OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

Eh, it’s okay. A little pricey and not the biggest flavor selection. I still prefer Sundaes and Cones over this place.

This is for the chocolate chip ice cream sandwich. While the ice cream was very yummy, the chocolate chip cookies were not. The problem with the cookies was the salt. Big pieces of salt on these chocolate chip cookies was not only unnecessary but made the cookies almost inedible. Additionally, the cookies were very hard.
While I would go back for the ice cream, I would strongly advise against a chocolate chip ice cream sandwich.
Please remove the big chunks of salt from the cookies!
Also, overpriced.

The Caramel Chocolate Toffee flavor is fantastic! My friend did a make your own type Odd Pocket sandwich (normally not allowed but the lady working was nice and recommended flavors and toppings). She topped it with salted caramel and cornflake crunch. Best ice cream sandwich I have EVER had. The rich and crunch toffee, with the bit of salted caramel and cold ice cream was such a bit of sweet and salty, creamy and crunchy and cold and warm.
I had the Cornbread Odd Pocket which was good, just not as great as what my friend had. The cornbread ice cream was very mild and the tartness of the blueberries were much needed. It just didn’t have that contrasting salty element like my friend’s did.
My other friend had the apple pie creation (I forget what the actual name of it was) but it was just a bit too sweet for me. It did taste exactly like an apple pie ala mode though!

TL;DR That cornbread ice-​cream man.
This review is completely based on the fact that their cornbread ice-​cream was indeed cornbread tasting.
Seriously…imagine how cornbread flavored ice-​cream would taste lick (oops my sub concious is typing) and that’s how oddfellows’ one taste like. It’s liek they put high quality cornbread in a blender and froze it and POOF out came this ice cream. This cornbread ice cream tasted better than 75% of the cornbread I had in my life. That’s how good this cornbread ice cream was.

I ordered the brown butter sage toasted brioche and it was amazing ! This place was such a great idea and I love their theme. 5 stars, I’ll be coming back plenty of times

Very tiny place with cute, vintage décor. There was only one worker so the service was a bit on the slow side.
We ordered the chocolate chunk odd pocket and it was pretty good! I love a warm base with ice cream because the two temperatures just work so well when it enters your mouth! It comes in a warm brioche bun and it’s topped with rice krispies? I recommend trying this odd pocket! You can also customize your own pocket, which is cool but I just Unilocaled and found one that looked good and got it.

oddfellows. i’ve seen nothing odd and i’ve never seen a male employee at this location. FALSE ADVERTISING.
the short n sweet. tiny ice cream shop. brightly lit. cute, cozy, very EV (east village not extra virgin). a few seats at the window and a bench outside.
the ice cream is very good. you can sample. some flavors are hits like s’mores, various chocolate variations, the pumpkin or apple ice cream (they excel at variations of basic flavors) and others are big swings ‘n’ misses like the miso cherry (which tastes good via sample, but a whole cone of it is no bueno. cloying and weird after taste is the common no bueno feeling.)
however, the staff is friendlyish. when they first opened. customer service was impeccable. now i feel it’s like every other ice cream shop ‘cept DAVEY’s whose staff is quirky n baller n superfriendly still. but i digress. for a ice cream break – you can’t go wrong here.
the real winners at OddFellows might be the build your own ice cream sandwiches or the SIGNATURE ice cream sandwiches like the CARAMEL APPLE ICE CREAM SANDWICH: apple ice cream, white chocolate, and graham cracker. so good. $ 7 so pricing is steep.
OddFellows has a customer loyalty card. ten ice cream purchases gets you a free scoop which is pretty meh – basically spend 50 bucks get a free ice cream. ugh.
you can also buy pints of the flavors of the day. ah the other catch… the flavors change daily, so a favorite flavor today gone tomorrow. basically the flavors change every day, so you either have to go to the website or stop into the store to check whether a flavor you like is being served. the variety and spontaneity is a cool hook, but that’s too much work for a glutton like me… and would become tiresome if a flavor i like is not back on the rotation.
drops mic because i have to go to a website to look up what this shop is serving today!
i out.
zzz

Small place but big in taste ! I had toasted coconut with milk chocolate ice cream
Two scoops of yummy ness ! Friendly staff they also do ice cream sandwiches which my friend had ! Check it out you won’t regret it plus they stay open pretty late !

My never-​ending quest for yummy lactose-​free ice cream continues!
I had visited OddFellows in Williamsburg with friends before and noted that they claim to have «Lactaid pills upon request!» I was curious to see what non-​dairy options they had, but was disappointed at the time that they only had sorbet.
I stopped by the new location in Manhattan and lo and behold! Three non-​dairy flavors! «Thai Tea,» «Coffee,» and «Chocolate.» And on the sign they offered Lactaid pills for 50 cents.
I opted for the vegan coffee flavor, which I thought was outstanding. The Thai Tea and Chocolate flavors were not nearly as good. We all got waffle cones, and they were more cinnamon-​y than usual but still good. Something about it was a little weaker and flakier than it should’ve been, and mine broke (I don’t even know my own strength). Fortunately, I caught the remainder of my cone and put it in a bowl.
The location is TINY, good music, very warm inside. Makes for a good snuggle-​friendly ice cream date during the winter time.

