A B C Pizza & Restaurant

Don’t waste your time. Might have been better if we ordered the pizza but we won’t be back.
Started off getting only two menus for our party of 4. Yes, two of us were kids (5 & 9) but they can read a menu and order for themselves. Then we were brought the wrong app. Server didn’t come back so that we could tell her til she was bringing our entrees which were seriously overpriced. I got the half Grilled Chicken Caesar salad, which I could’ve gotten a larger portion for a lesser price at a fast food chain. But, I like to support local business, hence this debacle. Chicken appeared to have been microwaved too long, definitely not fresh off the grill but there was plenty of dressing so I dug in only to be left with sand in my mouth after finally choking it down. One kiddo had the spaghetti and meatballs, more like meatball, singular. He wasn’t interested in finishing and after I took a bite I could understand why.
Other kiddo had the chicken nuggets and fries, tough to mess up frozen nuggets and fries but they were a huge portion, think we counted 15 nuggets so luckily our Mister meatball was able to share the slightly frostbitten chicken. Drench it in enough ketchup, they don’t notice anyway.
Hub had one of they totally lackluster sandwiches. At least the bread and butter were good and when we finally got our app, the fried trio was tasty even if there were only 3 mozz sticks.
Going to have to get a snack while running errands, leaving most unsatisfied.

I have been a customer of ABC pizza for my entire life and this has always been my most favorite pizza in the area. The pizza is unique, it’s not your typical «New York style» pizza. If you’re looking for traditional New York pizza– go to the hundreds of alternatives in the area. Abc stands out as my favorite for a number of reasons…
1. I lived in Brooklyn and NYC for about 7 years and of all the pizza I have ever had in my life there is nothing that tastes like this pizza. The sauce has a special zest and he crust has the most neutral flavor but just enough sweetness that it acts as a perfect compliment to the sauce.
2. The crust is crunchy on the outside and very soft and fluffy on the inside like a good bastone bread.
3. The pizza is not cut in triangles– it’s cut in squares and rectangles and is the most fun to eat!
I always ask for my pizza to be crispy– this makes the crust and cheese a little more crisp and delicious.
This place is Greek– I am told that this is normal for Greek pizza– but I never had Greek pizza anywhere else– so I am not sure.
Anyway, don’t come here if you’re looking for something traditional– it has been open longer than my 32 years of life and that says a lot a lot– considering how many places come and go around here. I love it!

Good penne ala vodka. Pizza is different. Not traditional. Service very friendly.

Horrible service and mediocre food
My husband and I had been trying out different pizza places and decided to order take out from ABC. They don’t deliver so I had to go pick it up. When they gave me the order of pizza, appetizers, and a dinner it was wrong. He said he would make me the correct dinner. I say down to wait and he left all my other food on the counter to get cold. 20 minutes later my correct dinner was ready. After I paid the bill (which was ridiculously expensive) I asked for extra blue cheese for my wings. The guy said it was 25 cents. I don’t mind paying for extra items but after waiting so long because of their mistake and my food getting cold on the counter I couldn’t believe they wouldn’t just give me a 25 cent cup of blue cheese. On top of l of this the pizza wasn’t even that good. And beware that it’s cut in squares like in the Midwest, it’s not normal NY slices.

This is the grossest pizza I ever had. How do you mess up white pizza? Their steak sandwiches are rubber and inedible. Everything has a ton of seasoning to cover up the bland taste. Skip it.

Great local restaurant for families, couples, friends, or groups. They’ve been in business for at least 20 years. I remember going here back as far as the early 1990s when they were in the plaza of what is now Destinta Theater. They have small booths in the front, a nicer dining area off to the side, and a large dining area in the back for group events. Their pizza is well known for their sauce, thin crust and square slices. They also have a full Italian restaurant which a large selection of food on the menu, as well as a variety of delicious deserts. The prices are very reasonable and the service has always been great for the 20+ years I’ve been eating here. This is a great, local restaurant dating back to the old, small-​town days of New Windsor.

Very good pizza and rigatoni a la vodka can be found here. You have to like garlic. The pizza itself is unique. It’s square cut with good cheese and very thick sauce that’s not too sweet. Prices are very good too. I recommend the place.