Superstar’s Beer City

Huge selection of beers. Employees were super helpful and knowledgeable as well.
Only reason why this place gets 4 stars instead of 5 stars is:
Not all drinks have their prices labeled, so it’s kind of annoying sometimes trying to figure out how much something will cost you. Of course, you can ask the employees there, but it’s work you shouldn’t have to do.

Do ya thing beeeeeer cityyyyyyy! They legit have every beer from old time favs like Budweiser to the newest, craft, high alcohol content, IPA, crazy beers! They’re the best around the holidays also bc they ALWAYS get the best seasonal beers. It’s clean, they’re helpful and they even sell ice and coolers so you can grab and go to wherever you need to with cold brews kids! Everyone I know goes here so just go and take a look I’m sure you will find something to meet your every desire and taste of BEER! They sell ping pong balls at the register and other little fun games for your drinking journey lol.

One of the best beer stores on LI. I stop there multiple times when I visit about 4 times a year. Everyone is very friendly and are happy to answer questions. They sell single bottles and growlers which is great when you just want to try certain beers without buying a 6 pack. Keep it up guys!

I love it here. I’m like a kid on Christmas morning browsing through shelf after shelf of heavenly craft beers. The selection is huge! The prices are on point! The staff is super friendly. And the growler station is always rotating out some banging brews! Sign up for email alerts for deals, coupons, tasting events and new releases!

The BEST beer selection. All different types of beer from all over the world. If you can’t find what you’re looking for they’ll help you find it. The prices are what you’d expect, but they have good specials that are always changing.

Shady mothers running this joint. I was ’tising the season with a pumpkin ale fix… brought what I thought was a magic hat pumpkin 6 pack to counter along with another 6 pack pumpkin ale & 2 22oz and $ 42 later… got to friends house only to be called «punked» because my magic hat container contained no magic hat but some weird German «nitzel» beer. I’m now driving back giving them benefit of doubt that some punk customer did this to save a buck. I get to counter and Wolfman like dude behind counter is all oh I told you this when you bought it. Um NO you didn’t why would I be buying a slew of pumpkin beers in pumpkin cartons if I wanted German schnitzel beer! He says «they don’t always give us cartons for beer so we have to put in WRONG MISLEADING cartons» So low and behold
they don’t have any LEGIT magic hat
pumpkin cold so I ask them to suggest
another. They do, I take. & wolf behind counter has nerve to tell me I owe him $ 2.17. I say really?! You guys are selling trickery, I’m driving all over deer park tonight & I OWE YOU?! He says «yes it’s more $» I say ok, I will be leaving some nice reviews for your place then on internet. He says without a sorry or twitch, «ok» I say are you the owner? He says «nope!» With a smirk. Great business! Owner should be proud that he’s proudly cheating his customers where he can and supports having smug employees that support bad customer service.

This place is just freaking huge with beers everywhere. There’s a line of all fridged beers that goes on for a while. A pretty darn good selection and they seem to know their stuff when it comes to beer as I overheard a conversation between a worker and someone who needed craft beer recommendations.

Beer City. What can I say? The name says it all. Nestled in a small strip mall area tucked behind a TD Bank on Deer Park Avenue in Deer Park, NY this place is a treasure of hoppy delights!
Beers from all corners of the globe adorn the shelves and freezers of this establishment. One just has to look around to see that their idea of craft brews and fine imports is way beyond expectation and that one’s idea of how many beers are produced throughout the world has been limited to lack of real exposure to the global brewing phenomenon that is growing at an exponential pace.
Beer from England, Germany, Turkey and China, as well as the nether reaches of Washington, Oregon, and Colorado are all tucked away neatly like a library whose Dewy Decimal System was thrown away to be replaced by names such as Hoptical Illusion and Arrogant Bastard. One can wander among the cases stacked high or into the freezer to explore the icy confines for the perfectly chilled addition to one’s football party or barbecue. If a growler is called for, the many taps against the wall of the freezer has a fine choice of craft beers that will truly have you wanting to buy quite more than just one.
The staff is always helpful and remembers their regulars. They will even carry the sleeve of ice you ordered to your car if your hands are full. My local supermarket needs to take a few lessons from these guys and start bringing my bags to my car, because if I could live on chips and beer alone Stop and Shop would lose me a customer forever!
Beer City. What’s in a name? Apparently the simplicity of it says it all. Don’t go anywhere else!

Been meaning to review Beer City for a while since it’s just down the road…
Excellent selection of every beer you could dream of, and if they don’t have the beer you want, they will get it for you (if they can!!)
Kegs/​cases/​craft beer/​growler filling station with some of the best craft beers on tap!
Whenever I need beer, I come here — Hands Down!

Best selection, best prices, and best service by far in town. The service is knowledgeable, friendly, and they really go above and beyond to accommodate requests /​questions. AND they have growlers. Come on!

I was hesitant to give five stars, as I typically try to reserve them… but honestly, the description «Woohoo! As good as it gets!» is the perfect way to describe this place in terms of beer selection and price,
30 pack of coors lite in a reusable cooler bag for $ 24? Yes, please!
LoL and that’s just the tiniest tip of a very large iceberg of frothy deliciousness in this overflowing Emerald City of beer. Always our last stop on the way to nearby Robert Moses beach.

Very expensive, do not go here!!! You can go to a CVS or a Rite Aid and get the same beer for less! These people are scam artists and ripped me off when I purchased a keg from here years ago. I’ll never go here again. I think the guy who ripped me off was named Frank. Go to Brightwaters beer distributor instead or any other beer distributor. Stay away from here

If I could give this place ten stars you can bet your bottom dollar I would!
I love beer and have been to beverage stores all over Long Island. None of them compare to this one!
The exit/​entrance is easy and so is parking. I write that for people like me who avoid places just because it is nerve-​wracking to pull out or something.
The staff are some of the coolest people ever. Knowledgeable on thier products, friendly and always willing to help. Do not hesitate to ask them for recommendations. They also have a growler station with exciting ice cold beers on tap. They will let you sample something if you ask!
My favorite part is the selection. They have something for everyone and carry products that others do not. For example a brewery that has been around since 1040! You have to try their Dark Hefeweizen — the brand is called Weihenstephaner and it is SO GOOD.
My other top recommendations for delicious brews are ANY of the Ommegang Brewery beers, Samuel Smith’s Organic Strawberry beer and Well’s Banana Bread beer. I also frequently get the Paulaner Salvator Double Bock which is soo full flavored.
I just love this place. Wish it were closer to me. Or maybe that wouldn’t be a good idea ;)

These guys are still awesome in my book. During the 2010 holiday season they were out of one of my favorite beverage flavors and they had it picked up during a run to their amityville location and called us as promised that same night before they closed to pick it up.