Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt

My first experience with Orange Leaf was a few years ago when I happened to just stumble upon it in Parker. Not sure what it was we tried and and Loved it !! Since then we have been back a few times but not that often. We went again yesterday after lunch and it lived up to the same good memories ! So many choices !!! They will let you sample as well and they have smoothies. There are 3 Dairy FREE flavors !! Orange, pineapple and pink lemonade. I got the pineapple and then topped it with fresh berries and granola. But there is a great amount of selection for toppings ! From brownies to waffle cones, cookies, fruit, nuts, candy, syrups, sauces, sprinkles, you name it ! Frozen yogurt is self serve which can make it pricey. It’s all by weight so watch what you load your dessert with ! The place is fun modern and bright orange with fun spoons, couches and chairs. Also outdoor seating. Everyone there is friendly as well. I’m gonna return for sure when in the neighborhood.

It’s OK. The yogurt is good and the toppings are awesome. It’s always busy in here, normally for events of some kind. Every yogurt place on this earth lets you get your own samples. Not here. It really bothers me, because I am indecisive and like to experiment. I don’t really feel like having to ask someone to sample 5 different things before I commit. Change that policy, and I go up to 4 stars.

I really like the look and feel of this place, it’s vibrant and clean, and the kicker is they really appear to do a job job of maintaining that look.
The flavors of the frozen yogurts are made perfectly, the Reese’s peanut butter cup tasted like an actual peanut butter cup, not like it’s just yogurt with chocolate and peanut butter in it, very impressive.
My two issues with this place is the amount of non dairy flavors, having a couple is good, but I like a nice variety of actual frozen yogurt, especially with how good their flavors are. Also, the lack of labeling on the toppings is odd to me, maybe I’m naïve for not knowing what everything is, but I don’t and it would be nice to know what I am buying.

My first experience with Orange Leaf was when I lived in KY, way back when. Don’t even think about a «March Madness» comment. I really enjoyed it then and I feel the exact same way now.
This location is always very clean, has very friendly staff, and changes their flavors on a regular basis. The employees are always more than happy to let you taste test, which I definitely recommend. Some combinations which seem very strange in your head, let your taste buds will be the judge. I always seem to go back to orange and vanilla — ah dreamsicle days.
I have visited this location at different hours and have always found an empty table. We have several frozen yogurt places in Castle Rock, but I still head to Parker.

Me and my husband eat foyo about once a week. We take it seriously. When we moved here finding a go to joint was a priority. The toppings are fresh and the yogurt has had a good texture and flavor. I would have gave them 5 stars except for the fact you have to ask for a sample cup and they get the sample for you. So far this is the best tasting foyo I have found in Parker.

Always good flavors to choose from and the staff is always friendly and helpful. It is always clean and comfortable.
It’s a great family putting for a sweet treat.

So the yogurt itself was nothin different from the other options in Parker in my opinion. But if I had my choice, I most likely wouldn’t return.
As a 40 year old man with my wife and kids, it was very awkward to have to be served samples before we decided on favors by someone almost a ¹⁄₃ my age.
I’m sure the owner my have lost a few dollars by kids taking samples in the past, but does that dollar amount surpass the revenue lost by the majority not returning?
We met the owner while there and it’s a shame it’s run this way. You really want a local place to survive. With more customer friendly options, we prob won’t return.

This is one of my sons favorite yogurt places so we have been in a few times. The sampling policy doesn’t bother me although it was a bit harder to get used to vs other places (not that we sample a lot but it’s just a little uncomfortable having Someone stand there and watch you eat). I was also surprised to hear Klove on the radio this time. I am in the customer service industry and it’s so important for businesses to be politically correct and to not offend however I couldn’t imagine sitting in here enjoying my yogurt (and having another religious belief) but having to listen about Jesus God, and sins while I eat. I am a Christian and it was still awkward.

I don’t understand why everyone is so bent out of shape about the sample policy at this location. I went into this store for the first time and thought it was awesome that they did that. So many times have I been into other froyo spots and there’s yogurt on the floor, overflowing tiny trashcans full of sample cups, and kids running around hyped up on sugar from their 15 samples. Yes, I admit I didn’t try as many flavors because I felt like a fatty trying every single one. But the first one I tried was delicious so I’m sure the others were too! Both the employees working at the time were super friendly and actually took the time to help us and tell us about their yogurt, which I thought was awesome! The place was super clean, which is major points to me! I do agree the chairs are a little tiny. I’m a 6’2″ girl and the one high top table in the store was occupied by two young children. That’s my only reason for 4 stars and not 5. I understand the décor is sleek and modern but it’s just not practical. I’m not normally one to review places but I was so impressed with the cleanliness and friendliness that I will definitely be back!

