Old Town Pizza

Average food.
Pizza is okay
Hero’s are bland
Pasta is the better choice
Nothing special though
Decorated nicely and clean
A little on the pricy side as well

The best Italian around. These brothers own a few places on the north side of Suffolk and they are all good. After moving they will still deliver to me. Only pizza I order!

Their pizza is very good and the prices are fair. However, don’t order whole wheat. It is very difficult to bite into, and the flavor are not nearly as good as the regular flower.

We love this place! The Italian salad dressing (maybe called house dressing) is absolutely amazing. We eat out once a week on Sunday’s and our choice is always the salad with grilled chicken. As the salad is good, it becomes great with the dressing! We actually get the dressing often for our salads at home. The kids won’t argue to eat their salads when we get the dressing for them… We will be getting married this summer and will buy this dressing to serve at the wedding for our guests. Ok enough about the dressing already. (Haha) all the food here is wonderful and as a family of 9 we love it all! Great job Old town pizza! Staff are wonderful always super nice! Forgot to mention the catered food! We have actually catered food to bring to events we were attending, everything we have ordered has always been ready when they said and was Delish!!!

The food is good, but the little assholes that run the counter most times I come in always give me dirty looks and make me wait to be served.

Ive always picked up my orders, so I cant speak about delivery! But every time my order is delish; the best salad slice– EVER!

Always good. My favorite Italian take out, Pizza great heroes, are too. Service is fast and place is neat and clean, Eat in, take out all good

Trying Old Town Pizza out again after a rocky first time and I gotta say, I do very much enjoy the food here!
My family orders in a lot and lately OTP has been the go to. I get a few different things but I really love their salads! The portions for a size large are astronomical! The Cesar dressing is really good and I am very particular about dressing. My sister always gets the crispy chicken salad and it’s very delicious and unique!
The delivery sometimes can be longer than what I hope for but like I said in my previous review their ETA is always on point! Good work guys!
Dennis: Thank you for reaching out to me. I looked over other reviews and I like how you are continuously willing to make any situation better for a customer. If I could make a suggestion I would recommend to stay open a little later, even if just until 11. Also I’ve been wanting to try the pasta again! Coming from my personal opinion I would say that with the amount of sauce, less is more.

Upon entering this establishment which is well decorated for where it is located, I witnessed an assortment of pizzas displayed pleasantly behind the glass counter. I decided to order my two «go-to’s» and I must’ve came here on an «off-​day». This place was recommended from a friend of mine who swears by it.
I ordered two slices of pizza (Chicken bacon Ranch) and (Buffalo Chicken) which I was expecting to be quite well indeed. Unfortunately I was mislead.
The CBR slice was just pure awful, and it’s painful to say that. The unbreaded chicken was not only soggy, but the ranch dressing was just not there in taste. I was certainly not a fan of the added tomatoes to a CBR slice. But I suppose they were trying to add some flavor to a very bland product. Certainly did not do anything for me, and had to discard it a quarter way into it. (Again perhaps an off day)
The buffalo chicken slice was alright, nothing to special about it really. It lacked that buffalo kick one craves when ordering such a slice. But that could just be my tolerance towards spicy foods. After all gotta keep it kid friendly I suppose. The lack of blue cheese was a let down as well, but did not make it uneatable. Personally with some tweaks it has potential.
Still this place did not impress me one bit. I may (and a big may) come back to give their pasta a go. But as for their pizza, I’ll hold off for now.

Just picked up dinner from here for the first time since it was Pepino’s years ago.
I ordered a large Neapolitan pie and a sausage calzone, both to-​go.
The cheese: sauce ratio on the pizza was excellent and it’s probably the best sauce I’ve ever had on any pizza in my entire life. That says a lot. But none of us were crazy about the crust. It was kind of bready and not crisp at all. Seems like it was taken out of the oven the second it was done and didn’t really have a chance to brown at all. I’m always reluctant to ever ask for a well-​done pie, but maybe next time I will and see how that turns out. I’m still giving them 4 stars because the rest of the pizza was just that good and the crust wasn’t bad per se.
As for the sausage calzone, it wasn’t that great. It was HUGE, but the sausage wasn’t too flavorful and the ricotta and mozzarella took over because there was just so much of it. However the small container of sauce they give you on the side was other-​worldly and I could’ve drank it out of a glass.
The staff was very friendly and made small talk while I waited and the speciality slices looked great. Dat sauce doe!

If I was just rating the food I would give a 5. But I don’t know if I’ll be going back. Every time I pickup my food or have it delivered the price is a couple of bucks more than the price in the menu. Today was the worst. $ 5 more than stated on the menu for 2 pasta dinners. The cooler than thou guy at the counter could care less. I should have just walked but we were hungry. I can’t imagine why the owner thinks this is a good policy but it happens consistently with ordering dinners. I’ve only had the pizza once and while it was expensive at least I knew what I was paying before I ordered.

The pizza wasn’t that great, the garlic knots were not good but not bad and it took a long time to get Pizzia.

My office had lunch delivered from Old Town Pizza today, and it was amazing. I can only speak for the Mama Mia Panini (grilled chicken, mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, basil, house dressing) and garlic knots, but these two items were so good I had to write a review.
I chose the panini largely because the menu said «homemade» and the ingredient list made me drool. When I got my order, I was SO pleasantly surprised to see that the homemade panini bread was actually focaccia (or something very similar to focaccia). Whatever it was, I was in love because I LOVE FOCACCIA. Another plus was that the dressing came on the side. FYI, the panini tasted great both with and without the house dressing.
Garlics knot were garlicky and chewy, just how I like them. And a perk of having house dressing to spare: a zingy dipping sauce for my knots!
All in all, wonderful lunch for a very reasonable price.

I live this pizza place! I’m not really a big fan of most common pizza, but this place makes a specialty slice called a crispino slice which has fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sliced tomatoes, and topped with balsamic glaze. I’ve had pizza similar to this at other places but no one does it like old town. I just wish I lived on old town road still because it was great being right up the road from them. You can’t beat the super friendly staff either. They always knew my order and were ready to make it when I came in.

Amazing specialty slices and food for an affordable price. Can’t miss with the rigatoni alla vodka slice.

Quite frankly, I am surprised by the previous reviews written for Old Town Pizza. Differing in the majority opinion, I believe Old Town Pizza is spot on. I’ve ordered from various pizza places on Long Island, and I think Old Town Pizza is pretty good compared to every other pizza place. We usually order pizza and have it picked up and I do not have any complaints what so ever.
Price — The price is slightly expensive for my taste, but I do not mind too much. I guess it all depends on how many toppings you order.
Overall, I do recommned Old Town PIzza to other pizza lovers in the area. I think it is better than most.

For the third straight time the order took over an hour and the two hero’s we ordered are cold. Owner/​manager if you are reading this –YOU NEED TO UPGRADE YOU DELIVERY GAME SERIOUSLY !!
we order every week religiously. We’re considering a change unless it improves.

Belly App location that doesn’t allow to redeem for food earned since they now have more business from that business program. I called to use my free large pie that I had earned and they said they do use Belly anymore and cannot honor a program they discontinued. Unfortunately, that is not ethical since they sign up for it and for those customers that came in regularly to earn points should be able to redeem despite their decision to discontinue to use the business app.

Excellent pizza, the crust could hold it’s own without all of the other ingredients. Clean, comfortable restaurant. I recommend it to everyone!

I order out all the time from them. the wait is reasonable and the food is hot and fresh