Three Brothers Pizza

We were so impressed by the variety on the menu, the quality of the food, and the incredible service. So hard to find a pizza restaurant that is good… none-​the-​less one where everything you order is delicious and the service is amazing! Highly recommend!

Small world when you run into someone from NY that owns a pizzeria in the middle of the most known place in Tampa that knows you from back home. Food was great. Pizza was delicious!!!

This place is amazing. Very fresh and clean. We got a couple of pizzas, garlic knots, truffle fries, and fried Oreos and we were blown away by the quality. I am lactose free and that is one thing maybe in the future I hope for is being able to get a lactose free pizza maybe soy cheese or whatever. This place was very good and the people were very nice. We haven’t tried the delivery yet but if they do go to us we will for sure be calling them up on a regular basis. 5 stars!

I’m from up north and have been living in Tampa for about 13 years. I haven’t found a good Pizza place until now! The pizza was absolutely delicious! Cheesy and crunchy! Great costumer service and super clean! Finally found my Pizza spot! Highly recommend!

Just visited this restaurant for the first time, as I’m new to the area. Was told by a friend how good it was. I ordered the The Brothers S.P.O. pizza with sausage, carmalized onions and peppers. It was amazingly good. Crust was nice and crisp, homemade dough and sauce. Beautiful carmalized onions and soft green peppers and wonderful sausage sliced. Sean was nice enough to let me try the homemade sauce which you can get with the entrees or buy it to go as well. It’s different than the homemade pizza sauce. It really is homemade and delicious! I can’t wait to come back to try one of the wonderful entrees they have in their menu. This is a gem of a restaurant and I’m so glad I found it!

Came here for dinner last night with the family and ordered the family special which comes with a large pizza, a spaghetti and meatballs, and a house salad for $ 22.95. We opted to add sausage and pineapples so it came out to almost $ 29.
The house salad looks like a typical salad with romaine lettuce, tomatoes, and black olives. But what separates this from all the other boring salads out there is their addition of homemade red pickled onions. There was something about this crunch, sweer, and tart condiment that elevated the salad into something I could not stop stuffing my face with! The homemade Italian wasn’t bad either but I could probably eat the onions by the gallons.
The spaghetti and meatballs were OK. The sauce was a little watery for my liking and the noodles were overdone but the meatballs were nice and tasted like something nonna would’ve made at home.
The pizza was huge but unfortunately they use the same watery sauce on the pizza. The crust was good if it wasn’t so soggy. The Italian sausage was really good though. I wonder if it’s homemade.
It’s been hard to find a go to pizza spot for us but now it’s looking like we finally have one!

First time at Three Brothers Pizza & we loved it. Pizza there is amazing! We had the pizza portobello and added pepperoni… Yum! All the ingredients were fresh and loved the seasoning around the pizza crust. Not greasy either.
We’ll definitely be back!

Best pizza I’ve had yet. I am from
Jersey and this place tops it. Well done. We have found out new pizza place. Can’t wait to try their calzones!

We ordered 2 large pizzas, a large salad, and ziti. All were ready for pickup within 20 minutes. The pizzas were awesome, especially the pizza bianca. Yum! I will definitely order again. Everyone was super nice too.

Very good!!! We ordered carry out tonight for a family of five and the food was plenty and delicious! We ordered one large cheese pizza with pepperoni and sausage, one large pizza Bianca, one large house salad and 1 large baked ziti. These items were all from the «specials» menu. I would definitely order carry out from this place again.

The best pizza I’ve had in the area, by far. The entrees are nothing special thus far — the only thing keeping this from being a 5-​star review. The pizza, however, is the closest to NY pizza I’ve had since I lived there. The owners are friendly and the prices are quite reasonable. They offer delivery, but their delivery times can get long when they are busy (1 hr+). But hey, that’s probably just an indicator that good pizza comes with a price — a longer wait than normal in this case.

