Bonetti’s Pizza

So this is actually my first Unilocal review! I’m writing bc I feel like Bonnetti’s should be more popular than it is! Haha. I’m an Italian and know good food. ;) I have to say for a long time we only got the pizza here bc Luigi’s is right down the street and just had always gone there. This seemed more like a «pizza place» to me and I didn’t (for whatever reason) think their meals would be that good. I was wrong! They make an amazing red sauce and seriously know how to cook pasta (something you would think is not a big deal but it actually makes a great difference when you have pasta that’s cooked right). All their portions are a good size and their prices are fair. They are also super nice. Make sure you give it a try bc I have seriously loved EVERY meal I’ve gotten there so far! We order from them probably once a week. The pizza, wraps, sandwiches, and meals are all great!

This is one of my go to pizza shops! Amazing pizza, salad options, reasonably priced and the guys are great! Must go! Also– they deliver!

HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE! Stopped in to grab a quick slice and the food ended up being so good we had to order a calzone for dessert. Meant to snap a photo but it was gone before i could remember to! Bada bing!

Their vodka sauce pizza is amazing. Like the best vodka sauce I’ve ever had. They also make nutella pizza that is like heaven in your mouth. They put melted marshmallows (and bananas but I asked for it without them) on top. The staff is very friendly.

Great food and customer service. Love the rice ball special.

Great food excellent fast service. Everything on menu is fabulous. We call for take out often. Clean atmosphere as well.

I stopped in for lunch on a Friday afternoon. Nothing special with the behind the counter service, the food looked ok. We sat down in back and had soup which was good and a ham and cheese sub. The sub was delicious until an object appeared in my mouth while eating the sub. It turned out to be a one inch piece of hard plastic that had jagged edges. It was my lucky day because as I was about to swallow, I discovered something unusual in my mouth. It turned out to have been a piece of hard plastic from a container produce was stored in. Somehow it was cut with a knife and never separated from the food. A careless mistake that could have cost me dearly. When prep work goes wrong like this, someone can choke on an object that would be very difficult to dislodge. They took the sub off the $ 28 check, what a sport. The owner did not have the decency to come to my table and explain how the plastic ended up in the salad part of the sub. He made the poor waitress do it. I would not recommend eating here.

1^st the pizza is eatable. But their service is its no good. I had Couple of issues with this people but where they really pissed me of was today. I came in for a slice of pizza. I always pay up front at every pizzeria. Including this day. When i was leaving i was being nice saying bye Have a great day! The guy was like you have to pay, I told him I already paid but the guy did not believe me and had to go asked his father which is find with he was just making sure but he went on on checked the machine for the last inputs it was embarrassing they make me Feel like a thief people looking at me and I even tip them. I mean he went to far. sure not going there ever and my coworkers said the same thing.

I came here since I don’t work on Thursdays (my normal go to during work is in Dayton). I was not pleased.
Older gentleman seemed irritated to take care of me. I had asked what kind of pizza something was. (I still have no idea what it was… it looked okay — something with chicken) A younger guy came out and took my order and was very nice.
I order a white slice and something else… The white slice I couldn’t finish. It wasn’t a good pizza. They both had been sitting out for a while, I could tell. The second slice wasn’t terrible, but the dough was very chewy and dried out.
Was it edible? Ehh… I guess. Would I come back? No.

Awesome grandma pie
Well done crust flavorful sauce and the perfect amount of cheese
Like all pizza, it is best to eat it at the restaurant
Nice folks reasonable prices

Pizza crust was doughy and chewy, sauce and cheese were dried out. Garlic knots were dry. It was so disappointing because we have had pizza there before

This may be the worst pizza I have ever tasted and I lived in Florida for 6 years. The crust was so dry. There was barely any sauce. The absolute worst. sorry guys. but that was awful.

I love their pizza! Staff is friendly and helpful.
You can order food online but beware that if you pay online, there is an extra fee. The 1^st time I ordered and paid online, I was unaware of the fee but I got a call from the restaurant saying they got my order and wanted to make sure I wanted to pay online due to the fee. When I told them I didn’t know about the fee, they were nice enough to let me pay in person instead!
Once they messed up my order and instead of making me wait for them to fix it, they corrected the rest of my order and delivered it to my place.
So yes there are mishaps that have occurred, but they want to make their customers happy and will accommodate them, which is what I like to see!

YUCK! Won’t be coming back here anytime soon! Had 2 slices (pepperoni & buffalo chicken). Barely any sauce, crust very dry and bland. Also a SWIPE FEE FOR BILLS UNDER 10 $!!! Swipe fee!!! Greedy asses! GTFOH!!!

Being from New York I didn’t have high expectations for pizza in NJ, but Bonetti’s is the exception! When we moved into the area we just stopped here on a whim. Pizza was thin and crispy! The riceball parm was delicious. I will definitely be back.

Pizza and wings were just okay. Bleu cheese dip was awful. Service was very friendly though.

We are semi-​obsessed with this place. We recently moved from the city and were nervous about leaving NYC pizza. Well, now we live within 10 minutes from this place and like their pizza even more than anything we ate in NYC. They are super nice in there too. So glad we found it!

Yummy grandma’s pizza. I’ve also had spinach with garlic, I asked for a lot of garlic and well done and they listened… Something weird about credit cards, I think there’s a minimum for them… The people working there are nice. I’ve never gotten a whole pie made just for taking out, I’ve only had warmed up slices from the ones already made, so maybe I’d go higher if I’d tried that. For this lacking-​in-​good-​pizza area, it’s one of the bests.

Can not say enough good things about this place. Chicken parm subs are the best around, soups are great, pizza great. Great place at least once a week we go here to eat. Have had both take out and stayed in. Staff is very nice and attentive