Toni Pepperoni’s

Brought my girlfriend and her kids here for dinner recently. Salad bar was good, lettuce was fresh, plenty of fresh toppings. They could probably use an extra variety or two of salad dressings but what was there worked. The wings were boneless wings which was surprising but they tasted ok. My girlfriend got a piece of cheese and pepperoni pizza that has no sauce on it at all. I could see certain types of pizza not having any sauce but that should never be the case for standard cheese and pepperoni pizza. I also tried some of their other items such as mashed potatoes and gravy, and pasta noodles with sauce. It all tasted fine but nothing to get excited about.
This would be a good place to bring some hungry kids to for a cheap buffet. From the adult’s perspective, not so much so.

Very good and reasonable… A large selection of pizza, pasta, chicken fingers and salad. They also have desert pizza and ice cream with a lot of toppings. The salad bar is giant and they have spaghetti and meatballs too… Any kid would love this place. They were very friendly as well. My only suggestion would be to get your ice cream right at the beginning of your meal and let it thaw a bit, the vanilla is in a freezer in cups which you add your own toppings to… Hot fudge etc… The ice cream is really frozen. We will definitely be back.

Good food great value for the $$ food items continually refreshed and large selection !

I was told if you have nothing nice to say, say nothing at all. I would give zero stars if I could! Horrid, at least the salad bar was somewhat fresh because nothing else is worth eating.

There’s nothing I like more than trying a new restaurant and enjoying it. Toni Pepperoni’s opened just yesterday in the home of the former Shanghai Buffet at the Five Corners in Orchard Park (Orchard Park Rd in the plaza with G&G Fitness and the Orchard Park Antique Mall). I wasn’t sure what to expect going in, but it certainly surpassed my hopes.
The most important thing was going to be the pizza crust. Many places offer cheap pizza options but with such a poor-​quality crust that the financial advantage advantage doesn’t make it worth it. All of the pizzas (and dessert pizzas) I sampled were really good. The crust was crispier on the bottom than most ‘Buffalo-​style’ but was pleasantly spongy and delicious. The sauce is good, and they proudly claim to use local Sargento cheeses.
Their buffet also includes Chicken Fingers, French Fries, Spaghetti, Meatballs, Italian Sausage, Nachos and Cheese, Parmesan Bites, two homemade soups (today was chili or chicken and rice) a full salad bar and dessert items, like a Peanut Butter Pizza that included chocolate and crushed butter fingers, Cinnamon Sugar Pizza and even Cinnamon Sugar Bites.
I found myself incredibly impressed by the value, and while I would not go so far as to say that always looking for someplace carb-​tastic for my cheat days… I know one when I see one, and this IS one and one at a great price! They also offer a number of different specials, including $ 2 for kids on Tuesdays (for each full priced $ 8.99 dinner) or Unlimited Wings on Sundays ($ 10.99 instead). They also offer an extensive takeout menu.
Now that’s not to say that there isn’t room for improvement; The Mac & Cheese left something to be desired and the fried food steamer table (which featured Plain, Mild, and BBQ Finger) food, while delicious was a little cooler than I’d normally like, but they could just up the heat from the steam table, add some heat lamps or rely on smaller portions rotating more quickly or by adding lids to hold in the heat better.
But these small issues can be easily ironed out and it is only their second day.
I cannot wait to go back and indulge in the delciious food and catch up on the latest sports news on their big screen TV!
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!