Scotty’s Brewhouse

can I give 4.5 stars? Our first experience at this location everything was great except the server had to redo our bill about 4 times. Our second visit we had an awesome waitress who was on top of everything and had a winning, smiling personality. My son who is 3 absolutely loves Scotty’s. I think their free VIP rewards program is great (free kids meals on Tues/​Sun). We’ve more often frequented the 96^th street location (honestly not a big fan of the recent remodel at 96^th compared to what it was before), but we like this new location in noblesville. great atmosphere, love the round booths and firepit inside is nice.

I dunno, the Noblesville location just lacks the energy that brings me back to Scotty’s so often. Service was alright, food was alright, atmosphere was alright. Obviously you get what you’d expect from a location in Noblesville, but I guess it just seemed inadequate. I’ll definitely be sticking to my guns and frequenting the Downtown location whenever I have a say in the matter in the future.

We were very excited to have a restaurant/​bar so close to our new house however we’ve been here 3 times and never been impressed. The service is always terrible and the food is sub par at best and over priced. There are several servers scurrying around but we always have empty drinks and it takes a long time to get our food. Just tried «taco Tuesday» today and I would have rather had Taco Bell– no flavor and the beef tacos were so greasy they were inedible. We’ve been to the Scotty’s in West Lafayette and the service and food are better. Seems like this Scotty’s location may have management/​work flow issues. We will not be returning any time soon.

We’ve been at this location 3 times in person and we have done 3 carry out orders. Unfortunately, all three of our dining experiences at the restaurant were bad and they all progressively got worse, to the point that I has become a comedy of errors and we haven’t been there since October 2015 and won’t go back.
Two of our three carry out orders were okay until last night. They carefully opened every item in front of us, which was nice. But left out a buffaloes chicken dip and replaced it with broccoli. Which was discovered after our 10+ minute drive home. With people over sharing appetizers during the playoffs, it was infuriating that the employees continually make huge errors.
Dine here at your own risk and know you will most likely get poor customer service with a smile…

Good food, good variety, great waitress and fun atmosphere! However, after my cousin found a 4 inch piece of plastic bag in her mouth while eating her salad, I was a little disgusted. Accidents happen and we were told by the manager it was the distributors fault, I understand that. But don’t play the blame game, take responsibility. He removed a 99 cent charge on the bill and a drink. I’m not a person who goes looking for free meals but I am a business owner and know I would do more than expected to have my existing patrons and new customers at this table to walk away happy… more than a $ 5.99 credit. I expected more from Scottys.

Scotty’s is exactly what a great neighborhood restaurant should be — food that is consistent and consistently good, combined with a friendly and attentive staff. This is our GO-​TO place — I highly recommend giving it a try!

My husband and I had the worst service we’ve ever had at the Scotty’s Noblesville location. We dine out a lot and if there is a problem getting our order to us, we can be very understanding, if a server simply communicates with us. After she took our order, we were completely ignored by our server. We were seated in this big, cold room; We were served our drinks, our order was taken and our server never returned to our table. We saw her roaming around the bar area and she looked our way?! We waited at least 20+ minutes before we finally got up and left. The Carmel location isn’t much better. They’re definitely trained to push alcohol and I understand that. If that’s the reputation you want, then be a bar, not a bar/​restaurant. While we have alcohol with dinner, we rarely drink alcohol at lunch, but we always tip 20%, sometimes more! The owner needs to work on training his servers to be more professional. There are too many other places to dine. We won’t be going back.

A staple of the Indy area. Several locations to chose from. Always a good special for food and drinks. Happy Hour and late night discounts of apps. Wednesday is my favorite drinks special with the craft pitchers. The menu evolves and there are a wide range of choices. The burgers are a solid staple.

Great place to watch sports and drink beer. There’s a TV at every table, which is pretty awesome… their in house brewed beer is pretty good too.
The food was just okay. Burger patties are a good size and very tasty. I ordered naked wings with sauce on the side, but got the sauce on the wings. Wings also came out warm, not hot. Sauce for the wings was good though. Wings come with celery and carrots… I ordered extra carrots and got only carrots. Lakeside Mac n cheese was good, more like a pasta carbonara than anything.
Chili was terrible… which was surprising since the waitress told us it was a great choice. Potato soup was more like mashed potatoes… not very soupy at all.
Service was good, considering the other reviews said it was terrible. Waitress was very attentive and came to check on us several times.

Rudely treated grabbed a table the bar, waitress was rude when telling us we needed to get up because they were being seated by hostess only! No signs on tables in bar. Scotty’s at 96 street does not operate that way.

Not sure where/​when people are getting bad service but our’s was excellent. The food is the same great food we’ve come to love at Three Wise Men. Would be an amazing place to watch a game with tons of TVs. We were surprised it wasn’t more crowded. We’ll be back for sure!

