Lincoln Square Steak

I had my birthday dinner here with a part of 7 last night and it was great! I booked the reservation via open table and when they called to confirm they asked if it was a special event and I said it was my birthday. Without making special requests they gave us an awesome table in their blue private dining room, a menu with happy birthday on it and deserts for the table. Their attention to detail and the service was fantastic! They even took a picture of our table and had it printed before we left. Not only was the service 5 stars but the food was wonderful as well! This is a neighborhood gem and we will Definitely be back!

I had the pleasure of dining at Lincoln Square Steak this evening. Not only was my New York Strip steak one of the best I ever had the ambience food and service were beyond excellent!
This was such an overall POSITIVE. Experience. I thought the restaurant had very good acoustics as well as although busy it was not noisy and it was easy to carry on a conversation
I cannot wait to go back!
Ellie

My wife arrange for us to have a night in the city for our 2^nd Anniversary and she chose this restaurant because, well, who doesn’t love a good steak!
During the course of our dinner, every person who dealt with us wishes us a happy anniversary which was very nice. At our table our menus were printed with a happy anniversary message, a nice touch to make our evening special.
The food we ordered was a porterhouse for 2 with creamed spinach, potato gratin and truffle Mac and cheese. While we were waiting we emerge treated to a delicious homemade bread and a sample of the mushroom ravioli, also delicious.
The porterhouse was cooked perfectly and delicious. Spinach was the best I have had in a steakhouse so far and I love the fact that it was not overly creamy. Potato gratin were very nice also. My wife loved the truffle Mac and cheese.
We were not going to have a desert because the meal was enough but another surprise, a chocolate soufflé to share with a happy anniversary message on the plate along with a nice photo keepsake from the manager. What a lovely way to finish off a perfect meal.
They certainly made our experience memorable with not just the food but he service and the atmosphere. Wonderful restaurant.

What an awesome experience. I took my parents while in town and it was my wife’s birthday. They went out of their way to make the experience memorable. Free appetizers and free desserts and asked to take our picture to remember the experience. All in all it was great food at a reasonable price with remarkable service.
Next special occasion you have don’t think twice to go to Lincoln Square Steak!

The BEST dry aged steak on the upper west side. I normally will only go to a downtown steak house staple and tried this on a whim. Management is very cool and staff is on point. Most importantly the steak is cooked perfect temperature and has the crust I live for.

Once again, I took a large group to LSS. This time they asked if we would prefer a private room, even though we hadn’t booked it. We accepted their offer and it was great! My group of ten had a wonderful time. From the private room we could hear the piano player from the lounge, which you normally can not hear in the dinning room. She was playing an appropriate selection of jazz tunes and it added the positive experience. Bruno comped our group with an intermezzo mushroom ravioli and some desserts. I keep coming back here for a reason. I love it and I get treated like family.

What a great experience! The food and service were absolutely stellar. Uncle Bruno the owner is clearly at the top of his game.

Was only here for drinks, as a friend had reserved a section at the bar for his birthday celebration, but the atmosphere and space was very nice. They also have a piano on a raised platform (a mini stage, I guess) near the bar and people were taking turns playing and serenading the party with show tunes (we had a lot of musicians in this group). Drinks were made strong and well. They have a nice selection of top shelf liquor, including some very nice whiskeys. It’s a rather classy place (I’m wondering what the patrons thought of our musically themed party) and I’d consider going back here to dine.

My wife and I made a booking at 6 and were promptly seated. This was our first dinner out with our 2 month old baby so we were expecting the worse but the service was amazing so we felt very comfortable and welcomed. The staff were very attentive. We noticed a few families as well which was a great sign.
No complaints with the food; the Maryland crab cake, prime NY strip steak and braised short ribs didn’t disappoint. They also gave us a complimentary pasta dish and dessert.
We live in the neighborhood so would definitely come back here with no hesitations.

