My Cheese Shoppe

What can I say other than I love this place! The Delice Brie is my favorite. The coconut gouda and cougar gold, oh gosh so good. There is a truffled Brie like cheese there right now that I need to try. Laurie and Tim are great. She did my cheese for our wedding and it was a beautiful display.

I go here all the time and always buy at least $ 50 worth of cheese alone. Amazing place to be!!! I’ll never buy regular old cheese again.

Very friendly ladies. So many selections! We sampled several cheese as the very nice and patient lady helped us choose. It was so hard to choose just one, must go back again for more!

We love this little place, it is a true «local shopping» experience. They are more than happy to share their love of all things cheese with customers. It is a must go!

So glad this local cheese shop is in my neck of the woods! I just love this place, and cheese!

MCS is my go-​to place for little «thank you’s» to my clients. They have the best cheesecake in the area — and I know because multiple clients have said, «Where did you buy this? It’s SO GOOD!»
It is a clean shop, and they are very generous on the free tastings. I think this shoppe has the potential to be HUGE!

Free tasting to pick your favourite cheese! Mine… Truffle Gouda!
Tucked off the main road near the Puyallup Farmer’s Market (spring and summer months), Puyallup library you will find this quaint shoppe offering dairy treats.
Once weekend summer day, my friend and I popped in to sample many different types of cheeses and of course purchased our favourites. Mine, almost any cheese with truffles =D
I appreciated the uniqueness of this shoppe, helpful knowledgeable staff, location near to other local shoppes and market.
Shopping for cheese was a tastefully delightful task that you just don’t get the full experience in a chain supermarket.

My all time favorite spot for special occasion platters and everyday selections ! Lori is great about making special platters for your event. love trying new cheeses here!

This place is dangerous. You can taste anything and everything. So many amazing cheeses! On my first day in Puyallup my sister took me to this quaint local cheesery. The owner and her cordon bleu trained chef daughter really know their cheeses. You can really get to know your own palate. And they have a lovely selection of gourmet goodies salami, chorizo, crackers, bread, specialty salts, and regional chocolate as well. Their sandwiches look amazing. They’ve partnered with the Puyallup River Alehouse to do beer and cheese pairings. Wish I were still going to be in town for that event.

I’ve been here twice now. Both times have been great. They are very friendly and, of course, knowledgeable. They have all types of cheeses from all over the world as well as some great local cheeses. They let you try a lot of the cheeses but are not pushy. I think the prices are very reasonable considering the quality and variety. I’ll definitely be going there again.

My Cheese Shoppe is a fabulous place to shop for cheese and all the goodies that go with cheese. Laurie is very knowledgable, so friendly, and always willing to get me to taste something I wouldn’t normally try. I love this store, and am thrilled it is downtown Puyallup!

We discovered this place during Puyallup’s annual Art and Wine Walk. They were very friendly that night and we saw they had a great selection. We decided to go back on Small Business Saturday (the day after Black Friday) to shop downtown Puyallup and this was our «must have» store. What we appreciate most about this shoppe is how knowledgeable all of the staff are each time we have gone. They are also eager to have you try their cheeses. Makes sense, considering we end up buying most of the cheeses we try! We bought some landjaeger on small business saturday along with some Christmas gifts for other people. I hesitate to spread the word about this, but the landjaeger is phenomenal! The best I’ve had since Germany. We were traveling to see relatives for Christmas so we went back and bought 14 landjaeger (10 for the visit and 4 for the road trip!) and 5 separate cheeses. We probably sampled 8 different cheeses. Based on our likes and dislikes and our desire for variety they helped us choose some fantastic selections. A delicious cranberry (sweet and savory), an out of the ordinary creamy farmhouse cheddar with truffles (WOW — also sweet and savory), Ewephoria (premium aged sheep milk) Mt Townsend Creamery’s New Moon, and Beecher’s Yule Kase. Again, it was because the staff here listened to what we wanted, liked and disliked, and were eager to please. Everyone has their own taste for cheeses, and I can guarantee My Cheese Shoppe has a cheese for everyone. Thanks from our family to the staff for helping this holiday be delicious!

