Estella’s Pizzeria

This place promotes itself as a NYC business but the ambiance and attitude is far from it. I walked into this place 40 minutes before closing and was snarled at and then told that pizza slices were not available. Really (it’s a pizza joint)? I ended up ordering a pie because it was only $ 8.99 and to my surprise it was somewhat decent. Will I go back? Only if I really have no other choice because for me being a New Yorker bread, born, raised and lived, at the end of the day if I don’t feel welcomed in an establishment, then it’s not worth my time or money! Keep running your place as you do and overtime people will visit less often. The restaurant industry is based on hospitality and it will make or break you!

Best pizza in psl period! From regular to Sicilian to their desserts the food is awesome! Definitely will continue to be a customer

I am very happy to order pizza and wings from here. I tried their lobster tail pastry the other night, it was delicious.

What a disappointment! After reading the Unilocal reviews, we thought we found the «best» pizzeria in Port St. Lucie. We decided not to get fancy, and ordered the most basic pizza. A tomato and cheese. It was as blah and as ordinary as a pizza could possibly be. When you pick up a slice, and it collapses, you know you are in the wrong place. Soggy pizza! Basically flavorless. Without mentioning names, we have been to at least three pizzerias in PSL much, much better than Estellas. If the basic cheese pizza is bad??? We are Italians from New Jersey, so we know excellent pizza when we taste it.

We are new to the area and Unilocal has been good for us. Estrella’s is good. The chicken parm was perfect. I had the eggplant and it was also perfect. Lightly fried and layered. The sauce was light and very tasty. Not heavy with pepper. We will definitely return.

Awesome pizza and the garlic knots were fantastic! Would recommend for sure. Also fast delivery!

Coming from NY, I have had trouble finding good pizza. This pizza has that moisture layer between the cheese and bread done right, something not done well in many places through Florida. Like NY pizza, it had a few drops of grease when folding the pizza (In NY, we put a napkin behind the pizza to catch this), and it was just the right amount, not too much. Overall, Estella’s Pizza is the closest to NY pizza that I have found in Florida.

Had to give this place 5 stars. Not because it was the best pizza I’ve ever had, but the pizza was definitely great. The garlic knots, calzones, honey garlic wings and antipasto salad were amazing! The service was excellent! If you’re passing through Port Saint Lucie from the FL Turnpike, this is way better than stopping at the over-​crowded and over-​priced rest stops. By the way, I’m from Brooklyn, so I know delicious and authentic Italian food. This place definitely did me proud. They also have a great variety of desserts!

Hard to come by Italian in the tri-​county area, the few there are, usually aren’t great. But this place is really delicious! Love their sauce! Have had ziti & their eggplant app a few times, salad dressing is amazing, overall really good!

Pretty good for a pizzeria filling Paneriello’s shoes. It’s a quaint atmosphere, kind of quiet but you can hear every conversation every table is having. Personally I’d play up the old-​Italian family vibe that they’ve got going on but hey, they just opened and their pizza is what matters.

Probably the best «low key» Italian in PSL. Excellent pizza especially the Sicilian. Toppings are plentiful and the red sauce is delicious. Mostly take out but they do have 6 – 8 tables. Service is so-​so from the young waitresses.

We ordered the honey garlic wings, grandma’s pizza, spaghetti and meatballs and cheese ravioli for dinner tonight. The pizza kicked my a$$ with the red pepper flake heat but it was good and I can’t wait to try some different pizza combos. Special pizza for PSL, haven’t found it elsewhere. Garlic knots were great too. Cheese ravioli was aiiiiight. Not my favorite but the cheese was creamy and it was decent. My son enjoyed the spaghetti and meatballs. On to the wings! They’re fresh and seasoned with purpose. We will be back.

Very Good and this is from a NY girl who’s used to eating NY pizza! Garlic knots real GARLICKY N TASTY. Small antipasto fresh n good. Manicotti very fresn n flavorful. I believe the manicotti is homemade and filling. Chicken Parmesan was good tasting although a lil small. Still very good. Customer service was good and friendly. This will be our spot for Pizza and pasta when not in NY. Glad to have found it.

My girlfriend and i love it here. The pizza is great and the home made sauce is some of the best ive had. Chicken alfredo chicken patm and eggplant parm were superb. Everyone here is very welcoming and could not of had better service.

Awesome pizza awesome food everything here is good, never had an issue, they do not skimp on the toppings either, look at the pictures I’m about to post… Way better then little Italy frank and als or jacks … Best pizza and Italian food in the slw area in my opinion… Their sauce is really good and they even bottle their sauces to sell, I have no connections to these people What so ever but yea I’d say 4 stars for sure.

Some of the reviews on Unilocal are ridiculous these days. If I order two pizza pies with completely different toppings, then I expect them to taste different. If one pizza has way more ingredients than the other, then I also expect one to taste much better due to all the ingredients, right?
Moving on.
I grew up in Brooklyn and have eaten Pizza my entire life. From Howard Beach slices to City Line, Ozone Park, Sheepshead Bay, Bay Ridge, Mill Basin, Staten Island, Dumbo; you name it, I’ve had it.
Estella’s reminds me of a taste of home. It reminds me of when I was young and walked over to Liberty Ave to grab a slice and a can of Pepsi. It also reminds me of the Italian bakeries of my youth. The cannoli’s and such. The pastries are good, especially if you come from where I do. Tastes are subjective anyway, so if you feel different then that’s your right. For me, this place is it.
I’ve also ordered the Penne Ala Vodka and it was a huge portion and definitely enough for two. The garlic bread/​knots that came with the order were divine.
Service (call in and pick up only) has always been friendly and very efficient.
TIP: Extra Large Pies are $ 8.99 on Mondays and Tuesdays. Now that’s a deal!
3.5 stars

Okay, this is my second pizza. I dont know what changed from the first one, but this pizza sucked. The first one was sausage, green peppers, onions and mushrooms and it was so delish. My second was just a pepparoni and it was horrible.

Looked for pizza in this area and came across this great restaurant tucked inside a strip mall. Very clean, friendly staff and easily the best pizza I’ve had in a while. We ordered a half dozen garlic knots and Grandmas pizza, added eggplant to half. Ordered everything well done and everything came out just as ordered :) Wish this place was around the corner from us, we will definitely return whenever we are in the area!

I had the Itailian sausage with peppers and onions sub I didn’t like that the sausage was cut into piece Not my favorite Sausage sub Will try the pizza another time

Fantastic pizza the best new place for pizza in Port Saint Lucie. The owners are amazing and willing to go above and beyond for their customers. Definately will return, theres a reason they are so busy!