Amazing food, beautiful atmosphere. I was just there for dinner with my good friend. We were greeted right away. This place is now one of my favorite steak house in the city. We started with a callas and some crispy Canadian bacon (amazing), then I had the filet mignon cooked perfect (med-​rare) and the owner sent us a few desserts on the house (cream puffs my favorite). We had a very good bottle of wine recommended by Bruno (the restaurant owner and a very pleasant delight person who came and checked on as very often). Today was the place 1 year anniversary and I believe this place will be around fur EVER. It is run by the family and the quality, presentation and the quantity is unbelievable. I’m
So glad my friend told me about this place. I will def go there over and over again. The food, the service the atmosphere, and the piano playing beautiful soft music. This is the perfect place to take your valentine date, but they will be full so make reservation!
Love it love it love it!!!

Reservation was for 730, got seated right away however we unfortunately were disregarded and had to call for a manager at 8 to get someone to even take our first drink order. Minus 4 stars just for that.
Atmosphere was lovely and lively and wine list exceptional. We ordered a $ 30 bottle of red.
My husb and I shared the ribeye which was just right for both of us– it’s not a big portion though so keep that in mind if you’re going to share– and unfortunately a section of it was burnt.
We also Ordered the creamed spinach (since that is what most Unilocalers are raving about) which was delicious but very very salty. Unless you really love spinach, two people can share this side.
Truffle Mac was perfect.
Had an assortment of their desserts, none of which blew us away. I don’t think they are made in-​house and you can tell.
Anyways, contrary to all other reviews– we did not love it. :(3 stars because it’s decent.

We live in the neighborhood and went to Lincoln Square Steak on New Year’s Day to celebrate my husband’s birthday. Spectacular!
I’ve seen so many restaurants come and go in this very large space over the years — happily it looks like this one will stay. The porterhouse for two was phenomenal, the onion rings were crunchy and salty and sweet, the asparagus was delicious — so food is GREAT. And even better, the incredibly personal service. Over the course of dinner we got to know the lovely sommellier Marco who checked in a number of times (and approved of my choice of a Chilean Carmenere — delicious) and to top it off, because we were celebrating my husband’s birthday, they not only took a picture for us — but printed it out and presented it to us at the end of the dinner — old school and so lovely.
Can’t say enough great things… want to go here for every occasion — even if that occasion is just the chance to eat an absolutely delicious steak.

Wow this place was AMAZING! Beautiful ambiance, great wait staff and also very delicious. We ordered the porter house for 2 and it was a bit more then we can eat but it was literally the best steak I had ever had. The waiter was ON IT the whole time. Not ONCE did we have to look for him and hope to find him. He always checked on us and kept our water and wine full at all times.
I highly suggest this place if you have the money to spend. Also, they went out of their way to take our physical picture to give us, give us free desserts and champagne when they realized my boyfriend had proposed!
Highly recommended and will definitely go back!

Beautiful décor, large bar area/​full bar room at entrance, with pianist. In main dining area, nice & quiet, outstanding, attentive service. Nice complementary amuse bouche & dessert sweets, & outstanding popovers.
Everyone loved their main courses, steak of course, & fish and sides. Will definitely go back!

My husband and I went here for his birthday this year and we both thoroughly enjoyed our meals. Walking into this steakhouse feel like stepping back into a Mad Men-​esque era with red walls, comfy booths, and beautiful murals on the walls. This joint is owned by the same management as Club A Steakhouse, and it really shows.
Located next to major attractions such as the Lincoln Center, we previously stopped by to get the pre-​fixe pre-​theatre menu, which includes an entrée, appetizer, and dessert for $ 39.
However, on this specific October evening, my husband got to try the NY strip steak and I got a try a bunch of the sides. I highly recommend the creamed spinach and the truffle mac and cheese. Both are exceptional in their own right. We were also able to bring a great Italian super tuscan to dinner for a $ 20 corkage fee, a very reasonable fee in my personal opinion. When we finished dinner, we got free soufflé and the owner came to take our picture. There were other personal touches like a menu with «Happy Birthday» written on it. Would definitely come back for a special occasion or the pre-​fixe. This restaurant is a great addition to the area.

