Would not recommend the chopped salad pizza… VERY soggy. Delivery also took a very long time.
Hungry F.
Classificação do local: 4 Franklin Square, NY
New ownership and they are very friendly and easy to talk to while you’re waiting. Pizza is very tasty and the specialty slices are very good. Prices are good. Definitely a repeat customer.
Erin D.
Classificação do local: 4 Mineola, NY
Great pizza! Thin crust and great sauce! I have been going here for years, it is my absolute favorite in the area!
Jay H.
Classificação do local: 5 Mineola, NY
Sorry VALENTINO’S This is gonna be short and sweet . These guys are UNDERNEWOWNERSHIP! last owner almost put it in the dump . Had bad service. delivery ppl were horrible Always a good slice(i think the same pizza guy still makes the pizza) BUTNOW? Def a great lil pizza shop! friendly guys. Excellent pizza! Thanks to the new owner =)
Andy X.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
Good Pizza with some friendly guys. Good prices. A review from some random PA guy who looks like he’s going to shoot up a school. Clearly has no idea what’s going on, probably with life in general. Will repeat.
Bobby B.
Classificação do local: 1 Honesdale, PA
You need to get off the island if you think this pizza is good. Doesn’t look delicious at all. Get dominoes instead.
Kelsi G.
Classificação do local: 4 Garden City, NY
A little bit of a hole in the wall, and not the nicest-looking place, but the pizza is always delicious and the service is always friendly. Can’t ask for much more.
Sau Lai H.
Classificação do local: 5 New Hyde Park, NY
The two brothers that run this place are great. It does suffer when they aren’t around though.
Simon P.
Classificação do local: 5 New York, NY
Wasn’t expecting to be in Long Island again so soon, but I was and ended up getting another pepperoni pie. Still delicious. Consistency is key.
Patricia M.
Classificação do local: 1 New Hyde Park, NY
The food is decent, but the service is not. We ordered food for delivery and the order was wrong when it was delivered. We called the restaurant and were told that they would give us the correct order, but that we would need to pick it up(even though we had it delivered in the first place). When we stated that, since it was their mistake, they should deliver the correct food, the person on the phone hung up on us. There are so many good pizza places in New Hyde Park/Garden City Park area, there is no need to order food from a place that has such poor customer service. If you cannot count on a place to rectify their mistakes(which are bound to happen), it is not worth ordering from that place.
George P.
Classificação do local: 4 West Hempstead, NY
I love this place for the following reasons: The food is great, the selection is great and the guys who work/own the place are great. This is the type of place where the people actually remember their customers and are very friendly and accommodating. I usually go for their Buffalo chicken pizza and grandma slices. Never a disappointment.
Sabu S.
Classificação do local: 4 Hicksville, NY
I love Valentino’s. The pizza and pasta is great.
Natalia D.
Classificação do local: 5 Mineola, NY
Amazing pizza ! good prices ! the ppl are friendly ! and don’t look miserable like MAMA theresas across the street! Fing hate them!
Ashlee C.
Classificação do local: 5 East Rockaway, NY
Really tasty pizza, and tons of options to be found at Valentino’s. I have tried a number of their specialty slices — buffalo chicken, barbecue chicken, bruschetta with chicken cutlets, eggplant parmigiana, baked ziti slice, and they have all been wonderful. I swear, they probably have between 10 – 12 different kinds of pizza to choose from if you go during the lunch or dinner hours. Plus, the counter help is super friendly and does not rush you(coughUmbertoscough) while you are trying to choose between the amazing slices. Highly recommended.