Pizza Perfectta

Great pizza and fast service; what more can you ask for?
Everything about the pizza is fantastic! They are very generous with toppings, which taste wonderful, and the general cheese-​sauce-​toppings ratio of the pizza is very even. However, my favorite part of the pizza is the sauce. I believe that a good, flavorful sauce can make even the most basic pizza sing. The sauce that Pizza Perfectta used for their pizza had enough of a kick so that it brought out the cheese and other flavors of my pizza (mushrooms, onions, and sausage).
When I ordered my pizza from them, they were ridiculously fast about getting it ready and it only took 15 minutes for me to wait to get my pizza from them. I’m sure with delivery it might take longer for your food to be ready but if you pick up your pizza from them instead, it’s super quick! Pizza Perfectta is definitely my favorite pizza place in Shadyside and I am so lucky to live close by!

Not bad. Ordered a ham and cheese pizza for delivery. Arrived lukewarm but tasted decent enough. Won’t have a hankerin’ for this place but would order from them again if need be.

Best pizza in Shadyside. Always very quick when I do takeout, and their takeout specials make their larges/​x-​larges an incredibly good deal.

Super fast delivery and the food is-​always tasty. Great service and would definitely continue to eat here

Rude. Rude. Rude. They don’t speak English and they don’t understand English. And they are rude.

They close at 12am and I put my order at 11:58 and they still deliver it fast to me. Great people!

Took 1hr 15 min for a large pizza to be delivered 5 min from the restaurant. Estimated arrival was 9:36p and it arrived at 10p. Customer service was rude and unapologetic. Never again. It’s just pizza. If you can’t deliver it on time, you aren’t doing your job.

Fast delivery! Food was still warm when it arrived, which is always a plus when ordering delivery.
I got the special — Large pizza & a dozen wings.
I paid the $ 2.29 extra for a pepperoni topping. Fair amount of cheese & pepperoni on the entire pizza. Crust isn’t too crunchy, nor too soft.
I got the garlic parm and buffalo sauce ($ 1 each) for my wings — they put all the wings in garlic parm and gave me a side of buffalo sauce. I’m not sure how that made sense. Also, no ranch or dipping sauce even though it was requested.
Overall, an okay to decent pizza place that delivers. *$ 1 delivery fee*

Classic neighborhood pizzeria. The option to go with for delivery or pick up. Very good value to price. Been in neighborhood the longest of them all. Good hoagies as well. If you want to drive or spend more better options in East End… These guys are your go to delivery/​pick up. Tip if you like a heavier pie or cheese get extra cheese… Otherwise I find it a bit light.

You’d never know it by looking at this spot but it has the best Pizza in Pittsburgh. Tons of toppings, great quality.

The pizza and hoagies here are absolutely ON POINT. Wow!
I ordered a medium pizza with chicken and spinach. My husband a tuscan chicken hoagie.
First, the medium pizza is HUGE. Easily the size of a large at most places. The chicken was good and not rubbery. The spinach actually had FLAVOR. I eat a lot of spinach pizza and it usually is flavorless. This was amazing.
The tuscan chicken hoagie was next level. Super flavorful and delicious.
Best of all, everything arrived HOT! We’ve ordered way too many pizzas that arrive lukewarm!
We will DEFINITELY be back!

I’d been wanting to try pizza from this place for awhile, and I received the opportunity to do so when my dept. had some delivered for an event last Fri. Overall, I found their pies typical of PGH pizza in style, and slightly above average in quality, hence the 4 star rating (my average rating, as well as the PGH Unilocal citywide average, is 3.5).
Jason F. describes the elements of the pizza well, so I won’t reiterate them. I will mention that there was a generous amount of cheese, and the sauce: cheese ratio was on point. I don’t recall the crust being particularly crisp (my personal sticking point when it comes to pizza); however, on the other hand, I don’t recall it being floppy or insubstantial, either.
In terms of overall quality, Pizza Perfectta’s pies are a cut above those of nearby Pizza Parma, and they offer similar conveniences (acceptance of credit cards; delivery). Given that I don’t order food for delivery, I’ll stop by in person the next time I’m in the vicinity of Shadyside/​East Liberty.

Excellent pizza. Not the best I’ve ever had. But real good. It’s my neighborhood go-​to for sure.

Pizza Perfectta bailed my pregnant friend, her husband, and I out a few weeks ago when we were all HANGRY on a Friday night. Their online ordering system was easy to follow, and we quickly placed an order for a large pepperoni pizza ($ 12.59 special) for pick-​up. We were quoted a wait time of 15 minutes.
We picked up the pizza at exactly fifteen minutes. It clearly had been sitting for a bit because it was already cold by the time we got home. The pizza was just OK. There was plenty of pepperoni but practically no cheese. The crust was decent, but it just wasn’t a memorable pizza.
The biggest issue here is that there is no close by street parking so it is a big pain to pick up food here. We probably won’t return since parking is such an issue.

