Stevie’s Pizza

I was at Stevie’s recently and was not disappointed. I was visiting my parents who live in the area and they always end up here, sometimes 5 times a week! I can see why. The staff was friendly, gave suggestions on what to order (three of us split a calzone, more than enough food and it was delicious), and prices are very reasonable. I will definitely be back the next time I’m in town.

This is my goto place, the owner is a total New Yorker (straight to the point) and his family is super cool. Food great, I love the sausage pizza.

Will NEVER order here again. Promised a 45 minute delivery. After giving clear directions to our house in Vistancia, they tried to deliver to wrong address. Calling to find out what happened the owners daughter blamed it on us and hung up on us. This took TWO HOURS to get a pizza. The owner finally delivered a pizza that they had to return to store to heat up. Instead of making the situation right, the father/​owner defended his daughter’s hanging up on us saying they must have been busy, he told us to spend our money somewhere else. THAT WILL BE NO PROBLEM!
This is the second time we had issues, but thought the first time was just one if those things. This is the standard they have set for themselves.
STAY AWAY. Being busy is no excuse. Crappy pizza, crappy attitude, crappy service. There are 2 other pizza stores that will deliver here! ONE STAR because I could not give a ZERO

The people are so nice and friendly. They have a great house salad, but the lasagna is my favorite! The wine is pretty tasty too!

I was frantic trying to find someone that morning who could deliver 5 pizzas by 11am. They answered the phone at 10:15am and had my 5 pizzas ready for pick up ON TIME. They were quite good as well. The white spinach pizza and the bbq chicken pizza were loved by all and so was the giant cheese, pepperoni and special.
The service is above and beyond. They helped carry everything out to my car, they made sure to ask if I needed plates and cups, napkins… I would definitely order from them again!

Great food! Love this place. Service is fantastic and restraunt is clean. Love coming here.

I am so happy we live around the corner from Stevie’s, but if we didn’t I would drive a substantial distance for their ziti in vodka sauce! The staff is great; recently we brought family visiting out of town and enjoyed our food outside. They brought out cinnamon pizza knots dessert for us on the house! Thanks guys! I’m a customer for life!

This place is very lucky to serve such a great community and great food been here twice before for dinner and for pizzas awesome great food the old man seems kind of grumpy sometimes but the food pays for it it’s that New York attitude and New York flavor

This review is on one menu item only. I have ordered their wings on several occasions. The very first time I ordered their wings, they were the best wings I had ever had. Fresh, crisp, and their wing sauce is the best ever! Love the sauce! Unfortunately, in the 10 or so times I’ve ordered the wings since (always to go), they are soggy and gross (but the sauce is still good and I have no problem eating them!). I can only assume that the wings are cooked earlier in the day and reheated upon receiving an order. I assume this because I’m always quoted 15 minutes for my pick up time, but when I show up five minutes later, they are sitting there waiting for me. Stevie’s, make these fresh and I’d eat here at least once a week. Until then, only when I’m desperate or am craving your wing sauce.

When it comes to pizza, my expectations are a hot pie stuck together with great cheese. For me, the pizza was over sauced and messy. The staff was great. The pizza? Not my favorite

Wings were really good! The salads are pretty good too, and they have «good ranch»! Good ranch (meaning not oily) is hard to come by.
Plus they deliver. I’ve read other comments about delivery being slow. I had No problem with wait time for delivery, don’t wait till you’re starving to order then get mad because you don’t get your food instantly.

The pizza is horrible. Very little cheese, the sauce has no flavor and the dough tastes stale. Hoping for a different pizza place in Vistancia.

As new residents of Peoria my boyfriend I made it a point to find our new ‘go-​to’ pizza joint. And boy did we find it! After trying a handful of other pizza places in the area we were thinking we weren’t going to find a place we truly enjoyed, but we did and it’s Stevie’s. Not only does Stevie’s know how to make delicious crispy crust, the flavor of the sauce and quantity on the pizza is perfect. We love their veggie pizza and broccoli roll! My parents love the hot wings and pepperoni pizza! Oh, and the Eggplant Parmesan is so filling and satisfying. There is so much to choose from on the menu, we are excited to try everything Stevie’s has to offer. We also appreciate seeing the owner each time we go in, as we value his no nonsense attitude because it makes for good service and food. He also expresses his joy for his restaurant and recipes, which is attractive to customers like us.
Thanks Stevie’s, we looking forward to trying even more of your delicious food!

Great pizza, pastas and sandwiches. Go there 4 or more times a week. Reasonably priced also. Love it.

Super disappointed. Pizza was bland and tasteless. Beer labeled as shock top was not that. Worker was rude and pretty short with customers.

Delivered wrong pizza. When called, the guy on the phone didn’t seem to care.
I can order from any of the thousand other delivery places. Thanks, Stevie’s

Consistently great pizza, wings, calzones and sandwiches. It’s great having Stevies nearby for a planned dinner or pick up on the way home from work.

This is a short review of a modest pizza parlor that I have visited about five times to eat pizza. I have not tried their pasta dishes.
The first time I would have given it three stars for good pizza but all red wine is stored in a refrigerator at about 40 degrees, so forget having a glass of Chianti.
The next few times the pizza wasn’t quite as good. But the last time, my pizza had handfuls of ingredients piled on top in clumps, and the crust was soggy, and at places there were three or four slices of pepperoni on top of each other and sitting in an orange puddle of grease. This pizza was horrible, and I have not been back.
Consistency is critical in making good pizza (as Bianco’s proves every day), and I am not inclined to forgive a place for making a pizza as poorly as the last one I got at Stevie’s. Too bad because it is so convenient to where I live.

I was working in the strip mall here and this place was recommended to me, although for the pizza and not the eggplant Parmesan that I ended up having. The lunch slices looked like they had been sitting out for awhile so I went with the sandwich.
The cook (owner?) was so not into answering questions (he reminded me of the soup nazi from Seinfeld). He did say that he makes the sandwiches fresh but I’m skeptical of the fried eggplant, not very fresh tasting, also a little over cooked, almost burnt. Tomato sauce was tasty but not enough of it.
I won’t be going back.

This pizza joint is a youngling still that replaced the only pizza parlour in Vistancia that closed about half a year ago. At first, my husband and I instantly thought that this place just changed its name and still had the same menu, but it’s a different pizza entirely, and I love it that much more.
Papa John’s and Barros are very convenient and they deliver to the Vistancia community, but I love this New York pizza so much more than the so called «Chicago style» Barros pizza (which it’s really not), that I don’t mind driving here to get it instead of having other pizzas delivered.
Instead of serving soggy large slices, the slices have a texture similar to Peter Piper. I know that sounds bad, but despite the thinness, the slices actually have substance, which is a really good thing. But you know how Peter Piper has the stigma that people are afraid to admit that they like it, well, Stevie’s Pizza actually has the real taste to back it up. You can tell the ingredients are fresh, and even the staff is proud to serve it. (It seemed like the previous pizza place that this one replaced, the staff hated being there, but I noticed the staff at this new one actually cares about being there). There’s something to be said about service and food quality going hand in hand and that’s the reason we keep returning here.
I’d say even for people who don’t live in the Vistancia community, it is worth the drive out here to try this New York style pizza. It’s a refreshing change compared to the hundreds of pizza chains out there.