I ordered the juicy Lucy lunch special. A juicy Lucy should be stuffed with cheese. This was just a cheeseburger. With that said, the burger was very good. I liked the bun. The chips and Mac and cheese were also very good. Service was excellent. I look forward to trying some of the other burgers but I just wished they would change the name on the lunch special so it is not misleading.
They also need disabled parking. There are none anywhere close to the entrance. Not sure how get away with violating the ADA.

We got a grilled cheese, but the cheese wasn’t melted, and a bison burger that was a total JOKE! The service was slow. This is sad because we were so hoping for a great new place to eat. we walked in and sat at the bar and probably sat there for 10 min before we were acknowledged, we had to ask if we could place our order… I could go on and on.

The space is great. Food is well above expectations. Great drink options. It seems the staff are having a frat party most of the time just inside the kitchen doors with no time to check if people would need to order food or drink. Three stars because this can be rectified.

I am glad to see Scotty’s open in this area. I stopped in for lunch with a friend the other day. We were seated immediately, staff was friendly, great atmosphere, waitress knocked it out of the ballpark, and the food was good. I plan to make several more visits.
We ate here again last night. We sat in the area of the bar. I love all the tv’s and atmosphere. The waitress was outstanding. We never had to flag her down for anything. We both had burgers and food quality was worth the cost. The only setback in the visit was that the music was extremely loud, but not a reason to avoid coming back!
Another visit after a movie last night. The service was great and the food was good. Great place to watch the Cubs Win!

I haven’t written a review this low in awhile. It makes me sad, but tonight was odd. I have been trying to eat out less and this place makes me want to do that more :/
So I entered, told the hostess I wanted to place a carry out order and would just go to the bar. The hostess told me to hang on. Got on a walkie-​talkie. I stood there for about 5 minutes before being given her blessing to go to the bar. Weird.
I go to the bar and am promptly greeted by the only person who exhibited good customer service. A red headed bartender who was trying to get out of there to head home to her daughter who was with her mother (the daughter’s grandmother). She was just hanging on past her shift as the other bartender was clearly in way over her head
She got me a water while I looked over the drink menu and told me the specials. She passed me along to another bartender with a Buckeyes necklace named Cassie. This is where it went horribly wrong.
It took probably 10 minutes to be asked for a drink and to-​go order.
It then took longer than that to get the drink. To tell you anything, she had to ask the red headed bartender how to turn on the blender… No joke.
I get the drink — S’mores martini. It was overflowing and when she set it down the marshmallow garnish fell off. She looked at it. Looked at me. And turned around.
No napkin.
You couldn’t pick it up without spilling it as it was melting over the sides just sitting there. So that was a problem.
No cocktail napkins around.
I figured I would just wait for her to come back. Only she never did.
Did she walk by me to get to other customers? Yes.
Did she walk by me to go to the back? Yes.
But never did she ask me if I was doing alright. If I needed a napkin. If I wanted another drink — I wanted to abandon my sloppy drink that made my hand sticky (which with no napkin was an issue) and order a glass of wine (and most servers and bartenders like increased bills… Because you know… Money). But was never offered or approached. Awful. She also seemed to ask other customers their names and refer to them. She never once asked mine. Only knew it at the end from my debit card.
I still tipped her well. Partially hoping it would go to the only helpful person I encountered — that red headed bartender. I doubt it will, but one can hope.
My food finally came out. I paid. Tipped. Left. And will likely never be back.
I truly believe how people treat single people at a restaurant says a lot. In this case it said, «we don’t want you here,» based on the nonexistent service.
Next time I will save my $ 53 and either go elsewhere or buy something at Anthropologie. It won’t be spent here.
Two stars as the food was good and the red headed bartender was nice despite her shift being over and still being stuck there.
I sincerely hope she gets part of that more than 20% tip. She is who earned it.

Came in Sunday evening, service was timely and polite. Food was good. Had the nachos as an appetizer — a lot of toppings, ground beef was quite good.
I had the burger — jokers wild. Not too spicy and I was able to get it medium rare. It was juicy and of good quality.
I would like a broader beer selection, 3 wise men is OK but there are many excellent choices sound there.

Great food. Horrible service. Fifteen minutes to get water and then we had to send our orders back three times and it still wasn’t right. All four of us got the same thing… how hard is that?!

Great new place. Love the atmosphere! The kids room is excellent. HD TV’s in every booth. Will be coming here quite often.

So happy to see they’re open. stopped for lunch had a great experience. service was very fast but fresh and all very good. server was through and we’ll trained on menu items. patient and will to explain all specials and all sauce choices. will be back.