Cookie Rush

Have you ever been sitting around and really were craving a cookie and said to yourself, I wish there was a place that delivered cookies. Now your wish has come true.
This place is phenomenal. The variety of cookies they offer is impressive. They come hot and fresh & they are delicious.
These are gourmet cookies but not at gourmet prices. Whenever I am in the area, I have them delivered.

I am a person who prefers savory food over sweet food. So this wasn’t a place where I could appreciate much. The bake the cookies freshly. So they take 15 to 20 minutes to prepare your order. Luckily, they have a variety of card and board games to play while waiting. That kept us entertained until the order arrived. I shared a cookie sandwich with my friend. Had a chocolate chip cookie and a smores cookie with vanilla ice cream sandwiches in the middle. It’s not something to die for but just a place to hang out with friends and have something to go with the chit chat.

Why am I giving two stars? Because we’ve ordered cookies from here numerous times before and now they won’t deliver to our address. We are within their five mile delivery radius and they still won’t deliver to us anymore. I called and we were told the only reason we got deliveries in the past is because of a glitch in the delivery system. Great cookies but poor delivery service.

This place is absolutely fantastic. We placed a very big order to somewhere out of their delivery range and they had them there the next day by hand delivery. Cookies were absolutely delicious and every one is still raving about them! Jane is fantastic. Don’t hesitate to order! YUMMY!!!

Eh. I went here after a late night at Stuff Yer Face. Just had one chocolate chip cookie and a bite of the sugar cookie.
For me, it was just mediocre. I’m not a huge fan of sweets unless they’re amazing and for some reason, these don’t cut it for me. They just seemed like extremely sweet store bought cookies.
I get that they’d be a great treat for a student after a night out or even after a rough exam. The fact that you can get these delivered to your doorstep is a pretty great concept. I can see why this place does well at RU but it’s just not something I prefer. I think I’ll stick to Insomnia Cookies.

I’m slightly obsessed with this place. Unfortunately I found it because my dad is in the hospital and stumbled upon it while at a lunch place. Fresh baked cookies to go… And they deliver… Dream come true! I typically call in before picking up as it is about a 15 – 20 minute wait for baking… Completely worth it. If you don’t feel like waiting they also have some premade cookies and brownies. The last two times I was there they made smores brownies – with Graham cracker crumbles and lucky charms marshmallows. The workers are super nice as well.

So the concept of cookie rush is a good idea: get a fresh hot cookie RIGHT OUT OF THE OVEN. I was so excited when it first opened up near Rutgers.
However, after a night at the bars, I just don’t have the patience to wait 15 minutes for a cookie… I’ve heard that others feel the exact same way. Maybe if the cookies tasted truly homemade it would be worth the wait, but they taste like heated up cookies that you’d get at a supermarket.
My favorite part about Cookie Rush is that they have board games to play while you wait for your cookies.
Ultimately, for many college students that don’t have super high cookie standards, Cookie Rush is perfect for them! Ordering a takeout box of warm cookies is their heaven. However, I try to stay away from sugary cookies unless they’re amazing, and Cookie Rush just doesn’t cut it for me.

I also just called from Texas and ordered cookies to be delivered to some colleagues. John was so nice over the phone and helped make sure he had my order correct. They also were able to bake and deliver 50 cookies for me in 45 minutes (less than a cookie a minute :)!! My friends were raving on and on about the cookies and how they were still warm when they received them. Thankis for great service!!!

The cookies have the right amount of texture and sugar perfect for when you’re craving something sweet. Ryan provided great customer service, he was very helpful and knowledgeable about the menu. I highly recommend the cookies and cream cookie as well!

Fresh cookies at midnight? And they deliver? Whhhhaaatt? A cute place and a niche market but who doesn’t love fresh baked cookies. The cost adds up but what else would you really expect. The cookies are delicious and made to order although they usually have a few pre-​made if you are in a rush but the selection will be limited. Milk and cookies delivered to your house. Just awesome.

Smells delicious in here! They bake the cookies to order. I had a classic chocolate chip cookie and it was so good!!! They have some comfy couches and board games at your disposal and they DELIVER! Pretty cool for a college campus area!

WOW! Five stars!!! I called from Texas because I wanted to send someone cookies in NJ. Jane was so helpful and sweet on the phone. My cookie order was delivered in less than an hour after I placed the order and the cookie recipient was delighted.
Thanks so much, Cookie Rush!!!

