Milton’s Pizza and Pasta

I was not satisfy AT ALL with the pizza. The customer service was horrible and it’s way over priced. The tomatoes was soggy and I question the freshness of there ingredients.

20+ years and I am going to assume this was a moonphase — because on Saturday night Jan 2 2016 anything that could go wrong went wrong — from having to get my own refills to unusually slow service — just BAD! We will be back as we have every couple weeks for almost three decades — but if this stays the same we will find elsewhere! Sad!

Since 1990 I have been coming to this restaurant with my family. I had numerous birthday parties posted throughout the years at this restaurant. For the past several years I’ve noticed a major decline in this restaurant. Back in 2010 I used to come here with my mom once a week to get pizza until she passed in 2011. Since I’ve moved back to the area recently I’ve gotten sick to my stomach just about every time I’ve come here and been disappointed in their food and staff.
I went for lunch about 2 days ago and had to wave different servers down just to get a glass of water. The worst is the night after eating their pizza and salad bar I got a flu bug that has had me in the bathroom with diarrhea now for 2 straight days. I have contacted the health department for this reason. Never again will I eat at this restaurant. You have seriously lost a very long time customer. You are screwed Miltons pizza. The health department will most likely shut you down for unsanitary conditions. I repeat do not eat here!

Salad was fresh, pizza was great and dessert was wonderful. Everyone, from the hostess to the waitresses to the manager, was super friendly and provided a comfortable, enjoyable dining experience.

Let me put it plain and simple. If you want pizza, you go to Milton’s. It’s that simple. Do not venture off anywhere else because you will be disappointed. If I could put 1000 stars I would. Everything is great, pasta, pizza and salads. It’s always a treat whenever I get to go feast at Milton’s.
Keep it up!

The wait staff, especially Leslie, rocks. The Spinach Artichoke dip is this crazy good mousse like creation that will not leave you worrying if you have spinach caught in your teeth all night! The Chicken Parmesan pizza will leave you wanting more when you are done. This place is a can’t miss!

Good family restaurant. Food was par for the course. Maybe a bit to much money fit food quality ect. Overall not to bad

I’ve been here a couple times now. It’s pretty good pizza. Their marinara is on point! My only criticism is that I prefer thin crust. Theirs isn’t too thick, but I like it thinner. Still very good pizza with quality toppings. I would certainly recommend this place to others.

I can’t believe I haven’t heard of Milton’s sooner! We stopped by for a late Friday dinner and the place was still pretty packed. The interior was divided into two sections: on the left was the bar and a few tables around it and the right were the brightly lit booths. I really liked this atmosphere because you could choose if you wanted a quieter, less well-​lit area or the family-​friendly booth seating. We opted for the bar area and a waitress promptly greeted us and got our drink orders. We wanted an appetizer of the garlic bread but our waitress informed us that we get free bread and she could go ahead and bring us an order – hence saving us $ 8.99. The free bread is amazing!!! It is garlic bread with homemade marinara sauce but it is full of oily, savory garlic goodness. We probably ended up getting 3 orders of the bread (not counting the order we got to-​go) as it was so good.
For entrees, we ordered the fettuccine Alfredo and the Tuscan pesto pasta (basil pesto sauce with chicken and roasted red peppers). I typically have low expectations for fettuccine Alfredo because I assume the sauce will be heavy and tasteless. Not Milton’s! The sauce was creamy and flavorful and the perfect consistency to fill every mouthful with deliciousness. The Tuscan pesto pasta was great too (the fettuccine Alfredo was the winner of the meal though). The peppers and chicken provided great textural additions and soaked up the sauce wonderfully. The sauces were both quite oily however, as I found out opening the takeout containers the next day. If you don’t mind high-​oil and high-​fat sauces that taste amazing, this is the place.
I can’t wait to come back for more of that garlic bread and to try their pizza!

