Jersey Mike’s Subs

The foods pretty good
but something that you don’t get at most restaurants is great personality I’ve never seen the same worker twice but I always see the great upbeat how’s your day going attitude from every associate you don’t really see that anymore anywhere so kudos to you Jersey Mike’s in Rochester

I am a repeat customer of the Rochester Road Jersey Mike’s Subs shop. The subs have us ADDICTED. By far the best subs in my opinion. The staff are ALL above average. Always going above and beyond to make sure your experience at the shop is amazing. I don’t believe I have EVER had such interactive, fun sandwich makers take my order before. The pricing may be a few dollars more than the average sub, but it is worth it with the quality and awesome service! Grab your sub «Mikes Way» and it is made to perfection every time!

My husband and I started going to this Jersey Mikes when it opened. We have always had beyond great service! Nolan, especially, is genuinely kind and friendly. He is always the happiest guy and very social. He makes you feel like he truly enjoys his job and seeing you in the shop! The service is what keeps us coming back!
The food is great and fresh. A good serving size. The prices aren’t bad but they are higher than we would normally spend for a quick dinner. Overall, a great place for a quick bite.

Expensive but tasty sandwiches. Also, there are only two choices of soft white or soft wheat bread. The regular sandwich is only seven and a half inches long. Not quite enough for me for a lunch, yet it cost me $ 10.

Incredible customers service! Basically ruined it for the rest of the sub shops! Try the # 99!

Not happy about this place. Too much lettuce, no meat on my sandwich. Paid way too much for what I took home. Won’t be returning.

Best costumer service I have ever experienced. Always friendly and welcoming. Doesn’t matter how busy they are, they make sure each costumer feels special. Keep up the good work Mike’s!!!

I’m not into sub shops, but my sister insisted we try something different for dinner. The employees were awesome and the subs tasted great. Definitely fresh. Being my first time I asked the what he recommended and i definitely wasn’t disappointed. He recommended the turkey bacon and it was pretty delicious. My sisters steak and cheese was good too!

This is my go-​to spot when I don’t have an appointment for lunch. The staff probably thinks I’m a loner. The subs are made with high quality ingredients. Love the bread, the sandwiches are a notch or two better than Jimmy Johns and Firehouse, and much better than Subway. Hard to find a good cold Sub. The staff is friendly and efficient. It was just shy of ten bucks for a regular size sub plus chips and a water. And we’ll worth it. Seems like a healthy choice.

I crave their cheese steaks ! The chipotle cheese steak is definitely amazing and always made quickly. I’ve had thee regular subs and always tasted fresh also. A great place to grab a sandwich.

Love subs from this place, I get the italian everytime. Honestly not much more than getting a footlong from Subway and ten times better. Love how everything is sliced fresh in front of you.

Top of the sub chains. I really like their jersey point system. A touch expensive but worth it. If you like cheesesteak and spicy, try the Big Kahuna #56 .my fav.

Food is very good and consistent. But the real reason I feel good about spending money there is the staff is always very friendly and willing to take an extra moment to have a real connection. It can get a little bit pricey but the value is there if you look for it.

My favorites are the Cheese Steaks! While it is nothing to write home about, I’m a fan.
They are fast, friendly, clean and on the ball.
They have a good selection of subs and all the ones I have tried are fresh and very tasty. I prefer the hot subs, but the cold ones are very good too.

— Fresh and Fast!
— Great Variety
— You can get anything as a «sub-​in-​a-​tub» (salad)
I’ll start off by saying my favorite here is the «99 plus Cherry Pepper Relish». This sub of greatness is a hybrid of the Big Kahuna (#56 — steak and cheese with onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños and extra cheese) and the Chipotle Steak (#43 steak and cheese with onions, peppers and chipotle mayo). The steak and toppings are always cooked perfectly, and the jalapeños and cherry pepper relish add the right amount of heat.
Today, I got the #6 Famous Roast Beef and Provolone as a sub-​in-​a-​tub. I subbed Swiss for the Provolone and got the tub with onion, tomato, pickle and that awesome cherry pepper relish. This combination was also fantastic. The relish mixed just right with the roast beef and Swiss to make a nice refreshing (albeit HUGE) salad.
The staff is always nice here, and they know how to push out a great product. You can get any sub as a wrap or salad, and this place uses the freshest of ingredients. Take it from a regular… try anything here, and you won’t be disappointed.