Found a 12 for $ 13 deal on
and they were delivered right to my place hot and fresh. Loved the M&M’s and Reece’s cup cookies!

Was expecting this place to be more like a bakery than a made to order type place. That’s good because then all the cookies you order are fresh and warm.
So I order around 8 cookies and waiting about 15 minutes for them all to be done. I sat in their very comfortable love chair. It shapes to your body, if no one was there I would have fell asleep haha. By the time I arrived home they were still warm. My favorites were the cookies and cream, the chocolate chip, and the white chocolate macadamia nut. They are all super good but I think the cookies have way too much butter in them or even oil. The parchment paper that was underneath the cookies were soaked in grease it even sunk into the cardboard box. I was glad I finally tried the cookies though.

Warm and toasty cookies right to your door. First time ordering here, it was a good experience. Quick delivery. Accurate order, and cookies were fresh and delicious!

Awful customer service, crazy long wait time and incomplete orders make for a crappy experience. Don’t waste your time.
All I wanted was a cookie. Damn.

Cookies were good, but waiting 20 minutes for them not worth it. I think it would be quicker going to Stop & Shop, buy cookie dough, and baking them. And for the same price you would get so many more.
I understand the concept of baking the cookies only when ordered, but waiting 20 minutes for one cookie, no.

’twas the moment right after finishing my dinner, that the insatiable pang hit my belly. «Oh, I’ll have something sweet from my secret sugary stash,» I thought to myself. But I gasped as I saw that my treasure chest of cookie goodness was empty! The pang began to grow, the inner Cookie Monster urged me to Google restaurants that delivered anything with a sugar content higher than pizza. And that is when I discovered Cookie Rush. I called and spoke to an incredibly kind, knowledgeable, and sweet man who verbally walked me through his cookie haven inventory with intricate detail. I decided on several (it’s a $ 10 minimum for delivery, plus a 2 dollar delivery charge). The verdict:
1) Peanut butter Chocolate Chip = Meh, it wasn’t very rich. If you’re a PB fan, don’t expect too much from it.
2) Red Velvet = I thought it was good as soon as it was delivered. However, after it cooled and I tried some the next day it wasn’t very good. You could taste the dye.
3) Chocolate chip = it’s the thinnest cookie I ordered so it’s crispier than chewy like the others. Honestly, I was disappointed. This is my favorite kind of cookie and I asked for 3, but it did not woo me as I had hoped it would. They were on the drier side and really too thin.
4) Cookies and Cream = SURPRISINGLY, my favorite cookie. I wouldn’t usually go for this flavor, but apparently the cream cheese they use in the dough makes for a very soft and chewy cookie.
5) Gluten-​free = Now, they really need to change the name of this cookie to what it really is: The Sexy Chewy Chocolate made-​love-​to-​a Moist Succulent Coconut Cookie. Pssh, gluten-​free…
Also got some extra free frozen dough since it was my first time ordering. Thanks nice guy on the phone! GREAT service! Cookies are hit or miss, and it really depends on your palette and preference. Keep in mind that these cookies are not as heavy on the sugar as we may expect from the average American cookie, which I appreciated. Oh and the delivery time is long (as in an hour), so just order early.

My friend and I have had good experiences with cookie rush – I’ve found my cookies to taste pretty good.
But I’m comparing this to places like Insomnia Cookie (Philly), which are cookie bakers catering to late night college students. In this, I do give Cookie Rush a solid 4 stars.
Is this a gourmet cookie shop? No. But it’s in a college town, catering to college kids, and they’re a new business.
I appreciate the board games in-​store while you wait for your cookies to bake, and that they’re up when we’re out at bars or studying in our dorms craving homebaked goodies. I’ve been to a couple Rutgers events that have also had Cookie Rush cater and they tasted great. I’ve tried peanut butter, cookies & cream, coconut chocolate, and others.
The business is pretty new so I excuse the pizza box delivery (it’s cute in it’s own way), and the lacking atmosphere. Let them get settled, and we’ll see to those minor things. The important stuff (cookies!) are worth trying.

Me want cookies!
Pretty excited to see a cookie place on Easton Avenue. They bake cookies on the spot so place your order before heading there or be prepared to wait a few minutes. You can also have them delivered to your door! Awesome!
I haven’t had any issues with service or anything. The décor in their establishment could use some more personality. While it’s clean and modern, it’s not as fun or delicious as their cookies.
Try any cookie from their menu. Everyone’s a winner!