Angelina’s Pizza & Subs

I recently picked a menu and ordered an XL just cheese with extra sauce. When I picked up my order they tried to charge me $ 19.25. The price on the menu is $ 14.99. The guy then proceeded to say the prices on the menu that I just picked earlier were incorrect and he had so many menus made so he was going still give them out to potential customers so they won’t go to waste. If you order pizza from these crooks make sure to ask the price if you are looking at their menu because the prices are incorrect according to them. Also they tried to charge me $ 3.00 for extra sauce they consider that an extra topping
. I have never heard of this before. Instead of making it right he just handed me back my money. Needless to say I won’t be going back.

Good pizza &they DELIVER! !!! Cannollis r good and garlic knots. Much better pizza than Pizza hut. Subs are great. get meatball sub yum.

This is not an accurate listing. Went to this location ordered online and they said «they don’t do online»… Not sure who I gave my credit card information to but it’s definitely not them…

About 3 weeks ago I ordered a Stromboli for these people, they seemed nice enough but when it got here it the dough wasn’t cooked the manger said when I come back into town he would «hook me up». Just called them the same manger was extremely rude and try to make it seem like he had no idea about what I was talking about. I was told I would get a call back and never did. Will never order form them again. And would suggest you you make sure your order is right before letting them go or they will screw you out of money and food. I only wish there was a way to give no stars

Great spinach calzones. Very flavorful and fresh pizza. Fries aren’t homemade but are made fresh. The inside was nothing special so takeout is better. Great staff too.

My wife is a Philly native and I’ve had many stays in NY so I’m a bit of a pizza snob. Angelina’s is truly the best pizza I’ve had in a long time and the best canolli I’ve ever had. The owner and his family are very friendly as well. I’m lucky that I moved into their delivery area. I’ve ordered ½ a dozen times and it’s consistently good.

Our family eats here almost weekly cause I can’t resist the chicken cheese steaks. The Philly cheese steaks are awesome too but I’m trying to be little healthier with my choices. Pizza is really good New York style with huge cheesy slices. Keep up the great job!

Who knew you could get such great food from a gas station!!! This place is awesome. I have ordered pizzas, soup, sandwiches, pastas and all have been great. And they deliver, which so many places around here do not, so that is an additional plus.
Their pasta fagoili is absolutely DELICIOUS, if you are lucky enough to order some before they run out. I have ordered their margherita pizza which is absolutely awesome, even as leftovers! I really have nothing negative to say about this place.
I have only ordered for pick up or delivery so I cannot say much about eating there, but it is definitely worth a shot!

This is a very inconsistent restaraunt, once it was delicious, the other three times, not very good. The pizza was doughy and the cheese wasn’t very melted. It was also very greasy.

I recently moved into the area & was searching for a pizza place. I grew up in Philadelphia, so kind of a Pizza snob. Its’ not Ny, but it’s close enough that we KNOW good pizza! I read the reviews for this place on Unilocal and decided we would go in & get slices & some wings, just as a trial run. OMG! Great pizza, slices the size of your head & wings were really good, too. I’m not a huge wing fan, but my BF loves them. We got the garlic Parmesan wings & he devoured them. He’s very picky about wings, but he confirmed, these wings are GREAT. even i thought so & I can’t remember every saying that about a chicken wing. We will definitely be ordered a full pie next time, with wings on the side, of course.

I’ve been holding back on my review until I felt that I had enough experience with them.
They seem to be kind of hit or miss. I typically go there on lunch, as I work nearby.
The pizza is pretty good, but I’ve had better within similar driving distance. Huge slices.
The subs are pretty good, but its not what I expected. Big subs.
The pepperoni rolls are very good. Big rolls.
Don’t get me wrong. It all tastes good and the presentation is completely fine, but I don’t feel like its great for the price.
I ordered a hot Italian Sub this time around. I picked it up a little early, as quoted times always give a little padding. My sub was ready upon my arrival. I drove 2 minutes to my normal secluded lunch area and found that the sub was just warm with the bread barely crunchy and the cheese barely melty.
I was a little disappointed, but it still tasted good.
I’ve had pizza here that was really good, and not good.
I have yet to have a pepperoni roll that wasn’t great
I won’t stop my patronage here, but I will stick to going there when I’ve gotten tired of other places in the area.

We were visiting relatives in Odessa and they recommended picking up Angelina’s for a late dinner after a day at the beach. The takeout menu said they closed at 9:30 but when I called to confirm they were open, it was a minute before they closed at 9p. They insisted it was no problem to take care of our order except for the items they sold out of for the day.
We were shocked at how good the food was. The gas station setting is deceiving. The cheese steaks were fantastic. The house salad was fresh. The chicken parm sandwich was tasty. The garlic knots were addictive. The pizza roll was sliced and enjoyed by several of us. We asked about the cake cups and were encourage to try them. Delicious and not at all what you expect from a convenience case.
Had a great conversation with the owner who was friendly and helpful.

Love the pizza!!! Done let the location stop you from getting great pizza! A little piece of New York in Odessa!

I’ve had the opportunity to try this place a couple of times now and each time I can say it is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. It has the perfect balance of sauce, toppings, and crust. What really makes it memorable is that the crust is not cardboardy as it can be at places that serve this type of pizza. I was a bit skeptical at first since it is located inside a Shell gas station, but it will leave you pleasantly surprised. So glad I’ve been able to discover this hidden gem so close to home!

I eat here a lot because I work nearby. At this point I have all my coworkers addicted to the Hot Italian Subs here. They are my favorite even if they come out of a gas station, and especially because they come out of a gas station. The pizza is great, although you can’t order slices for delivery, but the slices are huge. The wings are done extra crispy and you don’t even have to order them that way. The only thing I’ve ever had here that I didn’t love was their blue cheese. They are always slammed, and always friendly, just give them plenty of time because you’d hate to stress any pizza shop out of a gas station that has chosen quality over speed everytime.

Great pizza every time! I don’t know how to fill out entire review, but this is one of the best pizza joints in the area. Beats some of the old local spots with ease.
With the pie and knots so good, I can’t wait to try out the rest of the menu.

Had a great little meal here. It is in a gas station but this is some of the best pizza and calzones I’ve had in Florida. Home made desserts too. Check it out if you like good New York style pizza. Owner is from the Bronx and very friendly.

Amazing! Everything I have had here has been sooo good. Their food is fresh and the employees are so personable. Do not let the fact that it is in a gas station scare you away. This family owned italian restaurant is a gem. The wonderful cooks will personalize any order. Try the conolis… they are to die for!

Best pizza in land o lakes! We eat there all the time!!! Food is always consistent, the people who work there are always nice and we love their food!!! Don’t let the gas station fool you, this pizza is LEGIT!!!

I eat here pretty frequently, but usually just order pizza. Yesterday, we decided to grab an Italian and we’re glad we did. Nice, thick slices of Genoa salami, decent amount of ham and wonderfully sharp Provolone cheese topped with lettuce, tomatoes and vinaigrette dressing. Very toothsome! I give it a solid 4 on my Italian sammich scale.