This is basically the sub sandwich equivalent of «Jake’s Wayback Burgers» (see my review on that): not a commonplace Subway of Jimmy John’s clone, nor a factory of oversized monstrosities like Dibella’s, but a strong middle-​tier candidate. They’re genuine, solid, and faithful, much like the geyser.
They make a mean Italian sub, and they cut up the meat right there, which is nice to see and makes me feel better about what I’m eating. Though you can customize what you want on it, they’ll often ask you if you want it «Mike’s way» (basically everything, much like Jake’s across the street). What an amazing lunch delight! Sure, you’re gonna throw down a little more coin than your round-​the-​corner chain, but I sure appreciate some solid ingredients when I get them.

In the war of over-​priced sandwich shops, there is no shortage of combatants here in Rochester. We have Jimmy Johns, Chomp, a variety of bistros, and now we have Jersey Mikes. Seeing that they were somewhat new in town, I had to give them a try. Initial glance at the menu shows your standard sandwich shop selection, italian, turkey, ham, club, etc. All meat is sliced at the time the sandwich is ordered. There is a modest selection of fresh veggies along with the expected condiments. So far so good. Then come the prices. noticably more expensive than Jimmy Johns. Sandwiches are a dollar or more more expensive here at Jersey Mike’s.
So I proceed to order, I went with the Original Italian prepared «Mike’s way» (everything on it). As I mentioned, the meat is frreshly sliced for each sandwich, which is nice. My disappointment started when I saw how small a regular sandwich actually is… only 7.5 inches. Again, compared to Jimmy John’s quite small. Jersey Mike’s is losing so far. Time to eat.
The sandwich itself was admittedly very good. The dressing and seasoning were very flavorful, the bread was great and the ingredients were fresh. All in all it was a very satisfying sandwich, the problem is I was still hungry when I was finished. Perhaps I should have ordered the «Giant size»… but it is $ 12.95 and there is no way in hell I am paying that much for a sandwich when I could elsewhere and get a steak for the same price.
The verdict: Good sandwich, probably equal to Jimmy Johns in terms of quality and taste, but terrible value. I doubt I’ll eat here again.
Pros: Fresh ingredients, friendly staff, great tasting dressing
Cons: Way over-​priced, skimpy serving size

I really like this Jersey Mike’s! The staff is really friendly and willing to answer any questions you have. I have been limiting my bread, luckily at Jersey Mike’s you can get any sub in a tub — it makes an amazing salad! Not very often can I say a salad filled me up, but at Jersey Mike’s it did! I try and visit here anytime I am in the neighborhood.

Although it’s late at night, 20 minutes until closing Tony gave me 5 star service.
It was a busy day of work, errands & the gym, plus several protein shakes & the only food of substance throughout the day was 6 ounces of crushed lentil soup.
So finally venturing home at 8:30, I wanted a Qdoba naked burrito, BUT the Qdoba at Auburn & Rochester Rd. is less than sub par, as Ive gotten sick there twice.
I had hoped to try Chipotle, but I would have been the 12^th person in line, okay so the new Jersey Mikes it is!
[ sorry for the rabbit trail, but I felt the need to explain my hunger & dilemma ]
Walked in & got the over the top welcome to Jersey Mikes from Tony, a very positive & energetic young man!
He inquired what brought you in today?
«That I was hungry»!
Oh I thought you came in for the charity promo?
I replied: I did get an email abotu it, ty for the reminder:
Every Jersey Mikes on 3−27−13 donated 100% of sales to local charities, VERY NICE 7 97.1 Stoney & Bill broadcast live from 5:30 — 10 am
Okay back to dinner, Ive been on a bread sabbatical throughout lent, so it was a Hersey Mikes «SUB IN A TUB» for me!
I ordered the club — mini
Turkey –Roast Beef– Ham — Bacon Provolone Cheese-​Chopped Lettuce-​Jalapenos –Banana Peppers-​Pepper Relish-​Thin Sliced Onions– with plenty of that MIKES WAY DRESSING!
Oh My Goodness!
It was truly a delight for my tummy!
And am plotting my next visit!
Tony also turned me onto & signed me up for the Jersey Mikes Rewards probram

Fresh bread = fresh yum!
This was my first visit to this chain. I enjoyed the #56 Big Kahuna cheese steak and added Chipotle mayo and cherry pepper relish! The bread was fresh with a nice chew. Held up very well to the moist steak and cheese. The steak was super tender. I’m excited to go back and try a traditional Italian sub. They have red-​wine vinegar and oil that is supposed to be super yum.
The inside was extremely clean, and staff very pleasant. I’m not sure it has a different ‘niche’ than say Dibellas Old Fashion subs, or other shops. They have some wraps which sound yummy, and aren’t in the mainstream sub shops. The cheese steaks are an exciting option for me.