Bommarito Bakery

The pizza and pastries are fantastic! The service is always given by friendly folks. The prices are so good for the quality food and service you are getting. Highly recommended!

LOVE this place! Their cannolis have been a staple at my family’s birthday parties for years now (we do cannolis instead of cake.)
I also love their pizza and casata cake!
Here’s a tip, make sure to grab a number when you walk in!

I love this place! Truely the last of a dying breed. Amazing sandwiches, I recommend the italian with hot peppers. Their pizza is legit as well. It isn’t near my house, but when I work near there, I always stop in. Try it, you won’t be disappointed! The reason for a four star is because it is a little caotic and unorganized while you order/​wait for you food. But does feel like you stepped back in time.

I don’t understand all the hype about this place. I grew up in GP, so I know a lot of people like it there. I keep going back after I visit my grandfather, thinking I’ll like it but I don’t. The subs really aren’t that good. It’s the bread people say – no it’s really not that good. We just had subs there two days ago and I’m still sick from them. Right after my husband and I ate, he was sick and then later on I was. I’d rather have a sub from Potbelly, Jimmy Johns or Tanias. Also, the staff there is extremely rude. Never will understand all the hype. Totally overrated.

I gave this bakery. five stars… wish I could give it six. Absolutely amazing pastries and fresh ricotta that will make you think your in Sicily itself. Family means from the heart and you can tell by the food that comes out of there that they cook with a passion.

I started with three stars because many of my coworkers love their subs, however I did not like their veggie sub it was pathetic it was 18 pieces of cheese, one single layer of iceberg lettuce, 5 banana pepper slices, 4 tomatoe slices, a tablespoon of onions. Pathetic, they could have added an incredible amount of more vegetables and not just replace the meat with cheese come on veggie is supposed to be healthy not artery clogging

Love this Italian bakery and shoppe featuring authentic Italian cookies, mouth-​watering and delicious submarine sandwiches on homemade sesame bread (A local favorite), wonderful staff and run by the family for over 90 years.
Try the baked ricotta cheese, Italian breads, lemon ice, or a slice of their Terrasini thin crust pizza with spicy pepperoni and Italian seasonings; or order an entire pizza… can’t miss at this local gem.

Okay Italian food with an Italian shakedown as well. If you want to literally have your money stolen from you via fraudulent charges then they can do that. If you like to have people try and give you the wrong change I hear that’s a specialty. Or maybe you want to be given receipts that aren’t itemized so they can make up a total. Perfect for those who don’t value money or integrity and want a decent sub.

Great place in the shores! Wonderful $ 5 pizza and amazing baked goodies. Great selection of authentic Italian foods along with small wine selection. Overall great place. Stop in and grab a number!

As I walked by the cooking area doors on the parking lot side, I saw a rather large man laying on the prep table with basketball shorts on. Rather than coming in and ordering a sub as planned, I decide to continue on my walk with my kids because that was kind of disgusting. I felt it necessary to call up there to explain to a manager why they missed out on my business today, she defended the cook. Apparently he was authorized to sleep on the prep table because he had woken up early that morning. She did promise me that the table would be cleaned after he woke up. Lol. It’s a freaking table where you cook food on, you don’t sleep on it, that’s ridiculous

Best subs EVER! You can get sweet or hot peppers fast service family owned. I have been going here my whole life so gooood.

My fiancé loves this place. We cannot drive past it without him stopping in for a Muffaletta. I don’t care for it too much. We did order my son’s first bday party sub from here. I scheduled a pick up time of 12 with guests arriving at 1. My fiancé left at 11:30 to drive to pick it up and didn’t make it back until 1:15. Now, he may have stopped to eat his Muffaletta on the side of the road, but I doubt it. He stated that it was packed in there, and still had to take a number and wait at the counter. Now that seems a little silly to me — why would I schedule a pick up time if he can’t pick it up then? He should have been able to just go to the cashier and pay and pick it up. Needless to say I am a fan just because it’s a family owned bakery and my fiancé has been coming here for years.

One of the best Italian bakeries around. Their cannoli and eclairs are perfection. Great subs, very good pizza, breads and gelato. They also have a huge wine selection. The staff are fast, efficient and friendly. They are often busy but the line moves quick.
Damn, I can’t stop thinking about the eclairs… mmm…so good!

I was not impressed. For such amazing reviews — the sub was just average and missing taste. The pizza looked old sitting in the warm case. :(
Also — the clerks had an uninterested attitude and it reflected that they could not care I was there.