Got take out as it is our Sunday tradition. We ordered the chicken Alfredo pizza. the large is certainly enough for 2 to have 2 meals. Crust is nice, light and they have the perfect crust: topping ratio! Roni rolls are also a must! Can’t wait to explore the menu more!

Pizza was filled with toppings, the crust was delicious and the sauce was tangy and sweet. Service was attentive, friendly and helpful. It was our first time there but it will be one of our regular dining out options from now on. We had the Hawaiian and salad bar, which was well stocked and often refilled with veggies. Great experience!

OMG the pizza at Milton’s is gooood! A friend of mine introduced me to this place because she has to eat a gluten free diet and they have a gluten free menu. I had a small one person pizza with sausage and peppers and other goodies on it. It was to die for. I absolutely loved it and I am pretty picky about pizza.

We love this place! Great for families and kids of all ages! The lunch buffet is so tasty! I love the grilled veggies as well as pizza! I come here as often as possible!

I went here with my aunt about two weeks ago while visiting Raleigh an I must say the food was absolutely amazing i had the fettuccine Alfredo dish it was an fresh an the salad bar was fully stocked an maintained very well an the waitstaff was really nice I would definitely pay them a visit when I’m in Raleigh again

Half price bottles of wine on Wednesday, need I say more! There pizza, pasta and salad bar are all delicious!

Like others, I’m not a buffet person, and this buffet, like others, has its ups and downs.
We arrived early, just as the place was opening, and our party of 14 was seated promptly, drinks were prompt and I don’t think any of us ever had an empty glass.
The pizza was pretty darn good, especially the pizza with the jalapeños on it. The salad and greens on the salad bar were also fresh.
Service was terrific, however, as with any buffet there was a pitfall or two: the pasta tasted «meh» and was soggy, as it also seemed to be the case with the meatballs — just «meh». Freshness for the hot foods seems to be sacrificed for volume and here is where I would probably prefer to order directly off the menu rather than settle for the buffet.

This is a good place for fatties, and I am their queen.
I’ve been here 3 times and I’ve left absolutely stuffed after each meal. Giant portions, giant salad bar, garlic bread served with many of the entrees. I waddle home each time. It’s an Americanized Italian menu with a home-​style diner-​feel.
Service has ranged from great to acceptable, and even when mediocre, the waitstaff are clearly trying (sometimes the problems seem to just be inexperience).
I don’t recommend the mixed drinks here though. Was it called the raz-​ma-​tazz? I can’t remember, my traumatized tongue asked my brain to forget. Yuck.
Otherwise, looking for a LOT of good Italian-​style grub in a very casual environment? Go here.

Have only gotten takeout pizza here which I thought was what you would expect from a neighborhood pizza place.
I thought the Pizza was average and slightly undercooked but was passable. I wouldnt rush back here for the pizza but would possibly try some of the other italian dishes they have on the menu.

An easy casual place to grab a consistently good pizza or calzone. They also have a great salad bar. Very kid friendly. They always have specials. Beer selection and specials are great and BONUS Saturday is $ 4 sangria

I confess when I heard we had been invited by friends to join them for a Sunday dinner at Milton’s, my initial reaction was okayyyy. Hadn’t been in YEARS. Remembered okay past experiences years ago.
Can happily report that Milton’s has done their part keeping up with the times. Yes, it’s still a neighborhood place with a small-​town feel, but our service was just great… friendly and helpful… food was down-​right very good! I enjoyed the pasta Ventura… which was a delightful concoction of spinach, onions, garlic and lots of artichoke hearts in a pink sauce served with garlic bread. Husband enjoyed a very good beef lasagne with garlic bread, and friends liked their large pizza.
Can also happily report that leftovers were very good, as well as the salad bar that came for free with pasta dishes on Sundays… which leads me to the TIP: check online for specials before you go. We enjoyed our free salads as a result!
Is this a destination restaurant? Probably not. But if you’re in the area and wanting a really good, friendly, affordable pizza or pasta meal… this is a very good choice!