Matteo’s Pizza & Subs

Food is awful don’t order. I got a steak and cheese sub. Bun wasn’t toasted. Steak tasted awful they put a piece of American cheese on it not melted.

Buffalo calzone isn’t so great here for me, but I come her for the subs. Their sub rolls are nice and soft unlike some shops where their rolls are hard to chew. Buffalo chicken subs, Italian subs, and the Greek wraps are all good here!

Great pizza and sub shop located inside Atlantic Market Liquors (which is also a good place), very clean kitchen, fresh and tasty food at a low price. Friendly employees and free delivery. Love the chicken cutlet and sausage & pepper subs. Very popular coffee shop in the store too.

Awesome food! They make their own dough and their pizza is absolutely out of this world its’s my favorite! Grilled chicken greek salad is amazing it the pita bread is warm! actually any sandwich on a pita bread is amazing,. they are the nicest people it is family run and the food is amazing.

Terrible. We got delivery and the food was not what we were expecting. The gyro had sour cream instead of tzatziki sauce. The gyro itself was dry and was not well wrapped. We also got buffalo chicken wings and it was just a dipping sauce and not tossed together. The garlic bread was barely toasted and also lacked garlic! Will not be returning customers here.

We would always get our chicken parm sub here when we crave for one. It might not be what you might expect in a reg chix parm. But we like it! It’s the combination of light sauce n high quality cheese on chicken cutlet type on a lightly toasted sub roll makes the deliciousness. The perfect texture n taste in every bite! #5 special is a large sub w/​fries or rings n a 1.5 liter soda. for 11.50. Get the fries. Very yummy!
Friendly family run business in a space inside Altanta liquor store.

I’m glad that I ordered pizza here despite the bad reviews. It is actually the best pizza I’ve had around here. I got a small and despite its personalish size I feel like I can never eat again after finishing it, haha.

No that good!
One of the worst sub sandwiches that I have ever had. My wife had a calzone that was more dough then the meat filling in it.

People are friendly taking your order but I wouldn’t say they know how to cook. I really want to like their food and I keep giving them chances but each time it is just a calamity. Soggy buns, wraps aren’t folded to keep food in, chicken wasn’t cooked, bland flavor. This location seems to be a pit of despair for aspiring pizza joints.

Very friendly service from the young man taking our order. When he forgot to pack our slice of pizza he gave us another one on the house. Huge improvement overall from how it use to be.

This is a big upgrade from the previous place inside the liquor store. Actually, the whole place has improved since it was bought. I can personally recommend the calzone and the gyro. I get the veggie Calzone and it satisfies. Dough is so important and they do a nice «town-​house» (that’s at least what I call it) style crust with plenty of good quality cheese that they brown nicely on top. The gyro is excellent as well. I’m looking forward to sampling more of the menu if I can get myself to not order my tried and true standard. They are also fast (15 mins), very friendly, and family owned and run. If you are lucky, the 5-​year-​old name-​sake might be hanging out behind the counter as well. Cute kid.
They have become a local standard for us. Head home with a sixer of good beer from the enveloping packie– you’ve got yourself a quality evening.