Location: located at 4^th street, Odd Fellow is pretty small. But it is definitely stood up compared to other stores. The decoration gives me a sense that it may be a toy store for kids, since it is decorated with warm colors like red and red. LOL Anyway, the store is small but has everything. Everything includes, 3 seats, a long table, a huge fridge which includes all the must-​try-​ice-​cream from Odd Fellow.
Ice cream: I had Match Crunch. It is creamy, flavory, and delicious. The crunchiness made you feel like kit kat match chocolate, but the cream gets you back to the reality that you are actually enjoying ice cream right now. I really want to try their signature ice cream sandwich, which is such a renovation for the ice cream industry that I should barely miss it. But I will leave for next time when I have my cheat day.
Service: really friedly to let me try some flavors. The black pepper fig is weird but still sweet and delicious. I am curious how they find the balance between all the weird flavors. The guy is nice and when I checked in with Unilocal,I got a pin!
Price: 4 dollars for a scoop, maybe expensive but still, it could be one of the best ice cream in Manhattan.
Overall: a must come back store and 5 stars for sure.

I have heard great things about this place but frankly, was disappointed. Maybe the flavors that were rotated the time that I went just happened to not suit my palate? It was just too sweet and a bit pricey too.
I had the Cornbread Oddpocket and the Brown Butter one. They were both just too sweet especially with the added drizzle on top. And they were 8.00 a pop.

The ice creams are delicious and the flavors are definitely unique and out there. It’s super creamy and sharp. I got an odd pocket and wished I got a cone instead. I felt there were too much bread and syrup masking the beautiful flavor of the ice cream.
Let the ice cream be the intended star.

This tiny window of a store with a little counter barely big enough for 3 people and a little store barely big enough for 6 people sells some delicious ice cream. Thank goodness Brooklyn and the East Village like to talk to each other. I can enjoy the caramelized white chocolate almond (always popular) and the Matchabar flavor which is amazing. It makes me want to stalk the MatchaBar but I haven’t made it to the ‘burg location just yet. Its hard to cross the bridge.
The flavors are always a bit unique. Strawberry Black Pepper is another one of my favorites. I usually walk by after hitting up my gym and hope they don’t have a flavor I like. They have 7 flavors on any given day (one sorbet for you vegan-​ys) and now make ice cream sandwiches (the kind with cookies as the ‘bread’).

When we went the store looked like it was under construction and we were informed they were in the process of changing their flavors therefore the selection was very small. After tasting a couple of flavors, I ended up getting the Caramelized white chocolate with almond. If you like nuts and caramel, this is the flavor for you!
Looking forward to coming back and trying out more flavors.

This location is smaller than Brooklyn original shop, but it is cute and charming.
Sign decal on the window (same as they have on the cart at the catering events) and same delicious ice cream — all handmade, and so, so, so good!
We picked up few pints for friend’s party — and it was a hit! Both Olive Oil & White Chocolate Caramel were loved by everyone. Olive Oil is unique — I did try it a while back, it is smooth, light, and creamy.
We also got few flavors to try on site — who can resist, really? I had Cherry Miso, which I tried before, and loved to bits — it is sweet, a little salty, well-​mixed flavor. I also took a spoon or too from my friend’s order — Lime and Taragon sorbet was tangy & refreshing, such a perfect summer flavor.
We were surprised it was not too busy midday on Sunday — and they even have seats in the shop.
What are you waiting for? Go check it out!
(I am coming back often in my hunt for their Guinness flavor. One day, I will catch it!)

*** Fresh, Unique flavors, Delicious ***
A definite must try if you’re an ice cream addict. There’s an assortment of unique flavors that you can test out before deciding on what you want to fill your stomach with. The location is tiny, but there is seating area inside and outside of the store. Highly recommend!

My plan: to visit every single (GOOD) ice cream shoppe in NYC (and everywhere else in the world).
I loved: Thai iced tea, matcha, extra virgin olive oil ice cream.
Shout out to the girl who served us, she kept her friendliness game going even at the end of the night with customers fiending for ice cream (me).
If they continue to rotate new flavors, I’ll definitely come back.
Note:
— Small place with a few spots to sit
— They take credit cards
— They have stamp cards

Fresh and creamy, the perfect dinner.[1]
OddFellow’s ice cream varieties are delicious SWAT teams, specialized-​yet-​coordinated. The smooth texture of their Thai ice cream is Thai iced tea distilled to perfection. Their chocolate chunk is chunky crunchity good, a must-​try.
Get your dessert to go, this location is tiny.
[1] It’s okay to have ice cream for dinner, I won’t tell anyone.

And the ice cream at night adventure continues! They change their flavors daily and keep some all time favorites. I was debating between a few flavors to commit to and ended up going with the black pepper strawberry. This was super interesting! My tongue was having a party! I was so happy; I love discovering such creative flavors.
The only downside is their size — their one scoop is legit one scoop. Some places serve a huge one scoop that looks like two scoops.
I don’t usually do repeats but I would definitely come back to try the other flavors!

Delicious! Tasty! Great consistency!
I taste tested the burnt caramel and vanilla bean. Both were good. Vanilla won over because I wanted to try the salted caramel topping.
Salted caramel was a bit too much for the vanilla flavor. Maybe half the sauce would have been better. It was still good just not the best combo. Store was clean but had the feeling of stepping back in time. The employees were friendly and helpful and when you try ice cream, you get to use a real metal spoon instead of a tiny plastic one. So simple but made me feel like I had picked the correct place to enjoy a frozen treat.
One scoop plus topping in a cup was $ 5. Good eats, cheap price point. Next time I’m in the LES, I’ll be back!