St. James Pizza

Was looking for a nice place to eat while waiting on my car to be fix and found this pizzeria, bought combo #1 one large pie with a tossed salad and six garlic knots, 3 drinks for a total of $ 32.00 not bad
Pizza was so fresh and yummy, nice place and people are very friendly

A ‘Master’ Pizza maker… Turning out masterpiece pies…
A fully cooked sauce… (can you believe some places get away with serving an almost raw sauce)!? over REAL MOZZARELLA and layered w/​presentation in mind…
My #1 pizza guy… Russell

Ok so let me just say I had to dl the app to right this and I never right reviews ! But this place is amazing! The guys are so nice, they always remember you and are personal amazing service and the food is to die for! Best pizza I have had in saint James !! Not to greasy and so much to chose from. Highly recommended !

This is our go-​to pizza place now. The family specials are awesome and priced right! The pizza is great… and their Fresh Mozz pie is yummy and decently priced. The heroes were absolutely awesome and the weekly specials are good for a last minute treat.

Called from the road to order on way home, they wouldn’t honor their online coupons which were expired. Didn’t want to go home 1^st and search for a paper coupon. They would get 3 stars for food but arrogance gets them 1. Inconvenient location. Best pizza in town is still Rocco’s.

TOP NOTCH SERVICE! The food Is EXCELLENT! This isn’t your every day pizza joint. I work locally, we order from St. James Pizza all the time. SAL runs a tight ship. If you live, work or are just passing through St. James you have to give it a shot. –Nick
p. s.- Try the rice balls!

I was not expecting much, this was a burger joint a few years back and when this place opened I had it in my mind that new pizza places are not usually very good, I thought I would walk in and see an American or maybe some Mexicans behind the counter. Nope, looks and sounds like it’s run by authentic Italians!!! I got a plain Sicilian slice and one of those gourmet bbq chicken slices. I know, why am I so worried if it’s run by Italians if I just go and order a bbq slice right? It does sound stupid. Anyway, the bbq slice was excellent, the bottom was so crispy that’s I could hold it by the crust and it would not bend even with all the chicken and BBQ sauce on it, they must do that on purpose so it does not get soggy and I applaud that. The Sicilian slice was also good, just not hot enough to really enjoy, I guess it was not in the oven long enough and I are it 2^nd. The tomato sauce on it was outstanding though and so was the cheese so I’m guessing everything else is good too. I will be back for sure.

Better than the average local pizza joint, St. James pizza is making great regular and specialty pies and dishes. The Grandma’s Pie with Vodka Sauce is an indulgence well worth the $ 22.
Funny, friendly crew that is straight out of a NY pizza parody.

Great Sicilian and regular slices. Nice employees… Sometimes they throw in some zeppolis. Yum!

Excellent pizza, both regular and sicilian! Staff super friendly and very accommodating! Happy to be a new regular customer! You must try, you’ll be glad you did!

So glad this place opened! It’s literally 3 blocks from home and they deliver too!
We come from Queens originally and have only been able to find what St. James calls upside down sicilian in a favorite of ours in Queens (where they call it red sicilian). It’s sicilian pizza with the mozzarella cheese on the dough, then the sauce on top and some grated cheese on top of the sauce. It’s so delicious because the cheese doesn’t flop off of the top of the pizza — and the crust stays extra crisp — love it!
We’ve had their regular pizza too which is good and their sausage rolls are also like Queens — with green peppers and onions in the roll, not just sausage. Chicken rolls are good too and my friends have had their soups which they say are good.
Give it a try — you won’t be disappointed!

Living just off of Middle Country rd, I was excited to find out a new pizzeria had opened within walking distance of me! We’ve had nothing but a good experience each time we’ve been there. Even when there was a very minor issue with our order one time, they IMMEDIATELY fixed it above & beyond our expectations. This place promotes quality food with top notch customer service!