We made a reservations based on the stellar Unilocal reviews and boy am I glad we did! We are visiting from Seattle for the weekend and wanted to have a fabulous dinner before we headed off to the Rockettes’ show.
We were greeted by a very friendly coat check and then we were greeted and taken to our table. We ordered a bottle of wine with our delicious dinner — I had a the price fixe with the filet mignon which was A+! The owner walked around and greeted us and made sure our meals were delicious and the temperature of the restaurant was right. It was! He also opened the door for us and walked us out as we were leaving — hands down best customer service we have ever received. Definitely will be back!

I had the pleasure of dining here last night with a group of 10 friends. The food, service and ambience were all top notch. I started with 6 pristinely fresh Bluepoint oysters and moved on to a perfectly cooked medium rare petit filet mignon, accompanied by lovely charred brussel sprouts, creamed spinach and hash browns. Service was on point and, as noisy dining rooms are a pet peeve of mine, I was pleased to find that I was able to converse with my friends without having to shout! Overall, a very enjoyable experience. I will definitely be back!

An UWS Gem!
I finally had a chance to try this steakhouse a few weeks ago. What a treat!
Great food, wonderful service and a terrific atmosphere. You feel welcome as soon as you walk in and Bruno, the owner, is clearly present and committed to ensuring a great experience for everyone. The Steak was amazing, the sides were delicious and the wide selection of wine made it easy to chose a bottle, affordable enough to afford two.
Don’t forget to ask Bruno to share the story behind the wonderful hand-​painted mural.
I look forward to visiting again soon.
Enjoy!

Most wonderful dinner with my daughter after her figure skating skating competition. On a whim, I was looking for a great steak place on our way home while we were on the west side. We chose Lincoln Square Steak after reading the stellar reviews and cannot say our dinner exceeded our exception. We had the most amazing prime rib– my daughter’s favorite and unexpected warmest personal welcome by the owner Bruno and his staff. They treated us to crème brûlée dessert and took a memorable picture which Bruno gave to us.
I will definitely come back with my daughter, other family members and with friends, as well recommend to anyone looking for a good meal and unparalleled dining experience.

Oh, wow, I had an excellent dinner at this place, but at a fairly high price.
Are you looking for some delicious and expensive steak in an upscale and sophisticated setting in the Upper West Side? My relatives were on the hunt for an excellent steakhouse in this part of New York, and we found out this place just opened. When I walked inside, I felt like I was inside a typical upscale restaurant in New York, and I was really under-​dressed, but you could wear something casual to this place.
One of the most expensive items on the menu is the Porterhouse Steak. Initially I was looking at the less expensive steak choices such as the Hanger Steak, but I was convinced to get the Porterhouse because it was a better quality cut of meat.
Although it was expensive at almost $ 50 per person, the steak is large enough for about two people to eat. We ordered it cooked medium rare, and it was so juicy and tender. After dipping it into some horseradish sauce, the flavor was even better. As for the side dishes, the asparagus was freshly cooked and had a decent flavor. The Au Gratin potatoes had a nice creamy taste and were a great complement to the asparagus. The Canadian Bacon was also really good, it was not overly fried and crispy, but had that juicy tenderness with the right amount of thickness. They gave us some free ravioli pasta as a nice little bonus, and that was also pretty good with a nice creamy flavor. The wine they served here was also an excellent complement to the steak, we had a Los Nevados Malbec 2013 red wine and had a nice taste with a few sips to wash the palate.
The service was pretty good. One of my relatives recently had a child, and although she was crying a lot, the staff was so friendly toward my niece. If you are looking for servers that are friendly toward young children, this place is great, as long as the children don’t do really bad things to this place. Everyone overall was just really nice, helpful and willing to answer any tough question related to this place.
Overall, I thought I had some of the tastiest steak in Upper West Side area of New York so far. If you really want the best steak experience, you should get the Porterhouse Steak cooked medium rare, and if you want an enhanced experience, you should get some of that Los Nevados Malbec red wine as a complement to the Porterhouse Steak. I also thought I had some of the best bacon in New York so far, and the bacon would be nice for a very hearty and tasty breakfast.
I love tasty good quality steak.
I love New York.
I really liked eating at this place.