This was our second visit using a $ 10 Groupon. They had my favorite Orange/​Tart swirl. It tasted just like a Creamsicle. Yumm. I didn’t have to sample anything else.

This place has the best peanut butter yogurt and all the flavors taste so natural instead of artificial. The puppy chow topping rocks too!

Stopped by this place last night for a quick bite because I had a hankering for ice cream (obviously they serve yogurt, I know it’s different but it suited the purpose). My daughter had visited their Ames, Iowa location when in college there and really liked it. She loves their reward program because you get store credit towards future purchases.
I’m not sure why the other reviewers were bent out of shape over the sampling. I go into these places to buy, not sample, so if they are offering free samples at all, I’m happy. The thought of a bunch of little kids self-​sampling would actually turn me off just over the thought of all that yogurt on the floor.
The yogurt was good, they had a nice selection of toppings, the cost was reasonable, and the staff was very friendly and helpful. The décor is a bit interesting but then I’m old and not necessarily a fan of anything modern, so that wasn’t really an issue either way. It was very clean and tidy, and the seats were comfy, so that’s what counts in my mind.
This place is convenient and closer to where I live. Not as crowded as some of the other places in Parker, either. We’ll definitely be back.

I don’t think I will be back. I was the only customer when I came in on a Sunday afternoon. The place is nice and clean and modern and colorful. However, as I came through the door, I was hit with a nauseating disinfectant smell (they were cleaning at the time). It was VERY offputting, like strong chemicals trying to cover up a dirty bathroom, which is odd, considering how new the place is.
The young lady working the counter was friendly and helpful. However, the no self-​sampling is a big pain in the buttocks. I know some places make you ask for the sample cups, and that is fine. But, considering how long it took for me to sample two flavors, I cannot imagine how slow it would be with multiple customers. The flavors I tried were fine. The orange was kind of nice.
They have a large selection of toppings, but they did not have blackberries. The raspberries tasted fine, but they were pretty beat up. The spoons are like miniature snow shovels and not exactly ergonomic in their design. This is a silly example of form over function. Seating is similarly visually appealing and completely impractical for a larger adult. Not offering free water is needless penny pinching. Price, for my yogurt serving, seemed on the high end. I would recommend Swirls over Orange Leaf in a heartbeat.

Staff was very friendly, selection of frogurt was on par with the others in town and the toppings were stocked and numerous.
Not so sure about the décor — it’s like and orange and a lime got it on and created a
world of seating for very very small adults. There was one high top table in the place but it was taken so at 6′-1″ and 240 there was no room at the inn for poor old me.
Bonus points: They have a rewards program that’s a 10% cash back kind of thing and also they have outdoor patio seating which is a great thing in the summer. Also their hours are an hour longer than anyone else in town so I like that.
I see a lot of people complaining about samples. Good grief — what other restaurant let’s you have samples of the meals before you order? The super cute and friendly samples girl will help you out — she’s there to keep food costs down because of all your bratty kids!

Best flavor and toppings in town. The store was also super clean and even though they don’t let you get your own samples, they offer them to you as soon as you walk in. Nice atmosphere and the yogurt isn’t melting as soon as you put it in the bowl. I’m not sure why the other ratings are so low. Iv’e been three times now and have had a positive experience each time.

I won’t be back. Although the size of the store allows for more flavors at any given time vs. the smaller yogurt shops — it’s not enough to bring me back. The flavors offered, and toppings available were great; however, having my sample request ‘supervised’ is a turn off. I understand why they might do this, as I’ve seen abuse of kids taking samples and not buying but I shouldn’t be punished for that behavior.

The yogurt at Orange Leaf is delicious! Great selection of flavors. My favorites were Wedding Cake, Brownie Batter, Pineapple and Coconut. Great fresh toppings to. Toppings were also very fresh. This place is kept very clean unlike other yogurt places in town. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5, is because it was a little on the pricey side ($ 14 for both my husband and I). Also, you can’t get your own samples and I felt like a pig asking to try all the flavors. I do understand when you get little kids/​teenagers in there and they go sample crazy and create a mess. I am clean though and there was no one else there and I felt like I was being monitored by the sample police.

The décor of this shop is great – fresh orange tones, modern theme, inviting on a cool day. I wasn’t so impressed with the rest. As another reviewer noted, you aren’t allowed to sample on your own, so trying out flavors was diffcult. The price was just unreasonable. I know they weigh the ice cream, so I was careful with toppings, and yogurt for one adult and 2 kids was almost $ 18.00 – yikes! No water was availble, other than for purchase. We went to Smart Cow in Castle Rock and they had a water dispenser with fresh fruit – nice! I admittedly LOVE sugar and sweets but this yogurt was painfully sweet, and a bit runny too. Not my favorite. Probably won’t return. Guessing this place won’t make it.