Awesome local Italian Bakery. Subs made with fresh bread and Pizza by the slice (excellent spicy sauce) are great tasting and good value especially if you are on the run and in a hurry for lunch. My two fav cookies are the fig (made with real fig) and pine nut… not too sweet and just right.
Be sure to grab a number off the counter if it is busy to get prompt service!

When going to a dinner party, I usually stop in Bommarito’s and pick up some special treats for the host/​hostess. They dig it.
The bakery cookies are super fresh and delicious-​just like homemade-​with the peanut butter and coconut macaroons being my top favorites.
Freshly baked loaves of Italian bread and rolls, rows and rows of Italian wines and groceries, best pizza in town, Italian subs, cannoli, gelato and just about anything else you could possibly want to make your tummy happy.
Would you laugh at me if I told you Bommarito’s is what keeps me living on the Eastside?

Okay I’ll admit that this place is something special. I talked to a regular while I waited for my pizza and they definitely gave me the same vibe that I got from reading these other reviews. According to the gentleman I was talking to he was surprised that this place wasn’t busier while we were talking. Has the «old east side» feel that I love so much, the service was good and there is a lot to take in at once. I think I may need to look around the next time I go in.
I ordered a large pepperoni, small cheese bread, and two cannolis. Grand total $ 14 and change, what a deal! Got home, chowed down and I couldn’t be happier. Everything was good, I can’t gripe about this place. Pizza was cheesy, the pepperoni had good kick, and the sauce was really nice as well. The sauce is thinner than a lot of places and I really enjoyed that. Cheese bread was awesome! The flavor was spot on and there was no skimping on the cheese. The cannolis were really good (typically I only have cannolis when my grandma makes them but took a gamble here and it paid off). This place is solid you won’t regret it!

The house of homemade everything!
You take three steps in from the door and it’s wine to the right, donuts and pastries to the left, frozen goodies to your 7 o’clock and fresh baked bread right in front of you.
If you’re stopping in for a quick lunch, then call in your order ahead of time and pick it up. Why? Because this place jumps and the two people in line ahead of me cleared the place out of everything from pizza slices, whole pizzas, cheese bread and they ordered subs. We realized it was going to be a 20 minute for just about everything as these two customers caught the place off guard. No big deal though, we just took a look around the store and decided to come back on another day.
Great selection of Italian products from olive oil, canned tomatoes, capers, pickled products. Finally, I can get my anchovies, capers and giardiniera in larger quantities.
Fair warning Bommarito Bakery: my next visit is business!

This is a cool place in town that is great for foodies and wino’s, right in a good location.
I recently had my first experience here, per fellow Unilocaler reccomendations. The parking lot near the front was packed so we just parked on the back — no big deal. It is easier to get in and out anyway.
You walk in and take a number and wait. We showed up at 5 pm on a Saturday so we waited about 30 minutes as it was packed. But we looked around and saw everything… fresh rolls, pizza slices, pasta, hundreds of bottles of wine, scones, doughnuts, homemade pasta sauce and olive oil, fresh meats and cheeses, and many other sweets.
I ordered the prosciutto and cheese sub. It comes on a sesame seed sub sandwich with either mild or hot peppers, lettuce, onions, tomato and your choice of dressing. It was $ 9 and was pretty good but not great as I had hoped. It was not as good as the prosciutto at Ventimiglia’s, sadly, but it filled me up. (I don’t think the employee making the sub actually had gloves on and that was mildly frightening. I think I have Ebola now. Just kidding… maybe.)
The girlfriend got three slices of pizza: one cheese round slice, square pepperoni and a round feta and spinach pizza. She only really liked the cheese slice; I didn’t try any of them besides the cheese, which was quite good.
The best part was that a sub, three slices and an Arnold Palmer cost me less than $ 14. That was cool. There is so much to choose from and it’s a cool place, kind of old fashioned and I like that. Don’t see many places like it anymore. I wish the prosciutto was like the Ventimiglia’s one, though, but oh well. What can you do.
It’s worth a stop in to check everything out and buy items at great values. The service is good and the ladies are very nice behind the counter.

I drove from Troy on the recommendation to eat many things here, but mostly the Italian sub on their house baked bread. This is how you Bommarito.
1. Get a cannoli or 16 or die.
2. Never order the Italian Submarine Sandwich (skimpy meat $ 5.79)
3. Always order the Italian Sub Buster (extra meat $ 6.99).
4. Get angry and rage at all the good looking pizza if you like za.
5. Get out alive.