Pichirilos Pizza

Honestly this is the worst pizza I’ve had. It’s so greasy, a plain pie should not be greasier than your average pepperoni pie. The pizza is doughy and usually on the cold side. It’s mushy and bland and not worth it. The place is pretty unclean too. I would not recommend this place to anybody.

The pizza here is phenomenal. I always order for delivery and they always show up on good time! Oh and their mexican food is pretty good too!

This place was recommended by a friend so I was excited to try it. I ordered a Sicilian pie which looked great. I took one bite of the Sicilian and instantly felt something sharp and hard against my teeth. Turns out there was a bent nail in my pizza. I called the place and was told the manager was off. I talked to the employee who picked up the phone and explained the situation. It seemed like he didn’t care that a nail was in my pizza. He proceeded to deflect the blame and it took me 10 minutes of screaming at him to refund me the price of the meal. By the way, the pizza was terrible without the nail in it.

Pizza was ok but when the kids went to use the restroom there was no toilet paper. When we mentioned this to the guy behind the counter he handed us a stack of paper towels saying they were out.
We won’t be back. Not sure why this place got 4 stars.

In my opinion this is the best Pizza delivery option around the point pleasant area! I am from NYC originally (Brooklyn) and I have found it very difficult to find NY style pizza around here. It’s not that I don’t like other types of pizza, but there are times when I just want something familiar that is done well! this place delivers consistently good, well made pizza! The pie arrives quickly and the dough has a great taste and texture.

We always pick Pics when we are in the mood for pizza salad and mussels to be delivered and they make the best subs

Pizza wasn’t bad, but didn’t leave us completely satisfied. Service was awesome. The one guy working, I’m assuming the owner. was extremely friendly and quick with our order. The place itself was pretty odd. Doesn’t look like much from the outside, but the interior is worse. Like an old rundown fun-​house turned pizza shop from the early 90s. Yeah, if you can picture that. Menu was alos really odd. Half the menu is Mexican food. This would be my first Italian/​Mexican joint I must say. Like I said, the pizza was alright and the service was great, but I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone. They have some cleaning up to do before I would do that.

The best well done thin crust, wings & service .it’s a pleasure to receive both great service and quality.. I will always be a fan and customer. I hope you all will try this pizza at least once.

Before opening Picharillo’s Pizza, Victor, the owner of this pizza shop, used to work at a different pizza place in the area. We would ONLY order pizza on the nights when Victor was working because he made the BEST pizzas.
But, when he finally opened his own place, we were not disappointed. The pizza is great… not too too cheesy, but just the right amount. We ALWAYS get an order of garlic knots when we order from Picharillo’s. Their hot subs are just really well done. You can even get Mexican food from here!
He’s got cranes and games for the kids that visit. The parking lot is a little tough to navigate, coming right in off Rt. 88, but be careful, take your time and I promise the pizza will be worth it!
When Victor opened his place, his former boss told him he wouldn’t last a year. Now more than five years later, me and my tummy are so so happy that his old boss was wrong.