Colonna’s Pizza

One of our two favorite pizza places in town! (The other is Portofino). This place has a great location, easy in & out & plentiful parking.
Their pizza is super cheesy, therefore there is a decent amount of grease. The chocolate cake is way way rich & yummy.
They will deliver within a certain distance with a minimum order.
Have the pizza slices «double cut» for easier handling by kiddos.

GREAT FOOD! I understand the pizza sauce is a family recipe. So delicious! Highly recommend. We are looking forward to our next visit.

We love this pizza joint! Never eaten there, but get delivery/​take out a lot. The margarita pizza is super yummy.

Great pizza, fun atmosphere, for a fast-​casual restaurant.
You order at a counter and staff brings your food to you. The lunch specials are dynamite. 2 huge slices and a soda for $ 5 – 7 depending on your toppings. Sauce is perfect, crust is excellent, toppings are great, though I often find myself sticking to cheese or pepperoni.
Great for carry-​out too. We find ourselves making this our «local» «go-​to» pizzeria when we are looking for a tasty slice!

I really do like their pizza and the pizza by the slice lunch specials and would give them 5 stars had in not been for my experience today. I wanted a pizza with chicken, pineapple and jalepinos. The cashier said they could put the extra toppings on a slice of cheese pizza. No problem, paid extra for the extra toppings. My receipt said I ordered at 1:18pm. At 1:45 I took my receipt up front to ask when my food would be ready and the gentleman happened to be walking out with our pizza. I said oh goody we’ve been waiting 30 minutes and he said «no you haven’t». I was going brush the comment off but when he came by our table and asked how everything was I felt the need to give him the honest feedback. I was not looking for a refund. He seemed very combative and I felt he was basically telling me it was my problem not his. I’ll be honest at this point I was getting pretty upset. He then said what else do you want me to do? I was not sure what to say. He grabbed my receipt said if it’s a refund you want I’ll give it to you, if that will make you feel better. He came back with $ 14 cash and put it on the table. And this pint I’m pissed off and the money didn’t matter. I’m going to give him the benefit of the doubt and assume he had a bad day and they were busy and understaffed.

A pleasant experience in all! We ordered the Rio Rancho and it was delicious the crust was perfect. We also ordered the italiano fries and were not disappointed. Service was fairly quick!

For being NY-​style, the crust it too thick. The customer service is poor – I had to wait in line a long time just to pick up a to-​go pizza, and the two cashiers weren’t in any rush. Overall, that’s fine – they should give good service to the people they are helping, but an acknowledgement that I was standing for such a long time while they were helping the other customers would have been nice. While I was there I grabbed a piece of tiramisu from the refrigerator box. An hour later when I went to eat it it was frozen! Either they buy it frozen or the refrigerator box it set too cold. I fully realize that they probably buy it from a food distributor, but they need to make sure it’s thawed out. This is the third time I’ve been there because people keep telling me how good it is and to try them again. As far as I’m concerned, they’re 0 – 3 with me. I won’t be back.

The pizza here is OK. Was better on previous occasions, but the last 2 times not so much. The crust has gotten thicker & heavier, and the end of the crust doesn’t rise. It’s just a flattish lump of dough. This pizza isn’t worth the tradeoff of the calories & carbs I’m taking in.

Delicious pizza, friendly staff and beer & wine on the menu. They have great deals on lunch specials, and the take out for a fresh made personal pan pizza is only about 8 to 10 minutes. The crust is chewy and the toppings don’t overwhelmed the pie.
They also have delicious cannolis.

The lunch deal here is great, especially with how huge the pizza slices are. The pizza has a great taste to it with fresh ingredients and a perfect cook to it. The service here is also very friendly, it was my first time here and the guy at the counter was very friendly without trying to push me, it was very appreciated. I enjoyed the place so I gave it 4 stars but sadly I will not return because I need my Diet Coke with my pizza, and with Pepsi products I cannot.

Great GF crust for those with a Gluten sensitivity! We also enjoy their traditional New York Style pizza and sides — salad etc.; Good, solid pizza.

Excellent restaurant and the best New York Style Pizza around! The owner is from New York himself and comes around to the tables himself personally and serves you!!! I told the owner the food and service was exceptional and he gave my beautiful girlfriend and I free Canoli’s! You must try the Canoli’s.

Fantastic Margherita Pizza, do yourself a favor and add the sausage! Their salads are large and chilled and great as well. We got our order for take out, and literally as I walked in, our order was ready. Spacious booths for dine in, and the staff is attentive and nice. I recommend you try this place.

This is one of the best pizza places I’ve had. Great food and fantastic service. The owner always comes around to check on you. Also they do a ton of takeout business. Great idea when you aren’t in the mood to cook and need something for the whole family.
Corey Engelen

While the food is normally good, the order service over the phone and in person was quite rude and dry. She seemed like a hard worker, but it was if I was bugging her with my order. Such a shame, as the service previously was very good. The bread was old or overcooked and there was no garlic butter sauce. The pizza this time around was meh.

Fantastic made to order pizza, fresh ingredients, great sauce to cheese to tipping ratio, thin and crispy crust. Garlic knots not very garlicky but hot and tasty. Friendly employees, walk up and order then sit style.
Had the sausage mushroom pizza. Will come back to try Stromboli and calzones. Happy hour 3 – 5 2 for 2 draft.
Check in on Unilocal and get a free small cheese pizza.

Tried the meat pizza and it was fantastic! Service tonight was great as we walked in around 8:30 and they assured me that it wasn’t too late (they close at 9:00). Awesome pizza as this place starts to grow on me!

We were looking for a new place to go in Parker and decided on Colonna’s after looking at other Unilocal reviews. I’m glad we made that decision. All four of us loved the meat supreme pizza. We rarely get to Parker, so I wish there was one closer to Arvada!

Love this NY style pizza! Delicious, generous toppings, friendly staff & always consistent.

Haven’t been here for almost 1.5 years and I’m disappointed that my garlic knots weren’t drowning in garlic pieces like the last time we visited but their pizza was still good but this visit our crust wasn’t very crispy. We had a large ½ Milano aka Spicy BBQ and ½ Rio Rancho. We will skip the Rio Rancho and just order the Milano… It was spot on. Just wish they delivered!