Tonys New York Pizza

As a Oak Park resident, and graduate from Oak Park High School in 2000, I have been going to Tony’s for over 20 years. Just today I took my daughter and son there for lunch and it was great! As always, i ordered slices (Cheese, Pepporoni, and Sausage) with ranch. As usual the pizza was excellent and delicious. My daughter and son both loved it. I have never had a bad experience. I know that my friends who frequent here like their pizza to be more cooked and if you tell them they will cook it a little bit longer. The manager there is awesome and played with my kids so i could eat. He took time to come around the counter and keep them entertained. Thank you Mehdi! I have never had anyone do anything like that. A slice of Tonys pizza, ranch and a pepsi! Awesome!

I’ve been reading other reviews and I haven’t seen too many people mention their pizza sauce. It’s absolutely amazing! They’re extremely polite and fast on delivery. Love this place!

I like Tony’s! It’s my favorite pizza place in this area. Pizza is just the right thin/​thickness on the thin side. I particularly like the eggplant topping. And always have the Italian salad with the pickled veggies! Yum! (Even though they incorrectly call it peppercinis).

Good pizza, this is now my new go to pizza place. If you are in the neighborhood or nearby you should try this pizza.

FYI: Our family did a taste test comparison between a large Tonys cheese pizza and a large Ameci pizza… Not even close! The Amecis Agoura Hills pizza was far better testing, better sauce, better crust, better cheese, and not soggy like Tonys. Nobody would even eat the Tonys… It was tossed.

The pizza was soggy and cheese was rubbery. I didn’t eat the majority of the pizza. Won’t order from here again.

Nice people, love there food, it feels not like fast food, lasagna mmmmmm so good
Prices are good
Malibu Randy

Gross. Soggy. Limp. Saucy. Never again. I can’t understand the positive reviews. So bad we threw away the leftovers. A lot of leftovers. Who throws away pizza? It was that bad!

I had to go back and write another review for this establishment since they have provided us with a great customer service experience from my last review. After we were disappointed with a non delivery order, either the owner or the manager called my husband and apologized for the incident. He offered us a free meal on the house for the inconvenience at anytime. He took my husbands info and reassured us that all we had to do was call and give his name. Since we normally do not order take out often we waited a couple of weeks. Just last night we ordered and they recognized him immediately and even had our original order on file. They asked if we wanted the same order or something else. We kept the same. I want to say they got to our place in less than 20min. We were so impressed… way to go on turning a negative situation into a positive experience. Food was great, chicken wings were delicious. We will definitely order again and brag on the excellent customer service.

Amazing place!!! There is no other besides this place that provide this amazing pizza. Most reviews here are great and the bad one is confusing it with Tonys in Newbury park.

I’ve eaten here many times. This really is the best pizza in Oak Park. Always fresh.
I dislike places that use canned products; Tony’s actually cooks its own pizza sauce from scratch. No wonder it tastes so fresh.
I love their crust too; it’s really light and flavorful.
The guys who who work here are awesome; Sam is the best.
My buddy who introduced me to Tony’s, orders their giant sized pizza, and believe me, he eats all of it himself. He’s a monster. lol

I get cheese pizza from Tony’s at least once a week. The pizza is always fresh and made on time. Definitely hits the spot for me :) I had them deliver it on a few occasions and the delivery time has always been quicker compares to the Pizza Hut (which closed down) or Dominos

If you like pizza that falls over as you pick it up this is the place plus tony makes the dough

Tony’s — hole in the wall. In fact so much so that there is no place to sit or maybe a couple seats. But who cares, this is the best single outlet pizza place in the neighbor hood and aptly so. Everything from the dough to the pizza is made right in front of our eyes, the ingredients are super fresh and the veggies are beautiful. Service is quick the menu is compact and they do what they know best make pizzas. I loved their wings too. Very functional on time pizza place. The quality is consistent and the staff is very friendly. It’s pretty decently prized as well. It’s on the strip mall between Kannan and lindero and I know many mom’s around the area order Tony’s for bake sale, birthday parties and what not. Give it a try. I am sure you will love it.

Literally the best pizza I’ve had in Los Angeles. I just ate ½ of a large combo pie, and it was freaking beautiful.
No, it doesn’t taste exactly like N.Y. pizza. That’s not realistic. But it tastes like heaven… And should be in everyone’s mouth.

Delicious pizza and quick delivery makes for one happy girl. I recommend Tony’s to the good people of Westlake Village and Oak Park.

Great pizza! Quick service! Consistent. Salads and pasta are great too. My husband and I usually split a medium pizza and an Italian salad. It’s plenty of food for two and about $ 15. Can’t beat it!

This place makes the best pizza you can get. They haven’t changed a thing for the past 15 years. Nothing comes close in this area. Mushrooms are thinly sliced and generously spread as one of the available toppings, the dough is fresh and fluffy, the cheese and sauce combine in harmony along with oil (not sure if it’s olive oil) and a dose of great sauce seasonings… Hold on, I’m on my way! Make sure to ask for a side of ranch dressing — it’s bangin’!

After so many 5 star reviews one more almost seems pointless.
Real cheese on fresh crust! I just can’t understand why everyone doesn’t make it this way. It used to be the only way but now, only a few places, like Tony’s still do it right.
I’m a complete pizza snob, that’s what people tell me, and Tony’s makes great, real, old school pizza.

I’ve gotten so much terrible pizza in this area and kind of gave up hope of ever finding a good pizza place. Then I happened to discover Tony’s and their pizza is SO good.
I’ve always seen pizza commercials and wondered why the cheese never actually looked like that. Well at Tony’s, it does. Everything about their pizza is perfect.
The people who worked there were super friendly too, and they let me have a free soda refill.
Will absolutely be coming back!