Mancino’s Samuel

My wife and I had not been to a Mancino’s in several years, and had never been to the one in Nappanee Indiana. Our daughter had never been to any of them so with her loving «breadsticks and pizza» we figured we would give it a shot once again.
Best choice this year! We split a small pepperoni pizza, calzone, and breadsticks with cheese and pizza sauce. All were extremely well made and tasty. Service was great and fairly quick for fresh made food. We topped it off with more carbs in the form of the Cinna Bites and those were yummy as well.
We will definitely be back to the Mancino’s in Nappanee Indiana. Keep up the good work.

Pizza is undercooked and soggy. Toppings are barely there. A true Italian would never let this pass as food

Visiting a friend who works at Amish Acres. Really liked the personal pizza with breadsticks and a drink for $ 6. Good pizza and great breadsticks at a good price!

If you check in you get free breadsticks… BONUS!!!The grinders are very tasty. I got the Italian with extra mushrooms and double meat. It is a lot of food for the money and I can get two meals out of it. I don’t know what kind of mayonnaise they have but it is the best! I don’t have a Mancino’s in AZ so I always have to stop when back in IN.

This place is open. Per the management, it closed for a little while last winter and re-​opened in 2014. Mancino’s is always great. Love their pizza, their grinders and their breadsticks.
This visit we got the breadsticks (always!), kids’ pizza, chef salad and Stromboli grinder. They have garlic butter which was really good. The salad was surprisingly good. The grinder and pizza and breadsticks are always good and lived up to expectations. I heartily recommend Mancino’s for the pizza, grinder and breadstick fan.

This place has some really good food, like the smothered steak grinder (my personal fav) and the cinna bites; only reason I give it 3 stars: I’ve only eaten there like 5 times, but on two desperate occasions they’ve messed up my order. I’m not talking «oh darn they forgot to take the onions off» I’m talking… no sugar on the cinna bites, which isn’t a criminal offense, but they were so disgusting I wasn’t gonna let that one slip by. They were however very apologetic about that one and replaced them no problem.
The place is fairly clean and nice, nothing to write home about, but the food is good and relatively quick, it’s a little pricey but I’m willing to pay it (8 $ for a full grinder). I’d just recommend checking your order before you leave the parking lot if you’re taking it to go.

Apparently a regional chain, this Mancino’s (not «Mancino’s Samuel» as the current Unilocal business title indicates, alluding to a Samuel owned by a Mancino) is a small pizza joint in a town otherwise seemingly devoid of decent non-​Amish-​style dining. I mean, if you want Amish-​style, then you have your pick elsewhere.
Aside from Grandma Samuel (I don’t know her real name, but she seemed to be a pleasant woman and that’s what I’m calling her) writing my name down wrong and then walking by me with my order while she looked for a woman to bring it to, it was a really good meal. And cheap. $ 6.20 with tax for a personal 1-​topping pizza, two breadsticks and a soda. The breadsticks in any combo can be subbed for chips or a garden salad. And they have a number of combos available; not just pizza.
I really enjoyed that pizza. The sauce was excellent. Good amount of food, too.
They also have free wifi. Ask for the password. How often do you find that in an Amish town?