My husband and I just moved back to the Puyallup area recently and are now located in central downtown.
We decided to go for a scroll a few evenings ago and check out this shop we had seen in passing. It was about a half an hour before they closed and we figured we would just browse and not necessarily purchase anything yet.
We were SO PLEASED! The lady working there was very outgoing and nice without being too terribly aggressive. She offered many samples and everything was wonderful. She did a fantastic job on narrowing in on some things we’d enjoy and we ended up buying a few cheeses and a baguette. We immediately hurried home and starting cutting cheese slices and toasting the baguette for a wonderful snacky meal.
We will be regular’s here I am sure. It is so great to have a real cheese shop just a block away!

I’ve never been to a better cheese shop. The ladies working the store were helpful, informative and very patient! I learned something and got some delicious cheeses. Both women were really excited about the cheese which was infectious!
My one complaint — I just wish I lived closer to their store!

Highly recommend this lovely shop to any cheeseaholics. Both Laurie and Ashlynn are very knowledgeable and helpful so don’t worry if you are not sure where to begin your cheese hunt. As a cheeseaholic, I can be very picky when deciding which cheese to buy, luckily Laurie and Ashlynn are so patient and let me sample different kinds of cheese. Most importantly, they are doing their best to support local business so you can find a lot of local goodies in the store. Seriously, people, instead of getting cheese from Safeway or QFC, why not visiting My Cheese Shoppe for better quality of cheese and great service? You won’t be disappointed.

Have I really not written a review for My Cheese Shoppe yet? THEY ARE SIMPLY THE BEST. Every time I go in, I spend a good half an hour sampling cheeses… and Ashlynn and Laurie KNOW my preferences by now, so they always tell me: «wait you like SHARP and SMELLY… you’re gonna love this one!» I love a business that takes the time to know their customer — they think FOR me, so I don’t have to.
Besides being knowledgeable and crazy-​friendly, they are both incredible chefs… so as I’m picking out a new cheese, they are busy giving me the rundown on all the recipes I could use my cheese in. Haha. They are the best! Worth the drive, worth the time… I love all the down home, personal touches. I get my fancy cheese without the pretentious, stuffy attitude that I have gotten in the past from so many other shops, and THAT makes me happy!
Go see Ashlynn and Laurie! They won’t let you down. And you will have a bag of delicious, cheesy goodness under your arm when you leave.

Went back the following week and met the owner. Again, a delightful shop with great atmosphere and great selections. Every trip to Puyallup must have a visit to this shop!

The owner is absolutely delightful! She is the icing on this piece of cheese shop cake! They have a very wide selection of cheese (I’ve sampled/​bought at least half) and I’ve tried their salami. They have spoiled me, I will only go here for my «special» cheeses. It’s not only their selection that makes them great, it’s the people and the atmosphere.

This certainly isn’t one of those snooty, pretentious, stuffy little cheese shops you might find in Bellevue or Seattle. This one suits downtown Puyallup just fine. Laurie knows her stuff about cheese and will let you sample any one in the case. She treats everyone like shes known them for years.
You’ll find a wide variety of superior quality specialty cheeses not available at you’re local grocery store along with several different types of crackers, toffee, pepperoni and candies. Prices are reasonable so if you’re planning a picnic for two or a wine/​cheese party for several, don’t hesitate to drop in. You won’t be disappointed.

I am so happy there is a good cheese shop right around the corner from my loft. I shop here about once a week to get a good blue cheese for my salad, or something to go on my crackers or breads. There is a good selection, and the prices are good. The owner will let you sample anything you want and is so knowledgeable and helpful. She greets me by my first name when I walk in the door. I love it.