Solid Pizza
One of the best «Pittsburgh» buffalo chicken in the city. That being buff chick with the thick cut potatoes, chicken, and awesome hot sauce

It’s not a complete weekend for me without a stop at Pizza Perfectta. Pittsburgh pizza shops can be hit or miss, but these folks get it right.
The pizza itself is pretty nice. Well done, a good flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of crust. While they have good pizza, I usually find myself sticking to the hoagies, which are some of the best in town. They’re loaded well and toasted to perfection. I highly recommend the steak and mushroom, as well as the chicken parm. Very filling, and the whole ones often serve for two meals for me. The wings I’ve had were good, too. Nice and meaty, and just the right amount of sloppy.
Prices are on par with most Pittsburgh pizza shops, and I’d highly recommend checking out the online coupons on their site. Pizza Perfectta is fast, delicious, and a great value. Easily the best in Shadyside!

They claimed on their website that they have «the best wings in town». As a seeker of good wings, let me tell you about my adventure with this place.
Everything started fine with our order of 24 wings with three separate sauces for 3 eaters. The wings arrived exactly an hour later with the exact number of wings promised and a side of celery. Here’s the catch… THERE WAS NO SAUCE! My party of three decided to just tough it out and eat the wings plain. They were, I kid you not, so bland that I wasn’t sure what I was eating. They literally just threw the wings in the fryer and delivered it to us. So once we realized how unbearable the plain wings were, we called and complained about the sauce. About 40 minutes later, the sauce arrived. At this point, the wings got cold and our hunger turned into an unbearable rage. We tried BBQ, Garlic Parmesan and Spicy. The sauces were just average. The spicy sauce was so weak that I should’ve just settled with a bottle of sirracha.
The deliver guy gave us a cannoli as an apology… ONE CANNOLI…3 eaters! You get the point. But this gives me the chance to tell you how terrible the cannoli was. The outer shell was soggy and the filling made me gag a little. It looked nice, but didn’t taste that great.
So after 1 hour and 40 minutes, 24 wings, 3 sauces and a cannoli… we have 3 very unhappy customers. The wings were the most mediocre wings I have ever tasted. I will NOT order here again for the wings NOR will I recommend it to the fellow wings connoisseurs out there. Final verdict: MOST MEDIOCRE wings in town!

On the positive side, the delivery was pretty quick, given I ordered during the dinner rush, where I would consider under an hour to be pretty exceptional. After that, the food was pretty meh. The pizza wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t great either. Given the relative quick delivery, it was on the cold side upon arrival. Also, I had ordered a fried pickle appetizer. It was clearly a frozen appetizer, so I knew what to expect, but this also arrived cold and soggy. All and all not a terribly positive experience given the vast wealth of take-​out options in the area.

This is a 5-​star neighborhood pizza delivery joint. I’ve ordered from here multiple times, and the quality was consistent and the delivery was timely and friendly. The food comes hot, and they never forget to give utensils, condiments and napkins.
I’ve ordered the Wings with Garlic and Parm, which comes in a oven-​safe container for leftovers. The Buffalo fries are great as well– and if you top it with cheese you also get the aluminum container. We all know food tastes better when its reheated in the oven.
The Chicken Ranchero Pizza is great, but I feel pretty guilty about eating it, so I just order regular pizza with random toppings that I’m in the mood for. My other favorite item is the Cheesy Breadsticks.
Consistent, delicious quality with reliable delivery=5 stars. I’ve walked by the store itself– it’s a takeout place.

Working weekend shifts at work are kind of annoying, but the perks can be sweet! One being free lunch! This previous weekend my boss bought us lunch from Pizza Perfecta.
After ordering pizza at home twice that week (we DID NOT feel like cooking), I decided to go with a grilled chicken salad. Meh. I’m not saying it was bad, but it wasn’t really that great either. I thought they could have dressed it up some more. It was loaded with (too much) cheese and it melted due to the fries being warm, making the top of the salad kind of gross. Underneath the melted cheese was the lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cucumber. I guess this is all standard for a salad, but it really just didn’t impress me. Plus, I thought the chicken tasted pre-​cooked which should be a big no-​no for restaurants. One perk, however, was the size as it was pretty big! However, for $ 8.00, I felt it was a little steep.
I also had a slice of pizza (I can’t resist pizza) and it was comparable to any other pizza shop.
Service is very good, though! I placed the order and the employee I spoke with was very friendly. They had it delivered in time as well.
I’m not complaining because it was a free lunch, but I would never order myself.