Crossroads II Pizza & Subs

usually good but this time the pizzas were, like, not fully cooked. had to put them in the oven at home to finish them off. weird.

Very few places are perfect, but this pizza comes close! I think a more accurate rating would be 4.5 stars, but only because the fries we ordered were a bit soggy after being delivered. The pizza itself was delicious! I am usually a thin crust gal, but I am so glad we went with the house crust. Crispy with a good amount of chewiness. The toppings were plentiful and fresh! Will definitely order again. Support local!

Good carryout pizza. I would say 2^nd best pizza in New Berlin that I have tasted. We will purcase pizza from Crossroads again.

Great pizza. House crust is the best. Love the cheesy garlic bread, too. Delivery is fast and reliable.
Crossroads is a great community supporter, too. We sold Crossroads Pizza at our Scout carnival. Thank you, Crossroads!

We love crossroads! We order about once a month and couldn’t be happier. It’s a great neighborhood pizza place.

We’ve ordered from Crossroads since it opened. The subs are good, the pizza is outstanding. We usually order salad too; share one as they are as big as they are good. Basic salad but very good. Crossroads pizza is a must-​have for my adult children, who now live far away. Beware that this is not a dine-​in spot; carry out or delivery, only. Also know that on televised game-​days there may be a bit of a wait. Otherwise, they can be surprisingly fast. It’s well worth any wait. We compare all other pizza to Crossroads.

Get the house hand thrown crust, sausage is awesome. No credit cards! Don’t order the meatball sub, they have ham and rolls on Sunday morning.

This place is close to our home and if we’re in the mood for pizza we pick up or have delivered. The pizza is very tasty and they always get our order correct which for some reason other pizza places have a very hard time with (I don’t get it… sausage on all, one half mushrooms the opposite side onions… it’s not that hard people…) Under $ 20 for a large. Last time I went to pick up and actually saw their menu. The have alot of sandwiches on the menu that look to be pretty tasty and well priced. I’d like to try those sometime. Nice delivery staff and friendly at the counter too.

My favorite pizza in the whole world including Italy!

Great pizza delivery joint. Tasty thin pizza with a lot of steaming, flavorful sauce. Tasty, fresh ingredients.

This is such a ubiquitous Wisconsin thing. You know a place like it – they exist all over. An out of the way business with a subdivision built around it. Sometimes it’s a bar, sometimes an eatery, sometimes a takeout food place — each of which can just blow you away with it’s surprising fare — nothing fancy but oh so yum!
Crossroads is just such a place — a take out eatery. I drove past this place daily for nearly a year but never stopped in. This time, in search of something different than the usual chains, I decided to stop. I am so glad I did. The pizza and wings were extraordinary.
The pizza comes with a traditional crust (or thin crust) but is loaded with toppings that make each bite of pizza a meal in itself. Seriously. The small pizza was so heavy I though I had the wrong order. The wings were nicely cooked and flavorful but between the wings and the pizza there was enough food for a couple of more meals. That’s okay though — cold pizza and cold wings are just as tasty.
I look forward to stopping by here again next time I’m in the area. There’s nothing like this place where I am now. It’s making me appreciate all the things I took for granted. sigh.