Attila Toth, MD

I read Iris and Ira’s one star reviews and I am shocked. I traveled to NYC from South Florida to see Dr Toth because my cousin is also his patient. My cousin believed Dr Toth could help me have a child after IVF attempts I tried with my husband had failed. I called the office and asked them if he would take an older patient as I am in my mid to late 40s. HIs answer was and still is, «Age is the last thing I consider when we discuss your fertility.» EVERY OTHER DOCTOR always starts off very negative and causes me to stress out completely before we even begin. It almost is like other doctors chastise me for even considering it. I had my Florida hormone blood work sent in for him to review which supported that I have not entered menopause and I am indeed still fertile. Upon arrival, he came out to the lobby and greeted me. His staff was very helpful and very friendly. Before the exam he asked me a hundred questions, and just like my work when I need info from a client and I must direct them and cut off explanations to get it all done in time, he did the same to me, but I understand he is a doctor and scientist and he is looking for answers and clues to my body. In the middle of all the questions about topics most people balk at, he cracked some jokes to make me smile and we laughed. He made the whole ordeal bearable. He made me no promises. He examined me with respect and information the likes of which I have not been treated by any other obgyn ever. He turned the ultrasound screen so I could see it as he explained to me what he was looking at. He said I have one ovary with plenty of eggs and the other not so much. And, he showed me what he believes to be a big hindrance in my fertility and told me what we can do about it. He also did my annual exam and he was extremely thorough to look for lumps and swellings from the glands in my neck and behind my ears to my armpits and all of my breasts and he did not rush through it and refer me to a mammogram as other doctors have all done. After the exam, he took me back into his office and went over the pictures of the sonogram and again explained to me what he can do. No other doctor has ever considered the things he considers in fertility and in just a simple annual exam. Why all other doctors fail to do necessary testing or dismiss things blatantly infront of their faces and pass us women off to mammograms I will never understand. The way I see Dr Toth’s methodology is that he works to get the reproductive system as close to perfect as possible to support a healthy baby. And, in my case, to have one would be a miracle at my age and if I don’t get one, at least besting my health will only bolster me against any cancer or illness in my female system which affect too many women. I hope other patients will choose to inform the public what really can be done by Dr Toth which is NOT being done by all the obgyns I and my friends have ever experienced. And, as to only wealthy patients, I saw a hipster couple and a middle-​class African American couple there yesterday. Maybe it was them?

The other reviews are spot on. Spend a fortune, endure ridiculous pain and discomfort for weeks, and not only show 0 positive results — but took a huge leap backwards with respect to fertility. My wife hasn’t been the same since and the treatment had serious detrimental effects on our fertility. And Yes, beware the phantom chlamydia findings. Yes, same experience here as the other reviewer. That’s always an interesting conversation to have with your significant other. Never once had my wife or I been diagnosed but somehow Dr. Toth found some odd strain. Sort of makes you feel good that you may be on the road to recovery that you may have killed some bacteria, but if it doesn’t really exist — its just a scam. Soaks you for your $, gives you a warm fuzzy, makes his procedure seem legit and you’d be missing out on life if you don’t do it. Stay far far away!

Dr. Toth is a complete fraud.

Toth is a nice old man, with a funny mustache and a bit of humor. He is also rude, condescending, unhelpful, extremely obnoxious and unapproachable. Especially after he asks what you do and learns you don’t have all that much money. He then sends a nice letter saying that we have different «medical philosophy» and I better look for another (read: cheaper) doctor. Nice going. So, if you have a trust fund — he will be happy to have you share it with him. If you don’t, this is a complete waste of time and resources — he just doesn’t care for your kind…

I came to see Dr. Attila Toth after I had done an extensive research on the web. According to some reviews, he is a «king of antibiotics», «inventor of revolutionary approach to infertility treatment», and «an exceptional person.» His services and test cost at least 20K for a couple.
I first set up the phone consultation. It costs 375 $ for an hour. The conversation with Dr. Toth left me with a weird, better say, an unpleasant feeling. The guy sounded extremely arrogant and inconsiderate. He was talking without a break the whole hour, and when I tried to put a word, he said: «Your time is over, I have other things to do.» This was it.
I decided to try again. This time I made an appointment in his office. I flew from Washington to NYC.
He looked and sounded wacky. Very bourgeois, self-​obsessed, with terrible bedside manners, on the one hand. Very convincing and optimistic about outcome of the treatment, on the other hand. Most of the time during consultation he was asking senseless, unceremonious questions. Then he proposed to have culture study and a sonogram. I agreed. It cost me $ 1 815. In the end he said: «You should not be worried anymore. I’ll take care of everything. I’ll cure you.» Well… I came back home very encouraged, and convinced my husband to have all tests as well. He did so. It cost him $ 1 815
($ 3 630 for both).
After 4 weeks of wait, we got an email from Dr. Toth with culture study results. He found chlamydia, which was never found before and after by other OBGYNs. The final words were: «My advice to both of you would be to contact your LOCAL gynecologist and urologist respectively and request proper therapy for this infectious condition.» What???
I called back and asked whether he wants to work with us. I’ve already changed my plans for the next month so that to spend two weeks in NYC for treatment at Dr Toth office. It turned out that doctor had changed his mind afterward, and would NOT have us as patients.
My question to him was if he could recommend any other doctor who would work with his test results. The answer was «NO.» He sounded very rude and annoyed.
As I said, no other doctor have found chlamydia afterwards. It means the following: (1) Dr. Toth, most probably, falsificated results; (2) we wasted our money and time; (3) this guy prefers to deal with rich people, we didn’t belong to his «target audience»; (4) he is is a dishonest, irresponsible and unreliable person.
CONCLUSION: IF AFTER ALL THIS YOU’LL DECIDE TO DEAL WITH DR. ATTILA TOTH, BLAME YOURSELF FOR CONSEQUENCES. OR BETTER — STAY AWAY FROM HIM!