonight together!

I visited prime selection with very little knowledge on meat products. I didn’t understand the difference between supermarket quality and «prime selection «but there is such a thing. So, I went in and asked for help. Luckily, I happened to come in when the inventory manager was on duty. He introduced himself as Roger and quickly went to work asking me what type of meat I like. If it weren’t for Roger I never would have known the difference between grass fed beef and other types of cuts. Customer service was two thumbs up. If you are looking for a good company to purchase quality product this is it!

I can honestly say that I have been purchasing steak and seafood from Chris for over 5 years. I’m reading some past reviews and I think these people have nothing better to do with their time. I have always had great product and amazing service. My family and I buy from Chris every time because we know he always comes through. I give prime selection 5 stars and hope to keep buying from them for years to come. I hope some people give them another chance.

My mom had been ordering steaks and seafood from Chris for years and now that I live on my own, I have to also cuz I can’t live without em!
My newest favorite was one I think called the teres major, my boyfriend always goes with the ribeye. You also can’t go wrong stocking up on these burgers for any backyard barbecue or tailgating. They even have ostrich burgers! My favorite from the seafood is the jumbo cooked shrimp. Perfect for an easy cocktail! Be sure to check them out. Such a great deal!

I would rather eat the butt off of a skunk than to ever eat/​purchase meat from Prime Selects again. I was suckered into buying from the truck and I am not even upset about their sales techniques or lack there of. Once I got over the sticker shock of my purchase, I got excited about the fact that I had a freezer full of «Natural/​Organic/​Grass Fed» protein, ranging from beef, chicken and seafood.
Fast forward to a weekend where I was having friends over for dinner and decided to break out the case of New York Strip Steaks. They looked nice but the taste was something else. Not only were all of the steaks in the case tough and had large amounts of fat (not marbled fat) but all of the beef had a fishy flavor. All of the steaks were thrown away and we ordered pizza.
Giving it another chance I went and pulled out 4 individually packaged, herb marinated and 2 honey mustard flavored free range organic chicken breasts to defrost them for grilling. Grilled them up, tasted them and immediately spit out the bite I had in my mouth (the rest of my family did too). The flavor on the honey mustard one was so overwhelming, I couldn’t taste the chicken. The flavor of the herb marinated was ok but the quality of all the chicken was sub par at best. It was rubbery and tough. All of the chicken was thrown in the trash, just like the steaks were.
On to the payment aspect of this «company». I put a deposit down and then filled out carbon copies for future debits (which would be taken out on the specified days) to payoff the debt I incurred when purchasing all of the not great quality of meats. They stopped by my house at 7:30pm and demanded that I pay the amount due because they hadn’t gotten their payment yet. I showed them the receipt copies that I was given when I first signed up with them no more than three weeks ago and was told that my receipts weren’t good enough and I need to make my payment at that moment. When I questioned the rep, and asked for the number to finance or his supervisor I was told to look it up on line because he didn’t have the number on him. At that point I told him to take the meat that was left, since I was guaranteed 100% satisfaction and I would then cancel the service. the rep then told me that he wouldn’t take the meat back and would not leave until he got his payment. Umm no. That’s not how things work. Once my husband came to the door and threatened him, he finally left.
I will be calling the office tomorrow to have them come pick up their poor quality, over priced product and to cancel the rest of my payments.

I don’t take time to write many reviews, but my experience with Prime Selections makes me want to vomit. I was introduced to them by a friend that said they came by him with a missed delivery of a neighbor but had a good price on grass fed beef. So I took the sob story and got a couple boxes thinking the price was good. This meat is terrible, so bad some cuts are throw away because of the amount of fat and connective tissue. The burgers are ok, but the steaks I won’t even feed to my dog. Horrendous beef!

Did not like their sales pitch at all. High pressured and full of b.s. Claimed that some people who were customers in my neighborhood weren’t home — their usual spiel. Asked for a business card and they claimed they had none. They said I could Google them. What kind of legitimate outfit has no business cards or sales brochure?
Weird part is that they singled my house out of dozens on my street. Zoomed away when I told them no.
Thank goodness for Unilocal.Saved myself a lot of money.
If you see a small refrigerated truck in front of your house that says Prime Selection with the web address
do not answer the door.

Horrible meat and very deceitful sales staff. Would recommend you buy any where but here, wish someone gave me this advise, especially since they target military families.