I’m from new York, just moved down this past summer. This is the first plain cheese pizza that I have tried that taste just like New York pizza. Now I’m ordering a large pie to go

The food is great! Best pizza I’ve had since moving to Florida 6 years ago. We have also tried the baked ziti, hot wings and garlic knots. It’s all very good. The food is definitely homemade. No mass produced frozen nonsense like from those other places. The staff are also very friendly and courteous, they even brought my food out to my car while I was waiting. Prices are reasonable and they have good specials. They are also in the process of expanding to sit down restaurant. We can’t wait!
P. S.– I would have posted a picture of the food but the family got to it before I could. :)

I am changing my previous review.
The food quality here is top notch. Their pizzas are fresh and not greasy. They have a variety of options including salads, sandwiches and more.
Recently they have run into service issues — taking longer than normal to deliver and have messed up on recent orders. However prior to that they were very good with no issues.
Their management has acknowledged these issues and are diligently working to make it right.
I am very supportive of independent businesses and especially since the quality of food is high I hope they work through the recent service issues but I have a very strong feeling they will.

My husband & I are on the search for the best pizza in Trinity/​Odessa area. The Slice special is what we ordered which consist of 2 slices & drink for $ 4.99. They also offer Military discounts. The place is a casual; A little hole in the wall located off of Van Dyke Rd. Staff courteous & attentive. Busy place, lot of delivery orders & pickups. The pizza is very good better than Lonzalos. The sauce has a good flavor & nice amount of good cheese used. My husband said the bread was not sour & made perfectly. Leaves you craving for more! 5 stars for the pizza
They have gluten free pizza available*
28″ pies available*
Very accommodating to Vegetarians _​including sauce (no meat sauce) and customizing pizza. I heard a person order a balsamic eggplant for the Family special. The staff is super friendly and efficient! Thank you for recommending to try the special pizza with Chicken, bacon, mozzarella and onions with a dash of garlic powder & salt. Wow, I actually liked because normally I am a plain Jane. Will come back to try the Bianca.

GREAT place! The pear salad is wonderful and the pizza is always perfect. Best of all, fantastic service. LOVE this family run business!

I can not speak highly enough about this place. The food is wonderful, the staff is always friendly, personable and attentive. Their pizza is by far the best I have had in FL and gives the pizza places in NY a run for their money. The prices are good specials like 2 slices and a drink for 5 bucks, or monday and tuesday pies for 9…
It’s one of the few places I’ve been to that gets the ratio of the pizza correct. (dough to sauce to cheese). They also have sicilian pies which, by itself is pretty difficult to find here, let alone good sicilian pizza.
Oh, they also have really good cannolis :)

Great to have an option to all of the national chains nearby. Ordered the Sicilian, a large thin crust and apple/​walnut salad. The gentleman taking the order indicating the salad was a great pick, and he was right. The thin crust tasted like true New York pizza and the salad was exceptional. We enjoyed the Sicilian, but not quite as much as the thin crust and salad.
The family is all looking forward to trying the pizza (and salad!) again soon.

This is my new favorite pizza place. Located near the suncoast trailhead, it’s a great place to refuel and relax.
The pizza is so much better than that Mellow place. Sit down and watch a ball game, or grab a pie to go.
The stromboli is amazing, the garlic knots should not be missed, and the 28 inch pie will blow your mind. And this all comes with their delicious home made red sauce. Thumbs up!

I’m coming back on a rainy Sunday and think it would be nice to bring home lunch.
New pizza shop opened up the road — let’s check it out!
I was only going to get a few slices but I see a white pie on the displays that is calling my name. Well I did not get it because I meet Nick — one of the brothers and we start talking hometown and of course they are from LI NY — where I used to live.
So back to the pizza. I did get a regular cheese pie with half chicken broccoli garlic Alfredo and it is outrageous good!
The boys have a great menu and they are friendly, accommodating and really Italian from NY. So they understand we need pizza and good Italian food here .
Go visit– get a slice!